3 ms·
>He definitely should have kept quiet even if it was against his own personal beliefs. That argument for moral complacency is largely self-fulfilling, because
by whatshisface 8y ago
>He definitely should have kept quiet even if it was against his own personal beliefs.
That argument for moral complacency is largely self-fulfilling, because if nobody thinks that one person defecting will change anything, you'll never get more than one defector at once, and nothing will ever change. In that way everyone will march in lockstep to hell and deserve every bit of the torture that's waiting for them.
The foremost thing that Snowden achieved was that he quit doing the bad thing. There is some value in not being an active contributor to the suffering in the world. Sure, if you quit littering that won't clean up the parks, but at least you won't be a litterer anymore. The first thing Snowden did to improve the state of the world was reducing the number of NSA employees by one; and he improved himself by switching from NSA employee to unemployed. Too many people overlook this, thinking that all that matters is whether or not the world is good on average, while ignoring whether or not they themselves are good.
Secondly, Snowden hasn't been forgotten. It might take a few more to follow in his footsteps before the lesson sinks in to the public, but the things he revealed are still out there.
Finally, there actually have been some changes because of his actions (I saved the most concrete point for last). Nobody on HN discounts the reality of malicious state attackers anymore - it used to be that nobody expected to be on the receiving end of a state level attack (and we never secured appropriately), but now it's common knowledge that Public Enemy Number One is actually the public itself. Snowden definitely helped push forward HTTPS rollouts, for example.
- Aeolun 8y agoYou can stop littering without being fucked over by it very easily.
- whatshisface 8y agoIf you stop littering you'll have to carry trash around for longer, which is a personal cost. Littering is a miniature analogy, with and smaller table stakes. The hedonistic difference between making a good salary selling out your countrymen and hiding from your government in Russia is pretty big, a lot bigger than carrying a chip bag around, but the moral difference scales in proportion. A common fallacy is thinking that you only have to be a good person for matters less than $100. I can't explain it or present an argument in its favor but it is a very common sentiment.
- Aeolun 8y agoI don’t think that’s a fallacy so much as survival instinct. Doing the ‘right’ thing becomes disproportionally harder when the matter goes over $100. Good is relative to average, and is a concept that society determines the baseline of.
- whatshisface 8y agoThe problem with recourse to the survival instinct is that survival actually turns around and becomes bad past a certain point. For example, consider the survival of a brutal regime: they might say "we have to be brutal or else the people would stop us." A lighter analogy would be a vampire that drinks blood to say alive: yes, he has to do it to stay alive, but the thing that's being kept alive is a vampire. More realistically, someone might say, "I am embezzling from my company because if I didn't I would default on my house." Of course, that is a silly objection, because the person they're keeping housed is an embezzler. So, Snowden's choice was between giving a traitor the easy life and facing hardship and uncertainty as a good person. Granted, he had to suffer a lot, but the alternative to suffering was providing comforts to a criminal that happened to be him.
- Simon_says 8y agoSnowden's escape was a near-run thing. He intended to go to Ecuador and got trapped in Russia. He's only living free now because Putin likes showing the rest of the world that the USA is just as bad as Russia. It very easily could have gone another way with Snowden never seeing the light of day again and getting tortured for the rest of his life. That's a lot to ask of anyone, and why I think Snowden will go down as among the bravest people in history.