6 ms·
“Learn to Code”: The Meme Attacking Media
- malvosenior 8y agoIt's not "targeted harassment", it's millions of people who have been looked down upon, talked down to and generally attacked by these media properties enjoying some schadenfreude while pointing out their hypocrisy (telling coal miners to learn to code...).
- maccio92 8y agoAnd it's not "anti-media" it's anti-tabloid. BuzzFeed listicles, quizzes, all that shitty content that's plagued the internet and social media for years. Good fucking riddance.
- organsnyder 8y agoBuzzFeed News was a very different product compared to much of the rest of the company.
- plussed_reader 8y ago"Ah! You see it was a right handed weapon the assailant used, and I only use my left. Obviously I can't be the person you're searching!"
- happytoexplain 8y agoUnfortunately, it's pretty easy to simply attack whatever outlet one wishes and label them as such (tabloid, fake news, pick your insult).
- Arzh 8y agoHow is that not targeted harassment?
- malvosenior 8y agoYou have to view it within the context of what Twitter does allow. For instance there's been weeks of people fighting about the Covington High School kids with people on both sides hurling insults far beyond "learn to code" at each other and Twitter as done nothing. In fact many of the journalists "targeted" for this were extremely vicious in their condemnation of the teens, town, church, republicans... I suspect that this happened leading up to the layoffs only heightened people's interests in seeing the journalists get a taste of their own medicine.
- Arzh 8y agoWhy exactly did you quote targeted? You are saying specifically that people are targeting these journalists, you just have no sympathy that they are being targeted.
- malvosenior 8y ago"Targeted" implies they are being harassed. I don't see this as harassment as much as the fair result of their own actions and people correctly leveraging an open platform.
- sc8erboy 8y agoHow exactly is it ? Was it not targeted harassment when they were suggesting that miners should "learn to code"? Why not though? We all know that was derogatory. Does it become targeted harassment because it came from 4chan ? Or are they entitled to protection from the same type of jokes they were making?
- Arzh 8y agoWhen they were 'suggesting that miners should "learn to code"' was it in an article they wrote or was it a coordinated campaign to find people who were laid off of coal mining jobs and tweeting them "learn to code"?
- 8y ago
- rhema 8y ago>"Learn to code" is not a viral phrase that’s being spammed to out-of-work journalists; it’s a targeted attack disguised as a meme. I emphatically sympathize with the journalist who have been recently let go. However, I wish there were a better way to define the difference between a meme and a targeted attack. Maybe Twitter should think about banning political speech or be upfront and adapt club-penguin levels of moderation. Consider the "Vax-Happened" meme. This is a funny meme that is a "targeted attack" on a specific group. Really, most political speech is an attempt at a targeted attack / meme. "Republicans only care about rich people", "Liberals want to take all of your money in taxes". "Bernie bros are aren't living in the real world". In terms of internet culture, this is hardly the first meme in poor taste designed to cause trouble. I think the point is setting the bar so low in terms of offense that to be offended seems more ridiculous. It's like when my 6 year old hones his annoyance to be so quiet that I can't hear in the front of the car, but the whispery weird noises cause his sister to squeal. This new appropriation of "learn to code" is more personally insidious to me than other radicalized phrases and gestures. I like coding and hope everyone learns to code to some proficiency. Oof.
- chuckgreenman 8y agoI've got no desire to kick people when their down, and make no mistake, these journalists are down. However, there is a tendency for people in media to look down on people with blue collar jobs, and to minimize the difficult of being an effective software engineer. It has resulted in a bunch of $group_of_unemployed_people should just get with the times posts. I'd feel bad for them if they didn't do it to other people first.
- Arzh 8y agoI must be blind to these so do you have any solid examples where the people who are doing the jobs are being talked down to?
- fullshark 8y agoI don't know if these qualify but google search for "coal miners coding" turns up a ton of pieces about some coal miners shifting work to coding. Presumably these people think such profiles are kind of condescending as the implied story is "your blue collar career is on the outs and your labor has no value." e.g. https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2016/05/06/477033781/from-coal-to-code-a-new-path-for-laid-off-miners-in-kentucky https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2016/05/06/47... https://abcnews.go.com/US/coal-miners-taught-html-coding-career/story?id=54988203 https://abcnews.go.com/US/coal-miners-taught-html-coding-car... https://www.forbes.com/sites/annefield/2017/01/30/turning-coal-miners-into-coders-and-preventing-a-brain-drain/#4eb94422f81d https://www.forbes.com/sites/annefield/2017/01/30/turning-co... https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/apr/21/tech-industry-coding-kentucky-hillbillies https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/apr/21/tech-industr... https://www.wired.com/2017/02/programming-is-the-new-blue-collar-job/ https://www.wired.com/2017/02/programming-is-the-new-blue-co...
- shortformblog 8y agoThe nature of journalism is that outlets report on things that are happening in the world. If these stories were just long opinion pieces about why former coal miners should code, that would be one thing and the criticism would be valid. But each of these pieces linked is literally a reported out piece about actual people and groups teaching people to code. You could probably go back and forth on whether the idea condescends to blue-collar workers. But the fact is, there wouldn't be these stories if the trend didn't exist and there wasn't a legitimate effort to make it happen before a reporter gave someone a call.
- factsaresacred 8y ago> “Learn to code” is more than internet schadenfreude. It’s also the most recent rallying cry of an anti-media faction. The same media that just days before were busy firing up an online mob to harass a 16 year old child who had the audacity to wear a MAGA hat. Why would anybody be 'anti-media' one wonders?
- ap3 8y agoAaah, look like you hit the nail on the hat.
- happytoexplain 8y agoKnow that I really don't intend to upset anybody or attack people unjustly for their ideologies when I say this: I think your point probably has legs, but could be made much more convincingly with other examples - it's hard to use a MAGA hat as an example of an innocent thing when it's so closely associated with, and so frequently used to implicitly express, a vicious hatred of liberals. I understand that to many people who wear it, that's not part of the message, but there are many examples of people expressing themselves in ways that are not so muddied by the hatred of broader groups, and you could probably find one of those more clear-cut examples if you tried.
- lliamander 8y agoI'm not sure it matters about whom a false story is printed. The point is that it was false. It was rushed to print without getting the whole story. Obviously, in the era of internet journalism it's important to get stories out as fast as possible, but (it seems to me) the incentive for getting out stories quickly that are likely to trigger outrage is pretty high. This particular example is rather salient because it is recent,the evidence of false reporting is fairly clear, and because the cost to the victims of this journalistic malfeasance is fairly high.
- factsaresacred 8y agoThe author of this article is referring to 'attacks' in the microcosm of Twitter and it was the very same accounts calling for the head of the MAGA kid who were on the receiving end of 'learn to code' comments. That's why I drew that comparison. But yes there's possibly better examples. > a MAGA hat [used to] implicitly express, a vicious hatred of liberals Come on. It's a campaign item that represents support for a President that 45% of the country voted for. If you see it as a hate symbol you're projecting your own meaning on to it.
- HashHishBang 8y agoEdit: Ok so if I'm going to be cynical I like to at least be right about things. It has been pointed out that I am, in fact, wrong. So here is my best attempt at breaking out the series of events. Expensive, Pulitzer prize finalist journalists, a part of BuzzFeed News (BFN) are cut. BuzzFeed (BF) contributors rightfully lament the loss of their co-workers. The internet, including me apparently, reads about this from a variety of sources and most of us reach the wrong conclusion about who is who. Since people jumped to the wrong conclusion about who is who and what actually happened people now spamming the more reputable side of BuzzFeed, who were laid off, with "learn to code" ----- I'm of two minds on this one. On the one hand I'm pretty confident there were at least a few legitimate journalists let go in the recent wave but boy oh boy is is hard to have sympathy for the content farmers that got the cut. > Last week, more than 1,000 jobs were eliminated at publishers including BuzzFeed and Verizon-owned Yahoo/AOL. I'm trying to think of the last time I intentionally sought out and consumed content from either of those two outlets. It's unfortunate that they were let go but I'm consistently surprised that BuzzFeed hasn't imploded already. But this isn't an article lamenting fellow journalists and their struggles. It's about: > The Meme Attacking Media And that's where I call bullshit. Is this an attack? No idea, debate away. If it's 4Chan screwing around...eh maybe, I guess? I'm more inclined to believe this is people on this internet punching down at people who are now in bad circumstances. Someone found a more effective way to punch and it took off. The thing that I call issue with is that this is "the media". Following some of the link chains we can see that: > In 2018, Vox, Vanity Fair, Vice, GQ, Vogue, Teen Vogue, the New York Daily News, Good Media Group, Glamour, The Outline, Refinery29, and CNN experienced layoffs Depending on politics and specific interests some will see outlets they care about in that list, some won't. But it seems like people aren't talking about the reporters laid off from Vanity Fair, The New York Daily News, or CNN. No we're getting BuzzFeed spam that have managed to turn their own demise into more bloody BuzzFeed spam. I'm not sure if I should be impressed or really mad.
- 52-6F-62 8y agoI think you might be railing against the wrong beast... https://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/staff-buzzfeed-news https://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/staff-buzzfeed-news
- yongjik 8y agoFrankly, saying that these journalists were "looking down on blue-color workers" sounds like yet another meme which is wildly blown out of reality, only a few step away from "white genocide" or "trans people are coming to get your kids". Well, maybe some of these journalists did, but this is America: who doesn't look down upon others here?
- deogeo 8y agoSetting aside conflating attacks with voicing opinions, there's also this: https://c1.legalinsurrection.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Learn-to-code-headlines-via-Twitter-620x421.png https://c1.legalinsurrection.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/...
- shortformblog 8y ago1. Nobody got laid off at any of the publications that wrote the stories in that image. 2. The reporters wrote the stories based on actual events. None of these pieces are "takes" recommending this. They are reported-out stories. 3. They didn't start the initiatives that led to the stories. If you've got a problem with it, go criticize the people that started these initiatives to assist these communities. 4. There are also initiatives to bring journalists into these areas to better report on them. https://thegroundtruthproject.org/call-applications-appalachian-reporting-project/ https://thegroundtruthproject.org/call-applications-appalach...
- deogeo 8y agoThose initiatives were also decried as attacks on miners by the laid off journalists?
- ap3 8y agoAren’t those actual events ? Those are people with previous coal mining experience that are now coding. It’s like reading about teens that built apps.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Vanit 8y agoThis oddly reminds me of gamergate whereby engaging on the facts seems to side you with the abusers.