4 ms·
I am programmer, I don't work in Aerospace, my skin in the game is that I fly in planes and know people that fly in planes. The first thing that comes to mind
by sitkack 8y ago
I am programmer, I don't work in Aerospace, my skin in the game is that I fly in planes and know people that fly in planes.
The first thing that comes to mind is, how many flaws do these inspectors find that aren't on the list of checks? Removing the inspectors presupposes that the entire effect they have on the system is codified in measurements they take.
Did they run a double blind study with fault injection?
> The introduction of sampling instead of comprehensive inspections of every job is a key part of Gonzalez-Beltran’s changes.
By the time the flaws arise due to these changes, the folks that instituted them will be retired or dead.
I am not disagreeing with holistically transforming manufacturing processes to reduce (and eliminate error), but automated processes are efficient and without constant feedback unobserved process flaws are even harder to detect.
Given the importance and criticality of such a move, I am not sure we can trust Boeing with this decision alone.
> An internal Boeing document providing “talking points” for managers, obtained by The Seattle Times, points another motivation for the company: faster completion of tasks: “By allowing the mechanic to verify their own work, wait time is eliminated.”
> The FAA “endorse and understand this,” Gonzalez-Beltran said.
I think what Boeing has done has automated the assembly, but not necessarily the inspections. Of course mechanics should perform the operation correctly, but they shouldn't be verifying their own work.
> Gonzalez-Beltran said these were isolated cases of employees not following company procedures.
Priorities are not aligned towards safety, if you have people verifying their own work, they are incentivized to cheat.
> Gonzalez-Beltran, however, insists he’s getting positive buy-in from mechanics who take pride in performing their work without an inspector’s oversight.
So the VP asked the line worker his _feeling_, like how hungry he is and what kind of steak he likes to eat.
Airplanes are not cars, while Poke-Yoke should be applied universally to all engineering pursuits, it in and of itself is not a complete solution.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poka-yoke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poka-yoke
- skookumchuck 8y ago> I am not sure we can trust Boeing with this decision alone From the article: "Boeing cannot move forward with such a radical shift in its manufacturing processes without the approval of the FAA."
- sitkack 8y agoThe FAA is too close to Boeing. In a change this large I believe the NTSB should have over site over the FAA. From the article it appears that the FAA has rubber stamped the process if layoffs are already in effect. https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/AAR0201.pdf https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/...