6 ms·
When the engineers are saying no, and the administrators are saying yes, you don't need to know much more.
by ncmncm 8y ago
When the engineers are saying no, and the administrators are saying yes, you don't need to know much more.
- rangibaby 8y agoSee: Chernobyl
- tantalor 8y agoEh? The root causes of Chernobyl disaster were bad design and operator error. There were no ignored warnings.
- LanceH 8y agoPerhaps a strong culture of not raising objections?
- khuey 8y agoThere were plenty of organizational failures in the design and conduct of the (failed) experiment which triggered the Chernobyl disaster.
- ancorevard 8y ago> There were no ignored warnings. In a socialist society, good luck to you and your family when raising objections.
- nkrisc 8y agoI think that's more a function of an authoritarian regime than socialist economic policy.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoHas there ever been a case of the latter without the former?
- penagwin 8y agoThey're two different things, although they are closely related they are distinctly different. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_compass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_compass EDIT: Essentially "socialism" is an economic status, while Authoritarianism deals with social freedoms. Historically most "communist" societies are also Authoritarian, but that's not always the case.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI know that. That's specifically why I'm asking if anyone has managed to implement socialism (or communism) without being authoritarian about it.
- ancorevard 8y agoHistory is the bane for anyone peddling the idea that a socialist society and authoritarianism are two separate things.
- nkrisc 8y agoHistory we also the bane of anyone who thought man could walk on the moon.
- zaarn 8y agoIIRC the lead operator was saying "continue" despite several of the engineers at the consoles telling him that things where about to go nuclear.
- abledon 8y agoI raise this concern when people push Nuclear Energy as the solution we need everywhere. How will we deal with inevitable human error and conflict of interest in these events, especially when the fallout could be deadly for many living beings on the planet.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoSure, but this concern should not be seen as an argument against building nuclear power plants - the same way no reasonable people considered Challenger as an argument against human space flight in general. Challenger was about learning the lessons, and doing better the next time. In case of nuclear power, it's also worth pondering the disastrous consequences of failing to switch away from fossil fuel power generation. And as a side note: we have to somehow learn to deal with "inevitable human error and conflict of interest" in events where failure near population centers might be catastrophic. We either have to, or give up on a lot of progress. Quite a lot of interesting technologies and research areas involve managing higher and higher energies.
- jacobush 8y agoFirst comment I've seen from you I don't agree with. Not at all comparable. A Challenger disaster causes very little collateral damage. (Except fiscal.) A lot of people's lack of objection hinges on, dare I say, on the attitude "let them launch their over sized fire crackers into the sky, I don't care as long as it doesn't fall down on my head". Nuclear has the potential to create a whole no-go area around it. And I have very little faith in us humans as a wider group to learn to deal with conflict of interest. I believe mitigation is better. Widespread solar and other distributed tech like that might not hold the raw promise of nuclear but I hope it will give us a more robust energy system in the world, harder to disrupt either by malice, conflict of interest or by accident. Personally I am in love with things like nuclear fission powered rockets (nuclear engines could be started from bases in high orbit to avoid spewing dirty stuff into the atmosphere), submarine derived nuclear mini electric generator stations towed to coastal cities, fusion research and all that. I hope humanity in the long run will make use of such things...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GuB-42 8y agoEngineers will always say no. It's the administrator's job to decide which kind of "no" is acceptable. Here, the problem is not the engineers saying no. It is that for some reason, administrators weren't able to properly discern trivial matters from life threatening ones.
- mcv 8y agoWhy is it the administrator's job? Why is the expert who best understands the issues, empowered to say no? Engineers should be qualified to carry responsibility for their own work.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kamaal 8y ago>>administrators weren't able to properly discern trivial matters from life threatening ones That suggests a very serious flaw in the overall capability, seriousness and knowledge of the project of the person making that decision. The administrators are not that stupid. Reading the article carefully. These people were worried about the launch to be delayed by an year. That subsequently brings up the question about how that would work for their careers. Also what is the downside for these people. Say the Shuttle crashes, they are not going to be billed $2 billion or charged with manslaughter. Heck, all they get is a job transfer in the worst possible case(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linda_Ham#Columbia_disaster_and_investigation_report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linda_Ham#Columbia_disaster_an...). If you have literally no repercussions for making wrong decisions. You have now incentivized the administrators to make whatever decisions works best for them personally. No amount and quality of engineering reports are going to work from here.
- SomeHacker44 8y agoNot really. Engineers may be best qualified to quantify and estimate the risks. That does not mean they are best to judge whether the risks are acceptable. It is fair to imbue that responsibility in another role. Real world examples include, for software engineers, risks due to security issues or reliability issues. The business (perhaps a non-technical CEO) has to decide the prioritization of effort and funds on those items that will be acceptable to them to meet business goals while maintaining an acceptable level of risk. Not line engineers.
- invalidOrTaken 8y agoThe two shouldn't be siloed. I'm coming to the conclusion that engineers have a responsibility to get themselves promoted to get someone with understanding into authority.
- SomeHacker44 8y agoThe only/final authority (day-to-day) is the CEO. Who, of course reports to the board, which reports to the shareholders - in a large majority of business entities. As a many-time CTO, several time CEO, several time Chairman, I have had plenty of promotions but in the end you always do what your boss tells you (or resign). :)