6 ms·
While my eBook library is pretty something, the storage costs to rip my movie library onto hard drives would be cost prohibitive. I do keep physical discs of th
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
While my eBook library is pretty something, the storage costs to rip my movie library onto hard drives would be cost prohibitive. I do keep physical discs of the movies I really enjoy, and generally only buy digital during sales. Most of the "value" in my digital movie collection comes from digital copy redeems.
Vudu does $5 sales all the time, and the way I see it, that's less than a movie ticket. So if I see it once, it was like going to see a movie, but with the theoretical hope of long-term persistence. The fact that MA insulates the risk of losing your titles across every major tech company adds to the comfort level now too, and as noted, nobody is losing their UV library when UV shuts down.
- beagle3 8y agoDVDs are usually less than 5GB. 1TB drives cost $40 these days, less if amortized over larger disks. Which means $100 buys you enough disk space for two redundant copies of 200 movies assuming you vobcopy them; about twice or thrice if you convert to h264 or h265 or av1; and half again if you have BD quality rips. That’s about 50cents/movie for two copies, half if you only keep one. Is this really prohibitive?
- olliej 8y agoI assume people with blue ray want to rip at original quality - isn’t that 10s of gig per disk? (I have never bought blue ray so have no idea). For me the problem was ripping my dvds just took so long, and wasn’t automatable (weirdly my bottom of the line Mac mini struggles with re-encoding ;) )
- loeg 8y agoYep, Blu-rays can store something like 25GB per layer; industry standard for movies is dual layer (50GB). Rips can achieve comparable quality with lower bitrate than used on the original disk. Blu-ray dates to 2006 and (typically) uses inefficient high bit-rate H.262 ("MPEG 2", which DVDs used), H.264 (AVC), or VC-1. Rips can use high-efficiency H.265 ("HEVC"). Typical for a 1080p H.265 encoding is 9-15 GB. (Lower for animated films.) UHD Blu-rays do use the more efficient H.265 already, but are much higher resolution as well. I'm not sure how prevalent they are.
- bscphil 8y agoThe vast majority of newer Blurays use H.264, which is pretty efficient (much more than the other two). In addition, if you're just wanting to back up the film, and not any special features on the disk, at least half of films fit in 25 GB with no reencoding required. One big downside of reencoding in HEVC is that for a moderate gain in compression (0-50% depending on the film), you considerably increase your playback requirements. I use a Raspberry Pi 3 with Kodi as a playback device, and it's not capable of playing 1080p HEVC videos. UHD Blurays are getting more common. They usually come on 66 GiB disks, and it's becoming more common to let the video take up most of that, and bundling a second disk of special features if necessary. So even backing up the main feature of a UHD can easily run you 50+ GiB.
- loeg 8y ago> The vast majority of newer Blurays use H.264, which is pretty efficient (much more than the other two). Right; still quite a bit less efficient than H.265, though. > One big downside of reencoding in HEVC is that for a moderate gain in compression (0-50% depending on the film), you considerably increase your playback requirements. Yes, although this is becoming less true as more hardware offload support becomes available. For example, Nvidia 750, 950-960, and 1030 are all capable of HEVC offload[1]. The latter can be had new for ~$85; the others are probably a bit harder to find but given they're older midrange cards at this point maybe they're a little cheaper. > So even backing up the main feature of a UHD can easily run you 50+ GiB. Sure, I don't think there's any economical way to reduce storage requirements of UHD significantly without defeating the point. On the other hand, I don't think the extra pixels really matter as much as higher color depth (10 or 12 bit) and fewer artifacts at lower resolution, unless you've got a home IMAX or something. [1]: https://developer.nvidia.com/video-encode-decode-gpu-support-matrix https://developer.nvidia.com/video-encode-decode-gpu-support...
- 013a 8y agoDepends on the movie and if its 1080p or 4K, but generally I anticipate a ripped Bluray to be around 60gb. Re-encoding them is a PITA as well. Even on a HEDT gaming desktop with a brand new CPU, the process only proceeds at 8-10fps, if that, so at least 2x movie runtime. Maybe there are some ways to involve the video card which can speed it up, but I haven't tried it. And even if you want to and can keep the originals, you'll want to re-encode it and keep both; most Plex clients (think: Apple TV, shitty laptop, etc) simply can't handle raw 4K bluray playback.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoffmpeg supports a variety of hardware encoders but supposedly the quality will be worse than a CPU-encoded video at the same bitrate
- michaelmrose 8y agoPirated 4k videos are often 7-15GB. I presume this is optimized for size over maximum quality.
- jumelles 8y agoThat seems too small IMO. Encoded BD rips average about 20-30 GB; remuxes (no compression/encoding) begin around 50 GB.
- cortesoft 8y agoHow big is your movie library and what would you consider cost prohibitive? Hard drives are pretty cheap these days.
- opencl 8y agoHow many movies do you have? A 5TB hard drive is slightly over $100 and will hold a minimum of 100 Blu-ray rips, assuming they use the entire disk capacity and you don't reencode them to something smaller.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoWell, for one, hard drives also fail. So I need backups, unless I want to have to sit and re-rip everything when it happens. I'm a big fan of RAID 1 since I don't have horrific rebuilds, and I offsite my data as well. (Most of my data is stored on five hard drives currently.) So take your estimate drive costs and start multiplying. Second, my Vudu library contains over 600 movies and significantly more television shows than that. And before you calculate the cost of the storage, bear in mind there's another, secondary cost: The much higher cost I'd have spent to have built that library solely on ripped discs. I never paid full price for a digital purchase. (And specifically, never more than it would've cost to acquire it via disc.) Third, time. I'm also significantly backlogged in organizing my ebooks, which I do store on drives. Blu-ray ripping time just isn't something I want to dedicate a big chunk of my life to.
- scarface74 8y agoBackblaze is $5 a month for unlimited storage. If your hard drive fails, you can order a hard drive with your data.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoYou better store encrypted if you're pirating movies/music. It's rather easy to get TOS'ed even if you match filenames of common pirate name signatures.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoLuckily passive commercial scanners don't require much; tossing it into an encrypted zip with everything set to fastest still runs over everything passive that's not nationstate
- mark-r 8y agoWhen my kids were little and basically destroyed anything they touched, I started ripping their DVDs. Now there's over 200 of them on my media center PC. I had to upgrade from a 1GB to a 3GB disk at one point, but there's still plenty of room for more.
- eponeponepon 8y agoI thought cost was a blocker too till I actually sat down and worked it out. A cheap microserver with about 15TB of disk space came in well under the thousand pound mark - the real blocker is sitting down and actually ripping the things. There's a trade-off between space and encoding quality to be made, but I'm entirely happy with libx265's results at 1080p. Obviously your mileage may vary as to what's a reasonable cost.
- LeifCarrotson 8y ago> The storage costs to rip my movie library onto hard drives would be cost prohibitive The storage costs as well as streaming transmission costs are not only borne by but also provide profit to the provider. If they can profit off them, you can hopefully at least break even!
- ecpottinger 8y agoYou must be kidding. I bought two external 4TB for less than $130 CDN each.