2 ms·
Ok I don't understand how that kind of inertia would help in this situation. If a turbine is running, and supply and demand are at equilibrium, if you then adde
by benj111 8y ago
Ok I don't understand how that kind of inertia would help in this situation.
If a turbine is running, and supply and demand are at equilibrium, if you then added another load, that inertia wouldn't help maintain equilibrium, it would slow down spinning up the turbine hampering that goal, wouldn't it?
To put it another way.
Say if energy use jumps X%, inertia may make up Y% difference in the short term, you'd still have to put in more than X% in the slightly less short term, and it would take longer to make up the Y% shortfall. Is the Y% shortfall not big enough to be important here.
- Dylan16807 8y ago> Ok I don't understand how that kind of inertia would help in this situation. If a turbine is running, and supply and demand are at equilibrium, if you then added another load, that inertia wouldn't help maintain equilibrium, it would slow down spinning up the turbine hampering that goal, wouldn't it? If you add more load, you start dragging down the frequency. The more inertia you have in the turbines, the less the frequency is impacted. I'm not sure what you mean by "spinning up a turbine" in this situation. Do you mean to produce more power? You don't spin turbines faster to do that. > To put it another way. Say if energy use jumps X%, inertia may make up Y% difference in the short term, you'd still have to put in more than X% in the slightly less short term, and it would take longer to make up the Y% shortfall. Is the Y% shortfall not big enough to be important here. Yes, you have to make up the deficit. But the alternative means having a brownout. In a choice between "drain some inertia to cover the increased load, then overproduce by .1% to refill the inertia" and "don't cover the increased load, voltage freefalls until load drops", I prefer the former.
- benj111 8y agoOk think I've got it, I thought the grid was more sensitive then it actually is. Reading around, as the amount of renewables (solar) increases this might become an issue due to less turbines being in use. "spinning up a turbine" As in spinning up to speed. It can't go 0 to X000 rpm instantaneously. Inertia! Didn't realise they were designed to spin at a constant speed though, thanks.
- Dylan16807 8y agoWhen you bring a new turbine online you get it up to speed before connecting it, and you can do this long before it's actually needed. So inertia hurts your response rate slightly but the main factor is how fast you can get your boiler or water pipe ramped up. That's why you see gas turbines as good peaker plants, they have very little to ramp up. Solar is trickier but it's also more flexible in how it injects power. The real issue is not lack of inertia but the fact that it can lose production when a cloud comes by.