4 ms·
I think Apple is right here — they’ve detected a breach of term and shut it down. But I still think they are wrong for blocking 3rd party apps. I understand th
by jedberg 8y ago
I think Apple is right here — they’ve detected a breach of term and shut it down.
But I still think they are wrong for blocking 3rd party apps. I understand they believe it is for my safety and security, but there needs to be a happy medium. They should have a way for experts to side load apps.
- rsynnott 8y agoThey have, for the last few years: http://osxdaily.com/2016/01/12/howto-sideload-apps-iphone-ipad-xcode/ http://osxdaily.com/2016/01/12/howto-sideload-apps-iphone-ip...
- fetus8 8y agoI think you're missing the point. Experts do have a way to side load apps, through enterprise certificates and developer certificates. Facebook was distributing an app to consumers using the enterprise certificates, to collect data, in somewhat malicious terms, which is a direct policy violation of using an enterprise certificate.
- richardwhiuk 8y agoYeah, Apple have to step in here - otherwise they risk Enterprise certificates being used widely to violate Apple's AppStore restriction (which is what FB was doing), which is clearly not in Apple's best interest.
- int_19h 8y ago> Experts do have a way to side load apps, through enterprise certificates and developer certificates Only their own apps. You can't use that mechanism to distribute an app to other "experts", which makes it of limited use in practice. You can distribute as source and require them to build it, but then everybody who wants to install your app on their device also needs a Mac.
- mevile 8y agoI think jedberg is saying he wants to be able to load whatever software he wants on a device he owns. Is this really controversial? There's no good pro-consumer argument for making it impossible. It's OK to make it technically challenging to prevent malicious software from getting on lay people's devices, but blocking it full-stop? If I own a device I should be able to put whatever I want on it. It's mine. Ownership means something. I'm not licensing my phone's hardware. I own it. I can smash it to pieces if I want, why can't I change the bits inside?
- majewsky 8y ago> There's no good pro-consumer argument for making it impossible. Possible arguments: 1. More security because of smaller attack surface for malware. 2. Higher average quality of apps because of curation.
- jyrkesh 8y agoSo make iPhones like Pixels. If I want to root the device, make it simple, make it factory wipe the device, and flip a bit that opts me out of software support. (I know Google doesn't do this last one, but I'm not opposed, I know what I'm doing.) But no. I have to buy a $1200 mini-computer and then accept the arbitrary whims of Apple on what code I can run when.
- wukerplank 8y ago> I have to buy a [...] That's the clue: You don't _have_ to. Buy a Pixel if you want to root something.
- jimbokun 8y agoIsn't that what rooting is for? I don't think it's controversial to say opening up ways to load apps outside of the app store will make it far, far harder for Apple to make any performance, security and stability guarantees about their devices. So if you choose to bypass Apple's ecosystem, you are on your own and can't blame Apple for anything that goes wrong.
- jedberg 8y agoI meant I want to side load apps on my phone that I don't write that other people make that perhaps violate Apple's rules. Like one that replaces springboard for example. Without having to jailbreak.
- saagarjha 8y ago> Like one that replaces springboard for example. This is not something that apps can generally do.
- ilovetux 8y agoI agree. I would like to see something like we see with Linux distros. Whether I'm using apt, yum or dnf I can add a third-party repo for my package manager to download and install from. When I was into jailbreaking my phone that is what this basically meant to me even though I had to go with a different package manager (I think it was called cydia).
- jil 8y agoThey’ve also been expanding the reach of TestFlight apps through public invite links. There are some notable apps (iSH, a Unix terminal emulator, comes to mind) that are only distributed through TestFlight, since that sort of thing would never make it through App Review.
- jedberg 8y agoYeah testflight distribution is a decent workaround, but the limit the number of installs. Also you have to pay Apple for the ability to distribute through testflight. I want a way for a 16 year old kid to make an awesome app and then distribute it to whoever wants it. Like back in the shareware days.
- dwighttk 8y agolike, the App Store? Is it just the $99/yr that you object to? Because you could offer some scholarships to promising programmers. The kid already has a Mac, I bet he can talk his parents into a developer account if he's made an awesome app.
- jedberg 8y agoNo, like apps that don't get approved in the app store. Like some cool springboard replacement, or an ssh client.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> or an ssh client. FWIW, I have a few ssh clients on my iPhone (Termius, Prompt, iTerminal) that came from the App Store. Termius even offers mosh. Why wouldn't they be approved?
- jedberg 8y agoThey didn't used to allow them for some arbitrary reason. It was just an example of something I might want that might not get approved.
- fixermark 8y agoIn practice, it means that when a company gets in bed with that hardware / software ecosystem, Apple is always going to be in that bed with them. Different companies will risk-assess that differently.
- the_duke 8y agoSafety and security sure is a secondary benefit for the userbase. Let's not kid ourselves though, this is mainly about preserving the huge app store profits.