4 ms·
Slavery or indentured servitude implies you have no choice. You do.
by bdcravens 8y ago
Slavery or indentured servitude implies you have no choice. You do.
- chottocharaii 8y agoEasy for you to say. You're probably not bonded to your employer like the OP. Get your head out of the sand.
- bdcravens 8y agoIf you're allowed to quit and go to another country, whether your country of origin or another country, that's a choice.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> You're probably not bonded to your employer like the OP. No one gets an H-1B involuntarily, and it would be an unusual circumstance where someone who had one was not free to leave. That said, I support liberating everyone bound by the H-1B by eliminating the visa category entirely.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoThey’re obviously getting what they want, a higher wage and living in America. If all they wanted was higher wages and a better standard of living, there’s any number of other countries, that have more relaxed immigration policies, they could have moved to. If they can get a job and a visa in the US, they’re obviously good enough.
- briandear 8y agoHe can quit. If he's really "highly skilled" and there really is a "shortage," then it should be trivial to find another job and another visa sponsor.
- cheeze 8y agoYeah. It's not that hard to move companies as a non-citizen. It's more difficult than a citizen, sure. But I agree with the poster above that I have many many friends who have done exactly this.
- jhwang5 8y agoNo one forced you to be here. Also, the quota problem affects only India and China, partly because there's a massive imbalance of inflow specifically from those two countries.
- 1024core 8y agoThere's always Canada. Sure, salaries may not be as high as the US, but if you have an advanced degree from a US university, you are welcome there.
- h1bslave 8y agoI have very restricted choices, it’s different from the choices you have and that is why it is easy for corporations to keep the wages down , the “lower wages” I get here is still way higher than what I’d make if I chose any of the choices I have.
- bdcravens 8y agoSo you're choosing the best option according to an objective standard, which is your wage. Restricted choice != no choice, and in the face of that, to compare it (and the salary that exceeds most of the world) to true slavery is pretty melodramatic.
- greglindahl 8y agoI want American to be a shining city on a hill, a place so great that people are strongly motivated to want to live here. I also want immigration to be fair. You might consider what your statement says about what you want about these two things.