24 ms·
Stealing the Enemy's Urban Advantage: The Battle of Sadr City
- oriol11 8y agoLooking forward to the next peaceful discussion about Middle East conflicts
- gilbetron 8y agoIn the day of fluff blog/medium posts, it's great to see something like this with it's incredible detail and exhaustiveness. I'll always be amazed that one of the main weapons in modern times is concrete. I worked for years as a contractor (geeky contractor, not merc-like contractor) for the DoD and it is fascinating to read this in-depth coverage of battle zones.
- ucaetano 8y ago> I'll always be amazed that one of the main weapons in modern times is concrete Oh, not just modern times. It was the same in Roman times as well, and when concrete was not available (either before, or after the Romans), rocks wood and earth would do the job!
- ranie93 8y agoThis article linked in OP's submission has more information on the role of concrete in modern battlefields https://mwi.usma.edu/effective-weapon-modern-battlefield-concrete/ https://mwi.usma.edu/effective-weapon-modern-battlefield-con...
- yread 8y agoDiscussed quite a bit here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776
- adolph 8y agoTwo previous HN discussions: The Most Effective Weapon on the Modern Battlefield Is Concrete (2016): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18651154 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18651154 The Most Effective Weapon on the Modern Battlefield Is Concrete (usma.edu): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776
- caf 8y agoIt did make me wonder why JAM didn't use some of their rocket / IED teams to attack the concrete batching plants.
- allen37 8y agoI had the "pleasure" of participating in these events as an 18 year old infantryman. Living in an outpost with a generator and no running water, tightly nestled away between AQI and JAM. Mortars in the morning, IED or two in the day, and skirmishes at night while the engineers brought in the T-walls. Character building, to say the least.
- elteto 8y agoIt was a fascinating and terrifying read. I’m glad you made it out.
- hart_russell 8y agoThank you for your service.
- jseliger 8y agoHave you read Sebastian Junger's book Tribe? If not, you likely should; I found it very interesting but cannot speak to some of his reporting on and experience with the military in Iraq and Afghanistan.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- psychedelic 8y agoNice to see I'm not the only 11B on hackernews. I was there as well from Nov 07 - Feb 09. Spent most of my days at Hope/SUJ. Had the "pleasure" of months of fighting and helping with the T-walls on route Aeros. Good times.
- throwaway713824 8y agoMy ETS date was June 2002, I was a 19k (tank crewman). My first day as a civilian I swore into the Air Force reserve. Word was they were stop holding tankers and calling them back in. No effing way I was going to war with the low lifes and criminals I served with in tank platoons in the late 90s. I understand recruiting did a lot better after 9/11, more motivated people. All I knew was if the Air Force has me the Army couldn’t get me. Peace brother.
- ucaetano 8y ago> Tanks began to fire 120-millimeter canister rounds (in essence, shotgun-type rounds that, once fired, open into hundreds of tiny pieces) down streets from their main guns. The canister rounds blew the trash off the streets and, in many cases, exploded IEDs lying in wait for the patrol. The interesting part that most people don't think about (and is extremely relevant in a MOUT setting) is the pressure shock coming out of a main gun, which can be deadly for up to 200m: The overpressure from the tank 120-mm cannon can kill a marine found within a 90-degree arc extending from the muzzle of the gun tube out to 200 meters. (Marines MOUT Manual) When firing it down a narrow, building-lined corridor, the effect can be far longer, and even without the canister shot it would likely be enough to clear a large section of the street.
- howard941 8y ago> Tanks began to fire 120-millimeter canister rounds (in essence, shotgun-type rounds that, once fired, open into hundreds of tiny pieces) down streets from their main guns. Are the resulting pieces effectively flechettes but lawful?
- iaw 8y agoI'm sorry, but where aren't flechettes lawful? Canister rounds, from my knowledge, result in ball projectiles (ballistic flight) while flechettes are finned (aerodynamic flight).
- howard941 8y agoI didn't think they were lawful but this book review says I was mistaken: https://www.lawfareblog.com/deadly-metal-rain-legality-flechette-weapons-international-law-eitan-barak https://www.lawfareblog.com/deadly-metal-rain-legality-flech...
- celticninja 8y agoI thought that using plastic flechettes was illegal because you can't x-ray to find and remove them.
- edraferi 8y ago> [JAM] Snipers would also shoot at the crane cable or the lone soldier that was forced to climb a ladder to unhook each concrete wall. Special operations forces snipers were extremely useful in a counter-sniper role. Nevertheless, there were situations where confirmed snipers and fighters that could not be engaged by US snipers had to be targeted with air-delivered, precision-guided bombs or Guided Multiple Launch Rocket System (GMLRS) rounds that could penetrate the buildings’ layers of concrete. One instance that required a concrete-penetrating option was when a JAM sniper occupied and fortified one of the few five-story buildings north of the Gold Wall was being constructed and at a key intersection where he was able to engage the wall-building team. Direct fire placed on the building did not affect the sniper’s fortified position. 1-68 CAB’s solution was to drop the building using the GMLRS. But for the duration of the Battle of Sadr City, coalition forces used fewer than three mortar or artillery fire missions because of the risk of collateral damage, the prospect of injuring civilians, and the potential political ramifications both locally for the government of Iraq and internationally for political support to the coalition forces. Don't bring a sniper rifle to a combined-arms fight, I suppose. It's interesting & typical of modern war that the politics of the fight constrain the weapons choice much more than the tactical situation.
- mathdog 8y agoI love sugar
- Spearchucker 8y agoA more prudent stategy, I think, would have been for the sniper to change position. As they say in the military - proper planning prevents piss-poor performance.
- skrebbel 8y ago> had to be targeted with air-delivered, precision-guided bombs or Guided Multiple Launch Rocket System (GMLRS) rounds that could penetrate the buildings’ layers of concrete. Wow, I'm very not used to reading military text. They write "a concrete-penetrating option" but they mean "we blew up the building and everybody inside it". I truly wonder how many innocent lives could be saved if military people would start writing honestly.
- ranchpredictor 8y agoCadr city
- dmead 8y agoalways gross to see the military posting on social media like it's nothing.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoWhat is interesting is how certain techniques in warfare are conserved. Reading about how a concrete wall was constructed to hem in the opposing forces and force their capitulation in 2008, brought to my mind the Battle of Alesia in 52 BC by Julius Caesar (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Alesia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Alesia). In that battle, as in the battle for Sadr City, the Romans were constrained from a direct assault on the city. The Romans built a wall surrounding the city, cutting off the enemy from supplies. Eventually, the Celtic warriors inside the city were forced to try to attack the Roman wall and were defeated (as was a relieving force trying to attack the Romans from the other side). The Celtic leader Vercingetorix surrendered (he was taken to Rome as a prisoner and eventually strangled), and this cemented Julius Caesar's reputation as a brilliant commander. That these two battles separated by over 2000 years and with completely different weaponry, still share the same basic plot, is to my mind amazing.
- AceJohnny2 8y agoSounds like the Battle of Alesia was a conventional siege, whereas Sadr City was, well, "urban warfare", a battle to weed out the rebels from lived-in neighborhoods.
- NovaS1X 8y agoThe Battle of Alesia wasn't a conventional siege in the sense that the defenders weren't behind a wall to defend themselves from open attackers, but the attackers were behind the walls using it against the defenders. The wall is offensive in this context, as a type of blockade, instead of a defensive structure. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investment_(military) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investment_(military)
- 24gttghh 8y agoThis is mentioned in the article: "Operation Gold Wall employed medieval siege warfare tactics with a twist. Instead of a city’s population withdrawing behind castle walls to wait out the besieging army, coalition forces brought a modern version of a siege engine up to the edge of JAM’s safe haven and built a wall around the enemy. This was very similar to the ancient tactic of circumvallation, an example of which was seen when Julius Caesar built a twelve-foot-high, eleven-mile wall around Alesia to defeat 60,000 Gauls in 52 BC."
- ranie93 8y agoThe comments on the NYT article linked in this submission are interesting to say the least. https://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/04/20/baghdads-great-wall-of-adhamiya/ https://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/04/20/baghdads-great-...
- ducktypegoose 8y agoGood god just thinking about the resources and costs behind what this report describes is staggering. If the collaborative insight, intelligence, engineering, planning, and... just... human effort poured into this microcosm was directed towards building something, what would we have? Probably something a lot more useful than a ruined city and a bunch of graves.
- kungtotte 8y agoYou're making the mistake of thinking that this amount of resources and effort was available in some kind of global pool to be allocated to anything, anywhere. The truth is that aside from maybe the human effort this would've gone to some other war or battle or simply be left unspent. If, on the other hand, you're making the observation that war and violence sucks and that humanity would ultimately be better off if we tried to work together. Then absolutely I'm behind you 100%.
- Noumenon72 8y agoThe "global pool to be allocated to anything, anywhere" is called the economy. When concrete is not needed for walling people in, Iraqi concrete factories don't work extra shifts. The people who would have had to work there become employed at other jobs. In the short term, a soldier who doesn't have to neutralize Sadr City probably does get assigned to some other war mission. In the medium term, his unit is not called up again and he returns to auto mechanic or whatever other productive thing he can do. He puts his effort into raising kids instead of raising barriers. War does have an opportunity cost.
- bmer 8y agoSome ideas: * multi-storey farms, with "JIT" food production: lots of our food production is wasted, what if we streamlined it, by locating food production centers closer to population centers? Homeless people/other "undesirables" could be given some work maintaining a food production source they can be proud of (availability high tech solutions for various problems, lunch and learns with power point presentations and fancy marketing speak, rapid solution iteration by close interaction between (think, same office) engineers and green-collar food workers) * traditional farms will keep their roles as is, but will have attached to them food preservation facilities, so that they can build stockpiles for when JIT fails us (natural disasters, etc.), and also be able to sell preserved stockpiles in general as special foods in supermarkets (bunch of "culinary engineering" will have to be done to take traditional preservation methods which have tasty output, and mass-produce it, or better yet, come up with new methods (with tastier output)) * public washrooms with automated cleaning facilities (janitors who maintain the washrooms are inducted into a 24 month MOS on mechanical design and robot construction---they don't need to be become experts on the physics, just aware of the possibilities so that they can combine their experience with this knowledge to come up with designs for engineers to construct, and are then responsible for testing in the field, and iterating on design) * people who are willing to take risks exploring (maybe again, many "homeless" people/undesirables) could be recruited into fancy programs with the goal of most expansive deep sea exploration to date: mountains of geological, biological, meteorological data for scientists to explore; plus, an excellent training ground for deep space exploration (hostile outdoor environment, massive pressure differentials making structural design complicated) * programs which involve the "mentally disabled" (think Down's syndrome, or other "obviously mentally deficient" illnesses) not in order to study them as "specimens" to be kept in the confines of their home, or a nursing home, but by involving psycholgists/neuroscientists to work with them in order to figure out the answer to: "sure, they suck at XYZ, is there anything they truly excel at? are there jobs/work/problems that other humans dislike doing which the "disabled" enjoy doing extremely, and are particularly well suited for? are there surprises regarding their capabilities (i.e. could it be that certain illnesses make you extremely good at certain types of mental tasks, which we don't know of because we simply don't interact with such people enough)? * similar to last point, except for elderly, rather than treating them as old junk---figuring out ways to take advantage of their experience, for their benefit, and that of humanity * fusion reactors * deep space asteroid-mining * energy storage research * UI research
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoAs late as 2010, when I was involved in the OIF transition to "New Dawn," Sadr City was still basically a no mans land, and was the bulk of where the "bad shit" would happen when it came to IED makers, smugglers, planners and other AQI activity. Some absolute horrors in what is effectively a tiny square Suburb.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ham_sandwich 8y agoUrban combat tactics are fascinating. I’m reminded of this post that explains how the IDF in the early 2000s would try to “walk through walls” in urban combat. It also discusses how the film ‘Die Hard’ is a study of architecture. [0] The underlying essay referenced in the post is brief and interesting as well, discussing how those urban tactics were influenced by postwar French thought, in particular the ideas of Deleuze & Guattari. [0] http://www.bldgblog.com/2010/01/nakatomi-space/ http://www.bldgblog.com/2010/01/nakatomi-space/
- AWildC182 8y agoIn terms of military doctrine, one thing that really struck me recently was learning that urban areas are considered similarly to mountain ranges and water from a theater-maneuvering point of view. Your tanks will get bogged down in a town just as fast as if you tried to drive them through a swamp. With the rise of increasingly large urban centers, a modern conflict could be very different than the second world war... At least until the slaugherbots are perfected :P
- jandrese 8y agoUrban combat is terrifying. In an open field a tank is pretty hard to counter since they can see further and shoot better than a person. It's very hard to hide, especially from IR. In a city there is almost an uncountable number of places for someone to hide and launch an ambush. They can get extremely close to a target without being detected, which opens up a lot of options for anti-tank warfare. They can also block paths extremely easily (with say a dried up cement truck) and neutralize combat vehicles. They also have a good idea of where you will be when planting IEDs, unlike in a wide open field.
- azernik 8y agoOne big lesson of the Libyan and Syrian Civil Wars was that, in an even close-to-symmetric war, large urban areas modified for military use are more effective than purpose-built fortifications for defense.
- secfirstmd 8y ago
- AceJohnny2 8y ago> Their only warning was when their garbage wasn’t picked by a contracted trash collector at the same time it typically was each week. When they called him, he was adamant that he was not coming. "Some of you guys are cool. Don't go to <blank> tomorrow" I wonder what other kinds of "canary" one can setup in such a situation.
- psychedelic 8y agoI was an infantryman in a outpost on the east side of Sadr city. There was only a few platoons at this place at a time. I was on guard that morning and all of the sudden there was a mass migration of all males leaving the area. It was so surreal. Most of them were just clearing out because they knew shit was about to go down and they didn't want to be around for it when it did. But seeing thousands of people just walk from their neighborhoods was crazy.
- starpilot 8y agoWar is fascinating.
- jimkri 8y agoReally interesting read. Lately I have been researching GIS Data and CRE Data. The military has to have a tool to do this, but what if you could have a live video feed that would watch for muzzle flashes or tracer rounds. When they are spotted you can try to pinpoint the location and add a layer of Building information to track the locations and all the risks associated with going into those areas. I wonder what researchers are doing for the military and if they are applying graph theory to these types of problems (or other things that I don't know about yet) and what tech they are using to help the people on the ground.
- donavanm 8y agoWRT detection triangulation based off sound is both effective and wide spread. Search for “shot spotter” in use in many cities in a civillian context. For military threat modeling you may be interested in the human intelligence exploitation (HET) teams in afghanistan and itaq. Theyre compound teams pulling in disparate specialists (like sociologists) to study, model, and report on an area. And yes, thats aggregated up through battalion intelligence for tactical use.
- jimkri 8y agoOh wow HET is really interesting, I never knew or thought about that type of work, thanks for the information! Do you know if most jobs in HET/HUMINT are for Military personnel only?
- donavanm 8y agoNo. They pulled in both other intelligence agency officers and more traditional civilian subject matter experts. Results were mixed with strong opinions on both sides. Check out the Human Terrain projects http://ssi.armywarcollege.edu/pdffiles/pub1308.pdf http://ssi.armywarcollege.edu/pdffiles/pub1308.pdf
- secabeen 8y agoSadr City feels like a current, slightly-less-dense version of Kowloon Walled City.
- politician 8y ago> The role and effectiveness of concrete in reducing violence across Baghdad cannot be understated. Concrete barriers had been used throughout Iraq for years to reduce the threat of improvised explosive devices (IEDs) emplaced along major roads. But during the surge, concrete barriers were widely used to limit the enemy’s ability to maneuver freely across Baghdad. The first surge unit in Thawra District, 2nd Brigade Combat Team, 82nd Airborne Division, led by Col. Billy Don Farris, emplaced over thirty miles of concrete barriers. One of the first uses of concrete was to protect the Adhamiya neighborhood by building a three-mile wall around it—which would earn a nickname: the “Great Wall of Adhamiya.” > The barriers used to form the walls were named after American states to denote their progressive size. The smallest, Jersey barriers (three feet tall; two tons), were used to block roads and slow traffic approaching checkpoints. Medium to large barriers—Colorado (six feet tall; 3.5 tons), Texas (six feet, eight inches tall; six tons), and Alaska (twelve feet tall; seven tons)—were used to construct checkpoints and protective walls around markets, mosques, and other areas where crowds were being targeted by bombs and shootings. The Texas barrier, due to its width and ease of transport, among other reasons, was predominately used to create the safe neighborhoods. But it was the massive T-walls that were used to create coalition and ISF bases and to maximize protection and prevent infiltration. Similar in size to Alaska barriers, the massive twelve-foot-tall, six-ton T-wall, with its interconnecting edges, created an effective barrier. Curious how folks interpret these statements as reinforcing or undermining their positions on the US Border Wall debacle. Is it a possibility that POTUS, upon hearing reports similar to this from Iraq, might be likely to want to reuse the approach? Conversely, why is this effective in Iraq? Can opposition forces not build tunnels or lay ladders over these walls?
- pchristensen 8y agoI think a given person's interest in building a wall is highly correlated with how much of a threat they see Mexican/Central American immigration. If you've ever used the phrase "caravan", then you probably think it's a severe problem that calls for drastic measures to protect America. If you've ever used the phrase "net-migration", you probably think those immigrants are not a threat, to life or economy, and you think that using violence and fortification against them is racist. From what I understand from reading a lot of stuff (including Sebastian Junger's book War), the barriers were needed because of regular and persistent attacks with bombs and gunfire, and I haven't heard even the most alarmist pro-wall person claim that level of violence from illegal immigrants. 99% Invisible just released an episode about the tunnels used in smuggling drugs from Mexico into the US - https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-tunnel/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-tunnel/. Basically, the tunnels cost $1-2M or more but paid off in a matter of weeks. Getting past concrete barriers in Iraq may have been strategically valuable but didn't have a business model. I would imagine that climbing the barriers puts you in a very undefended position for at least a couple minutes.
- AcerbicZero 8y agoI've always loved history, especially military history, however this is the first time I've read an article in this format regarding events I was actively involved with. I spent my formative years of 2006-2008 involved in OIF, and again in 2009-2010, and reading this has been both humbling and surreal. This article reads like a classic WWII historical analysis of some specific battle, and its kind of amazing that can even be done for this, because the way I remember most of my time during OIF, the whole thing was a jumbled mess of Army politics, confusion, and misinterpretation.
- hart_russell 8y agoThanks for your service.
- AcerbicZero 8y agoI never know what to say to that, but thank you for saying it :)
- Animats 8y agoThis article reads like a classic WWII historical analysis of some specific battle This was a very WWII kind of battle.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoI guess that gives valuable perspective on how reliable the ww2 accounts are. I think any account of military events that doesn’t honestly recount the actual confusion on the ground is rather suspect. One would hope that higher levels of command always think of how uncertain all information they get from lower levels is, but reading accounts of events written in this dead certain and authorative voice is a bit worrying. Only the number of enemy casualities hints at the uncertain state of basically all combat accounts.
- sgt101 8y agoA great and important essay. A classic.
- oskkejdjdkjd 8y agothis website is supposed to benefit American military academics and by extension the interests of the United States. But posting these lessons and insights publicly advances all nations equally, including our enemies. Wouldn’t it make more sense to keep all this stuff within the US military?
- nexuist 8y agoSome armchair philosophy (I have absolutely no valid credentials to justify the following points, but might be interesting to consider): Similar could be said about allowing the free press to report on the government's deficiencies (Presidential scandals, bureaucratic mistakes, internal strife, Snowden, etc.) One of the founding principles of a liberal democracy is that freedom to access information enables far more people to make far more attempts to innovate and invent new strategies/tactics/products that can help defeat the status quo. Even though your enemies may be able to access that information, the information is useless without brilliant minds capable of interpreting it and acting upon it. Hence the important role of public education / immigration within a democracy, ensuring that your citizens are the ones who e.g. come up with nuclear weapons before anyone else does. The mistake you are making here is the same that North Korea makes when it allocates a majority of its budget to military operations. Sure, you can acquire shitty second hand tanks and submarines and guns, but the real winners - the quick thinkers, commanders, tacticians, improvisionists (all of whom are just as needed on the field as in the war rooms) - can only end up at your service if you build a society that provides prosperous education opportunities and also takes care of all basic needs to enable citizens to focus on their education. It is with this system that you can end up with great soldiers, great generals, and great supplying organizations (Lockheed Martin, Boeing, General Dynamics, etc.) all under one flag.
- B1FF_PSUVM 8y agoThat's been standard policy for some twenty four centuries now, as laid down in Pericles' Funeral Oration by Thucydides: "Our city is thrown open to the world, though and we never expel a foreigner and prevent him from seeing or learning anything of which the secret if revealed to an enemy might profit him." http://hrlibrary.umn.edu/education/thucydides.html http://hrlibrary.umn.edu/education/thucydides.html (It mostly works, especially allowing for some, or a lot of, bending of truth in advertising.)
- WalterBright 8y agoSeems like they reinvented siege warfare. Caesar did something similar in the Battle of Alesia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Alesia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Alesia
- starpilot 8y agoThat's mentioned in the article along with another historical precedents.
- WalterBright 8y agoHuh, I missed that when I skimmed over the summary at the end.
- omio 8y agoA lot of this was used in Ramadi the year before.
- greedo 8y agoAnd the 2nd Battle of Fallujah.
- tlear 8y agoWould be fascinating to have analysis like this of the tactics employed by Russians in Aleppo and rest of Syria.