8 ms·
The fact that this exists makes me uncomfortable, but I'm having trouble pinpointing a reason why it's bad. People are opting into the data collection. Perhaps
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
The fact that this exists makes me uncomfortable, but I'm having trouble pinpointing a reason why it's bad. People are opting into the data collection. Perhaps they don't know the full extent of what Facebook is tracking, but sideloading apps on iOS is not a one-tap process—anyone who used this had a sense of what they were doing.
And, $20 per month is pretty substantial compensation.
The way that Facebook is bypassing Apple's rules feels shady, but I've always felt those rules were user-hostile to begin with. I firmly believe that users should have control over their own devices, and that means letting users give information to companies if they so choose—especially if they're being financially compensated.
- saagarjha 8y ago> People Children, specifically. > Perhaps they don't know the full extent of what Facebook is tracking …is this not bad? > sideloading apps on iOS is not a one-top process—anyone who used this had some sense of what they were doing This is not sideloading; this is enterprise app distribution. Users are not self-signing this app. > And, $20 per month is pretty substantial compensation. For a child who doesn't know any better, maybe…
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dymk 8y agoThey're not sending cash, it's a check or a deposit into a debit card. Not many "children" under the age of 16 have those. So many of the comments in this thread are literally "Think of the children!"
- titanomachy 8y agoReally? I think I opened my first bank account when I was 10 or so. My parents had to co-sign but other than that were not involved in it. I don't think this was very unusual, the bank even promoted a special free account for young people. I had summer jobs from the age of 12, would you expect me to shove the money under my mattress?
- dymk 8y agoWell your parents surely would be pretty involved with that, if their 12 year old son needs a ride down to the bank. It's not something that's going to be slipping under their noses.
- PavlovsCat 8y agoIf they're thinking of the child, that is. Which brings us back to you falsely claiming anyone but you uttered that phrase, and your implied assertion that there is something wrong or odd with looking out for others, including children.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoActually, the article says the money was paid "via e-gift cards", so I don't think a bank account would have been needed.
- anonymous5133 8y agoI use the app. It is $20 amazon gift card.
- r3bl 8y agoMay I ask why?
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> This is not sideloading; this is enterprise app distribution. Users are not self-signing this app. Just to be clear, that's the process I was referring to. I consider it a form of side loading, because the app is coming from an unofficial, non-Apple source. Enterprise apps won't run until you manually go into settings and certify that you trust the developer. Far from the most onerous of tasks, to be sure, but significantly more involved than tapping a download button. I don't see how someone could be "duped" into running an enterprise app.
- morpheuskafka 8y agoThey weren't duped into running it, i.e. they knew they were downloading and installing an app from Facebook Research. They likely did not understand the effect of installing the VPN and trusted root provided by the app.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> They likely did not understand the effect of installing the VPN and trusted root provided by the app. I'm just not convinced on this point. I think it's likely a lot of people did understand that Facebook could see all their internet traffic, and thought for $20 it was a fair trade. There's a HN user down thread (anonymous5133) who says he used the app and quite liked the exchange. Now, it's possible these users did not think through all the consequences that sending this data to Facebook could have—but just how much responsibility does Facebook have here? Does Facebook need to say in big red type, "This data could be given to health insurance companies some day and used to deny coverage?" (I'm not even clear if that would be legal, but I bring it up as an oft-cited nightmare scenario.)
- jolmg 8y agoRecently, there was an HN thread of a Chinese man who sold his kidney for an iPhone at 17 years of age and 8 years later was bedridden for life because his remaining kidney failed.[1] You could say the people who bought his kidney for an iPhone did nothing wrong. The kid had control over his own body and they made a deal the kid thought was good. I think, though, that he wasn't properly educated of the risks that doing such a trade would leave him with, and that the people who offered him the deal very well knew them, but targeted him for being a naive child who wouldn't take them seriously. I think this is the same case. People just don't understand or don't take the risks of this seriously enough, and companies like Facebook take advantage of that. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18925780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18925780
- wbl 8y agoMost kidney failure causes will affect both kidneys.
- FPGAhacker 8y agoThe failure was brought on by the surgery itself.
- jackvalentine 8y agoHis was apparently caused by a lack of quality post-operative care.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoYou're implying (perhaps unintentionally) that selling an organ is equivalent to selling information on what websites you visit. There's a reason selling organs is illegal, at least in the US. I don't think personal information is so valuable that we need to outlaw its sale.
- barrkel 8y agoOrgan selling isn't illegal because organs are valuable.
- my_first_acct 8y agoWhether or not you agree with Apple's rules, the fact that Facebook is willing to violate their Enterprise Certificate agreement with Apple is a red flag. If Facebook is willing to break an agreement with one of the largest corporations on the planet, what reason is there to think that they will keep any promises they make to individual users?
- mjamokeu33y 8y agoLinks below might help put a finger on exactly what's giving you that icky feeling? To me, the problem seems to be (a) lack of informed consent, compounded by (b) the targeting of a vulnerable population. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belmont_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belmont_Report [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respect_for_persons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respect_for_persons [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informed_consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informed_consent
- morpheuskafka 8y agoThose two and the lack of a robust, documented framework for Facebook to delete the data it is not interested in analyzing and store what it is securely. The biggest question I have is why they needed the root to analyze popularity of future competitors. Surely doing domain requested (visible even with TLS) and number/time of requests would be sufficient, and that would have greatly reduced the amount of private data gathered.
- _bxg1 8y agoYou could say the same about predatory payday loans. Just because something is opt-in doesn't mean it can't be manipulative and harmful.
- roguecoder 8y agoMany of the things they are spying on aren't just the business of the person who's getting the $20 either. If you message someone, do you expect them to turn around and sell that to Facebook? If you are one of Facebook's competitors, don't you deserve to not have them use their monopolistic power to scrape your data?
- morpheuskafka 8y agoIf there had been a hack of the data collected by this program, people could very easily and rightly have been fired or disciplined for exposing corporate data through a VPN. Even if most things are run through a corporate VPN or intranet, one sign in to your work account on Office 365 is game over for the company.
- anjc 8y ago> I'm having trouble pinpointing a reason why it's bad … $20 per month is pretty substantial compensation But Facebook's competitors did not consent to their traffic being spied on and had a reasonable expectation that their traffic would remain safe from this type of intervention on iOS devices. Ignoring the ethics of paying users for data and so on, this seems like a straight up case of industrial espionage. The article says that this is how FB spotted the rise of WhatsApp, and presumably informed the offer. They would have known exact usage information, this is espionage via surveillance.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoWhy do Facebook's competitors get a say in it? Facebook is only getting access to user-visible data; if the users decide to give that away (in exchange for compensation), it's their right. Amazon users aren't Amazon employees—they didn't sign an NDA and are free to share what they know.
- anjc 8y agoAt an individual level that may be so, but if they're doing it en-masse then they essentially had secret/sensitive competitor information when they made an offer to buy WA, daily active users, usage-by-demographic etc. On top of that they would have had access to message formats, headers, encryption protocols and so on, things that are potentially trade secrets. This isn't user-visible data and app owners shouldn't expect that competitors can access it directly from a user's phone.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoBy that logic, is the NPD collecting trade secrets by tracking game sales? We know a lot of publishers would prefer that information is unknown. Combining legally-obtained data to come to a conclusion is not illegal or immoral.
- zimbatm 8y ago$20.- is actually quite cheap for a total invasion of privacy. You can rent out just your Facebook account for $500.- per month[1]. [1]: http://fbdollars.com/ http://fbdollars.com/
- mverwijs 8y agoThis gave me words for that uncomfortable feeling: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/jan/20/shoshana-zuboff-age-of-surveillance-capitalism-google-facebook https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/jan/20/shoshana-...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zjs 8y agoPeople are opting into data collection in a way that creates a severe security vulnerability. Not only have you given up confidentiality (of everything, including passwords), you've also sacrificed integrity and availability. You can no longer trust anything you do on your phone. A hypothetical experiment Facebook might be interested in conducting: Do people use Facebook more if Twitter is slow and/or unreliable?