6 ms·
This is precisely why tech employees need to negotiate collectively. When your employer is posting record profits, but is lowering compensation, you have a much
by vkou 8y ago
This is precisely why tech employees need to negotiate collectively. When your employer is posting record profits, but is lowering compensation, you have a much stronger negotiating position when you work as a team.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoOnly you don't. If you go to a competitor and negotiate a 25% higher salary and bring it back to your current employer, either they give you a 25% raise or you leave. Either way you get 25% more money. If you go to a union and ask for a raise, they go to the employer, the employer can't afford to give everyone a 25% raise, so they give everyone a 2.5% raise. Then you have to quit and go work for the competitor. Only now they won't pay you 25% more because now they know your current salary based on where you work, your position and the terms of the union contract, so they know they only have to pay you 5% more. So either way you're making less. Meanwhile the competitor is still offering more, so your current employer starts bleeding talent, which reduces revenue generation and thereby the amount of money they have to pay employees in the future. It's not as if many people still aspire to work for GM.
- jakobegger 8y agoIs that how unions work in the US? Here in Austria we have "collective contracts" which are negotiated by unions. The "collective contract" specifies a minimum salary (depending on job title/experience), but employees are free to negotiate higher salaries. Senior developers usually earn way more than the minimum. The union also negotiates a minimum raise every year (I think it is 2.6% for IT workers in 2019). Employers are free to offer additional raises, and typically they do.
- sublupo 8y agoSo the valuable employees pay a percentage of their paycheck as union fees, so that the union can negotiate the salary of the not so valuable employees? That of course leaves less money for the high value employees. If the company was a factory, or something similar where the top employees are similar to the average employee, then maybe unions could work. But in the case of programmers, there is a big difference between top employees and average ones. That means that not so many top employees wound want to join unions, making employers even less likely to employ union workers.
- ggm 8y agoYou appear to have no desire to build a more equitable work experience for everyone. Presumably you also don't mind that your elitism assumes a lot of upside benefit for a few and a lot of downside consequences for most. I've never been the alpha chimp, but I've also never been the bottom of the heap. It strikes me that your lack of empathy strongly implies you think you not only would do better, but that you deserve to. Let me put it to you that you're wrong: you would actually do better long term fighting to get better pay across the board and incentives for high achievers actually do better long term (as in vesting) when everyone wins.
- quotemstr 8y agoThis comment thread is a microcosm of every unionization discussion in which I've participated. A: [Proposal for collective organization] B: [Explains logical holes in proposal] A: You're a bad person! Every single discussion on this topic eventually devolves into people demanding that others support a system that's not in their interest on the basis of specious moral principles that happen to benefit the person making the moralistic argument, for example, "you lack empathy" or "you hate democracy". The truth is, nobody is required to support a system that's not in his interest, and if organizers can't create a system that makes everyone better off, they'll fail to achieve their goals. Shame is no substitute for incentive.
- danaris 8y ago> This comment thread is a microcosm of every unionization discussion in which I've participated. I agree with this part. However, "but unions would try to level the playing field so I would not be able to maintain my (obviously well-deserved) elite status" is not a logical argument. And "you appear not to want to make things more equitable" is not saying "you're a bad person"—and you saying it is says, I think, more about you than it does about ggm's post, which stated things in fairly value-neutral terms. Even his final remark was not a moral judgement of any kind, but rather an economic argument. Of course nobody's required to support a system that doesn't benefit them. But (to take your position to its illogical extreme) if everybody fought tooth and nail to ensure that they got the very most possible without regard for what anyone else got, I don't think anyone would be very happy with the result. So yes, this thread is very much a microcosm of every unionization discussion I've seen on the Internet. A: [proposal for collective organization] B: [objects that with a union, they wouldn't be able to use their Mad (Negotiating/Programming) Skillz to get hugely better compensation] A: [attempts to argue that with a union, more people would be better off on average] B: [You're a socialist!]
- danaris 8y agoBut chances are, no matter who you are, at any given time, you can't negotiate a 25% higher salary from a competitor. If you could have done that, why did you take this job in the first place? On the other hand, at any given time, the union is always going to be fighting for you to get reasonable raises based on your position, and will be available to help you show that you deserve a significant raise if your current compensation does not match the going rates for what you're actually doing. This is ignoring all the other things unions do, that don't directly relate to compensation, like ensuring that employees aren't taken advantage of by the company in a variety of creative and quasi-legal ways. Frankly, if software developers of various types unionized, I would be shocked if that union bore much resemblance to the propagandistically stereotyped picture of unions we've had painted for us over the past several decades. I think it's much more likely that, given the prevalence of attitudes such as yours, it would be primarily concerned with the aforementioned protections, as well as setting wage floors for given levels of expected performance, while leaving the ceiling free for people who, like you, think they can negotiate something better. It's not like there's some "union rulebook" that all unions must follow as soon as they come into existence, that says, "First, make sure absolutely everyone makes the same amount of money. Next, make really crappy employees unfireable." Unions are made up of people in the industry they represent—that's the whole damn point—and their goals are set by those people. So in all likelihood, if there were a programmers' union, and you were in it, and you're really as good as you seem to think, you'd have negotiated your way to a position where you have at least some say over union policy. Then, even if there were, for some reason, union rules specifying that compensation for position title X could be no more than Y, you could work to change that.
- YawningAngel 8y agoAt least in the UK, job markets are so wildly irrational that I doubled my salary twice in two years. Both the salaries I ended up having doubled were more-or-less the best thing available at the time.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> But chances are, no matter who you are, at any given time, you can't negotiate a 25% higher salary from a competitor. If you could have done that, why did you take this job in the first place? Because you took it before you had your current level of experience or list of accomplishments that makes you worth 25% more money. > It's not like there's some "union rulebook" that all unions must follow as soon as they come into existence, that says, "First, make sure absolutely everyone makes the same amount of money. Next, make really crappy employees unfireable." There kind of is. What above average employees want is above average wages and competent peers. What below average employees want is average wages (i.e. more than they're worth). What really crappy employees want is to not be fired. You can't have them all at the same time. So if the union nominally represents all of them, who is it supposed to throw under the bus? If the company can spend a given amount of resources on employees, which employees should get them? A union representing multiple types of employees inherently has that conflict of interest. You can't just assume that the best employees will control the union. It's the worst employees that have the most incentive to make sure the union keeps them in their jobs -- the best employees can make the calculation that they're better off at a competitor without a union than to have to engage in constant struggle with not only management but also the other employees with conflicting goals. > On the other hand, at any given time, the union is always going to be fighting for you to get reasonable raises based on your position, and will be available to help you show that you deserve a significant raise if your current compensation does not match the going rates for what you're actually doing. How is that any different than what you can do on your own, or hire someone to do who doesn't have the conflict of interest of representing other employees competing for the same pool of company resources? > This is ignoring all the other things unions do, that don't directly relate to compensation, like ensuring that employees aren't taken advantage of by the company in a variety of creative and quasi-legal ways. That seems like the role of the various attorneys general. > I think it's much more likely that, given the prevalence of attitudes such as yours, it would be primarily concerned with the aforementioned protections, as well as setting wage floors for given levels of expected performance, while leaving the ceiling free for people who, like you, think they can negotiate something better. Then you're paying dues so they can negotiate higher wages for people who aren't you but come from the same pool of available employee compensation, leaving less for you when you still have to spend your own time/resources on top of that to negotiate your own compensation. Good employees and bad employees have different interests. And if you put them together in the same union, the bad employees are usually more interested in not getting fired than the good employees are in making sure that they do -- because the good employees have plenty of prospects at other companies where they don't have to constantly struggle to keep their own union from acting against their interests. Then good employees leaving impairs the long-term health of the company, which hurts even most of the employees left behind. (Though presumably not the ones that would otherwise have been fired for incompetence.)
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoTIL that professional athletes and Hollywood actors aren't allowed to negotiate their salaries /s. Both have very high levels of union participate, yet have extreme levels of salary negotiation. Unions don't have to involve fixed pay scales to boost salaries for the participants, e.g. SAG-AFTRA mandates a portion of revenue go to actors in addition to salaries, NFLPA requires that a certain portion of revenue be paid in player salaries, neither prevents individuals from negotiating a higher salary for themselves.
- mavelikara 8y agoUpvoted. Every thread on unionization here on HN presupposes a certain stereotype of unions.
- gaius 8y agoTechies: we’re all different skill levels we cannot possibly bargain collectively Hollywood unions: lol srsly, we have millionaires in our unions