4 ms·
If you stop littering you'll have to carry trash around for longer, which is a personal cost. Littering is a miniature analogy, with and smaller table stakes. T
by whatshisface 8y ago
If you stop littering you'll have to carry trash around for longer, which is a personal cost. Littering is a miniature analogy, with and smaller table stakes. The hedonistic difference between making a good salary selling out your countrymen and hiding from your government in Russia is pretty big, a lot bigger than carrying a chip bag around, but the moral difference scales in proportion.
A common fallacy is thinking that you only have to be a good person for matters less than $100. I can't explain it or present an argument in its favor but it is a very common sentiment.
- Aeolun 8y agoI don’t think that’s a fallacy so much as survival instinct. Doing the ‘right’ thing becomes disproportionally harder when the matter goes over $100. Good is relative to average, and is a concept that society determines the baseline of.
- whatshisface 8y agoThe problem with recourse to the survival instinct is that survival actually turns around and becomes bad past a certain point. For example, consider the survival of a brutal regime: they might say "we have to be brutal or else the people would stop us." A lighter analogy would be a vampire that drinks blood to say alive: yes, he has to do it to stay alive, but the thing that's being kept alive is a vampire. More realistically, someone might say, "I am embezzling from my company because if I didn't I would default on my house." Of course, that is a silly objection, because the person they're keeping housed is an embezzler. So, Snowden's choice was between giving a traitor the easy life and facing hardship and uncertainty as a good person. Granted, he had to suffer a lot, but the alternative to suffering was providing comforts to a criminal that happened to be him.