6 ms·
Immigrants Do a Great Job at Becoming Americans
- sitkack 8y agoAmericans born here had it happen to them. Immigrants actively seek it. The same thing applies to anything inherited, religions, food, music, operating systems, editors, etc.
- ataturk 8y agoBloomberg--the person who wants to disarm all Americans to make it safer for non-Americans to victimize us all.
- vokep 8y agoNot many are against immigrants or immigration in general, at least not in regards to the US. The issue is Illegal immigration. You're supposed to come through the front door.
- towaway1138 8y agoCame here to point this out. Both I and my wife had immigrant parents, and they all integrated beautifully. None of them would have been caught dead so much as speeding. The idea of breaking into the country--obviously a very serious crime--would never have occurred to them.
- eesmith 8y agoCould you clarify a few things which come to mind when I read your comment? I have problems reconciling it with my understanding. 1) What guidelines do you have for judging if a group of people have 'integrated beautifully'? As an example, would those guidelines show that the Amish have integrated beautifully? If they have not, is the lack of integration a problem that must be remedied? My understanding is that the Amish have not 'integrated beautifully' in the sense that they keep their own language and culture, and remain isolated from most of the rest of the country. My understanding is that that's also perfectly fine, because US culture is not homogeneous. 2) What does "breaking into the country" mean? As a specific example, when my US friends canoed in the Boundary Waters and knowingly landed in Canada to pretend to "claim" the land for the US - and did so not at a place of entry, nor did they report that entry - were they breaking into Canada? And was it a very serious crime? My understanding is that it's illegal, but not serious. 3) For a first time offender, entering or or attempting to enter the United States at any time or place other than one designated by U.S. immigration officers is a misdemeanor, with a punishment of no more than six months of incarceration and up to $250. How can something which is "obviously a very serious crime" have such a mild punishment? (The specific law is at https://codes.findlaw.com/us/title-8-aliens-and-nationality/8-usc-sect-1325.html https://codes.findlaw.com/us/title-8-aliens-and-nationality/... .) That is, my understanding is that "breaking into a country" is ill-defined, and reasonably interpreted to include things which are well-accepted as not being a serious crime.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoSix months isn't a mild punishment.
- eesmith 8y agoIt is a mild punishment for something which is a "obviously a very serious crime". How many other 'very serious crimes' have a maximum incarceration of only six months? How many other 'very serious crimes' are misdemeanors?
- SamReidHughes 8y agoSimple battery, shoplifting, petty theft, DUI.
- eesmith 8y agoAnd littering is also a misdemeanor which in some jurisdictions have a higher penalty than illegal border crossing, according to http://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resources/states-with-littering-penalties.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resourc... . My argument is that it's meaningless to describe all cases of illegal border crossing as a "very serious crime", because then there's no way to distinguish between the very serious crime of littering and the very serious crime of murder. Bear in mind that the term "petty theft" contains the word "petty", which means it's "less important, serious, or great than other" types of theft, quoting https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/petty https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/petty . The listed synonyms for petty are "minor, lower, junior, secondary". You are of course free to use "very serious crime" to apply to any crime, but that is not common usage. I believe most people, most of the time, would limit the term "very serious crimes" to describe felonies. For example, quoting https://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-law-basics/classifications-of-crimes.html https://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-law-basics/classificat... > Crimes receive different classifications according to their severity. The mildest crimes are known as infractions, more serious crimes are known as misdemeanors, and the most serious crimes are known as felonies. This would suggest that "serious crimes" might include misdemeanors and felonies, but "very serious crime" should be limited to felonies. Or from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seriousness#Measuring_degree_of_seriousness_in_crime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seriousness#Measuring_degree_o... > A felony is generally considered to be a crime of "high seriousness", while a misdemeanor is not. I am hammering the point because I believe that describing all illegal entries as a "very serious crime" muddies the water, likely deliberately so. Why describe it using terms more appropriate for murderers than litterers?
- hopler 8y ago1. http so://news.vice.com/en_us/article/pa4mq7/the-us-keeps-mistakenly-deporting-its-own-citizens US keeps mistakenly deporting its own citizens. 2. Natural born citizens don't come in through the front door. 3. Making immigration illegakt and then claiming to be anti illegal immigration isn't fooling anyone. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nativism_(politics) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nativism_(politics)
- artificial 8y agoOver 1 million people legally immigrate annually. No other country comes close to this and it apparently still isn't open enough. What do you propose to improve things?
- hopler 8y agoI don't know. I was simply refuting the bogus claim that there is some logically justifiable moral boundary between legal and illegal immigration. If you want to oppose legal immigration, at least be honest.
- romwell 8y ago>Over 1 million people legally immigrate annually. What do you propose to improve things? How about we really punish people who benefit from this? That is, punish people who hire illegal immigrants with prison terms. The only reason no other country comes close is that our country allows that to happen on purpose by not going after people who benefit from it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vokep 8y ago1. That sucks and is bad and should not happen. I would think we agree on that. I don't think this is relevant to the discussion 2. Yes that is how it works. It's an analogy and this is where it breaks, we could push it though - if parents have a baby, that baby doesn't have to pass tests to confirm it is their child and gets to stay in their home. If some random person claims they're your descendant, you'd have them do a paternity test. 3. I'm sure there are people who do that, but I'm not one of them.
- akhilcacharya 8y agoThis is a canard and actual immigrants aren't falling for it. There are lots of people that dislike immigration as a whole, either for matters of race, religion, or nebulous "culture". The Muslim ban, which then evolved into a travel ban coupled with a refugee ban, is proof of this. When President Trump asked why people are coming from certain countries and not others, everyone heard what he was saying. There's a good reason why Asian-Americans, who used to lean Republican, no longer do despite immigrating overwhelmingly through difficult legal channels.
- vokep 8y agoYou can claim its a canard, as you can claim the sky is purple. Maybe it is for others, but not for me and a some I know with a similar position. I have immigrant family members, I have no issue with immigration, with new people. There is no issue with someone coming to the door of a place and saying "May I please come in" and complying with whatever standards of admission there are. There is an issue when instead they break a window or sneak in somehow. Even if they aren't causing any harm, it isn't a reasonable precedent to allow to be set.
- akhilcacharya 8y agoThis doesn't hold water when the current administration stops refugee resettlement and makes applying for asylum more difficult (legal by definition) while simultaneously opposing family unification (also legal by definition) by calling it "chain migration". The RAISE Act would cut legal immigration in half. And that's while ignoring changes to the H4 visa and general animosity towards the H1B visa program.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoObviously all people anti-legal-immigration are going to be anti-illegal. You're guaranteed that Venn diagram by construction. People in favor of reducing or altering legal immigration are quite vocal about it.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Not many are against immigrants or immigration in general, at least not in regards to the US. Yes, many are, which is why the same people in government that have been most vocal in pushing for the wall have also been the most vocal advocates against a major part of the legal immigration (family unification, which gets the hostile name “chain migration” by it's opponents), have proposed or signalled support for laws slashing legal immigration, have taken executive action to direct border agents to use force to prevent people from legally applying for asylum at ports of entry, etc., etc., etc., ad nauseum, as infinitum. > The issue is Illegal immigration No, it's just immigration. > You're supposed to come through the front door. That would be a lot more credible if the people complaining about illegal immigration weren't the ones slamming the front door closed.
- TheBeardKing 8y agoWhat does becoming American even mean? This country is such a mishmash of religion, politics, food, culture, etc. As an average white guy, I'm happy if you just speak English and maybe put up something at Christmas.
- geezerjay 8y agoIt's as if immigrants excel at being immigrants in a country of immigrants.
- akhilcacharya 8y agoI was born here and don't put up anything at Christmas..
- beezischillin 8y agoI've been thinking about this for a while. While the US is such a huge country, it's obviously hard to pinpoint an obvious "American culture", but even more so maybe the identity is so hard to track down because of its prevalence? During the last 100 years American culture's become so prevalent in the west ("globalism") that a lot of countries are very Americanised where popular culture, art and even businesses originate from the US. I mean, I live in Eastern Europe and I'm currently watching an American TV series on Netflix while I'm writing this comment on my Apple MacBook with a podcast waiting for a listen later and there's a Sam Harris book on my bed. It's nothing like my heritage of what it means to be Hungarian, living in Transylvania. And yet you're sharing a lot of American identity with me. It's just a thought I've been playing around with, but maybe that's why Americans have such a hard time finding their identity as Americans?
- mondo9000 8y agoI think its just white Americans with that problem, other groups seem to have an identity. Why don't white Americans seem to have a culture? I think its an interesting question, I have various ideas, but nothing compelling.
- 8y ago
- akhilcacharya 8y ago> Assimilation, therefore, is really a process of integration -- many cultures becoming one culture. E pluribus unum This is 100% correct and it always makes me supremely uncomfortable when people champion "assimilation" as a goal. America isn't a Borg collective, and American exceptionalism would not exist in a monoculture.
- fallingfrog 8y agoI don’t really get the point of restricting immigration at all. I mean, why not build a wall between Texas and Oklahoma? They have a different state government, different tax rates, different state laws, different government benefits. Makes just as much sense as a wall with Mexico. Huge numbers of people move from state to state without any authorization or notification, and nobody cares. The whole debate makes no sense. It should be a nonissue.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoYou need to read up on your history. There has been a lot of complaint about state to state migration too.
- luckylion 8y ago> Immigration has lots of economic benefits, and few economic costs. Immigrants pay for native-born Americans’ retirement, start companies, and make the U.S. a desirable destination for investment, while not taking away jobs or depressing wages of the native-born. That's weird. Economists regularly find that more supply decreases prices, and that this holds true for the labor market as well. But of course, it's an opinion piece with no claim to be based on facts, knowledge of said facts, or anything other than "I feel like this is true". For more science-based thoughts on the economy and immigration, maybe turn to politico instead of bloomberg: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/09/trump-clinton-immigration-economy-unemployment-jobs-214216 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/09/trump-clinto...
- wtetzner 8y ago> That's weird. Economists regularly find that more supply decreases prices, and that this holds true for the labor market as well. You seem to be suggesting that immigrants aren't also consumers.
- luckylion 8y agoIf you're talking about buying stuff at the grocery store: sure, but it's not a 1:1 offset. You don't need to hire an extra employee to serve an extra customer. Over all, more labor supply = lower wages. That's really not a wild theory, and I personally haven't heard anybody claim that it's not true, but would love to hear your take on it. What typically is a response to realizing that is to try and regulate the labor market more so supply and demand don't set the price, i.e. minimum wage, fixed wages, or some other way of making the labor market work less like a market.