4 ms·
Something's fascinating to me. Clearly there's a lot of diversity. But there also isn't. I don't associate with any of it. Not because I'm a green space monster
by Waterluvian 8y ago
Something's fascinating to me. Clearly there's a lot of diversity. But there also isn't. I don't associate with any of it. Not because I'm a green space monster. But where's the potbellied, grizzled 55 year old welder? Or the "I hate kale, more bacon please" mother of three? Everyone looks so... Chic and young and modern and... Silicon Valley.
Is it the art style? Is that the point? Is that what the robotic "HUMAAAAN" is teasing? That these aren't anything like real humans?
- JulianMorrison 8y agoIt's advertart. There's a depth of absolute cynicism in it that is well represented by the lack of faces - and of any diversity outside of the superficial. Pose-able lies, for use by liars, to sell bullshit for companies that don't care.
- kohanz 8y agoThey're marketing materials. They often don't represent everyone, but rather a specific set of customer demographics.
- fvdessen 8y agoLike the pregnant men demographic apparently.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bane 8y agoYou may be using the wrong definition of diversity. It's often used to mean containsminorities(thing) == true vs giniindex(thing) == high .
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y agoYep, there's a difference between Diversity™ and diversity.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoHow do you know the woman on the splash page isn't a mother of three who hates kale? I'm serious. What does that look like to you?
- vertline3 8y agoHe's saying someone who is very overweight, I assume. I felt he was saying it in a diplomatic fashion?
- seanhandley 8y agoYou could always skew the image on the horizontal axis if you wanted broader people.
- freddie_mercury 8y ago
- whatshisface 8y ago>I don't associate with any of it. Not because I'm a green space monster. When I checked I didn't see any white people, so assuming that you are white the explanation for your reaction is probably just that your race isn't represented. People identify more with other people that look like them. If you had a kid from China draw a picture of some people they would all look Chinese, so my guess is that the author of the page is from a country that's mostly black and Hispanic. They might not even have noticed that they left white people out. In that light the "real humans" comment comes across as a little weird, though, so maybe this doesn't explain your reaction. Although if it helps clear the air, I'm fine with pointing out that I would prefer to use an icon pack that included white people, after all that's me.
- jazzyk 8y ago> If you had a kid from China draw a picture of some people they would all look Chinese That may be OK, but I can't think of a country where 80% of people are female?
- whatshisface 8y agoAt this point we're splitting hairs down to the subatomic level, but that can be explained by pointing out that the author made more distinct female hair styles than male hair styles.
- stronglikedan 8y ago> In that light the "real humans" comment comes across as a little weird But that's the light painted by you, not OP. OP gave very specific and valid examples of types of people that are missing. OP said, nor implied, anything about race. That's your straw man, and yours alone. The only thing that's weird is that an illustration library called "humaaans" is no where near diverse enough to represent humans.
- whatshisface 8y ago>But that's the light painted by you, not OP. Right, I'm saying that's the most accurate light. I'm not trying to accuse the OP of anything.
- ajcodez 8y agoIt either (1) looks like people you know, or (2) doesn’t look like people you know, in which case you notice everyone is young and healthy and happy (desirable traits). If you’re in the first group you definitely don’t want to see imagery of pot belly welders.
- tripzilch 8y agoThey don't have faces, I'm not sure if they look happy. In fact, not having faces communicates to me the complete absence of indication. That said, it's a cool project but I wouldn't use it just because the art style clashes so much with anything I would design. It looks like Word clip-art, imvho.
- iamben 8y agoDoesn't advertising largely play to aspiration? Isn't that largely how we live our lives? I'd bet most people who look at a guy in a Ferrari don't think "he looks good in that car!" They think "I'd look good in that car" or similar. It's tough to appeal to everyone, especially with images like this. Therefore isn't the safer bet to go for a 'middle of the road' aspirational image that's _close enough_ to the target demographic the product is generally associated with and for the most part doesn't offend or put off anyone, even if it doesn't exactly hit the mark?
- sigfubar 8y agoI've done my best to construct a "humaaan" that matches my own appearance (30s fat balding Russian dude), but the closest I got was the pregnant hipster lady. Oh well.
- TuringNYC 8y agoI love this effort. But sort of wish it wasnt just a drop-box site and rather a site where others could contribute and tag-index their contributions. This way, you could contribute the persona you're missing.
- Waterluvian 8y agoYeah, you're right! You also got me thinking about how some of the tools here lend themselves to assembling then contributing additional elements. Ie. drag out existing elements, do some basic vector drag and drop and editing, paint bucket, border thickness, etc. "Submit for peer review" (which can be a Pull Request).
- DoctorOetker 8y agoperhaps the CC license allows you to fork the project and do with it whht you waaaaaant?
- hliyan 8y agoAlso, where are the front-facing people?
- gus_massa 8y agoIt's probably more difficult to draw people front-facing. Most videogames and cartoons show the characters from the side. Also, to make a realistic drawing of a building it is difficult to paint from a point of view that is directly in the front, because you must hint the 3D shapes with the shadows and the draws. It's much easier to draw it from a point of view that is somewhere on the side, in front of a corner, like 45° or something like that. The perspective alone makes the 3D part visible, and the shadows only help to make the 3D effect better.