4 ms·
> Surprisingly, it’s not our shared language or even our ability to dominate other species that defines us but rather, our shared fictions. I read his book whe
by lordnacho 8y ago
> Surprisingly, it’s not our shared language or even our ability to dominate other species that defines us but rather, our shared fictions.
I read his book where he talks about this. It makes some sense: you can operate at varied scales if you have shared fictions.
When you meet a complete stranger, you're both members of the human race, sharing a desire for a better future. Meet a fellow countryman, and there are songs and stories that bind you together. Work for the same company and there's internal culture as well as the glorious leader you both work for. Support the same football team and you both remember that night in Istanbul. You were sitting at home in Liverpool, he was in Malaysia.
Hard to tell as with anything historical whether this is the most convincing explanation though. I'm sure there's other things that separate us from the animals? But a compelling enough story and he tells it well.
- hammock 8y agoThat night in Istanbul was a fiction? Isn't that just a shared story?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mostlysimilar 8y ago"Football" being anything other than a bunch of humans running around on some grass kicking the ball is the "fiction" in this context, where "fiction" means "shared belief" and things like game rules, organized competition, etc. are mutually agreed upon and able to be talked about.
- lordnacho 8y agoThe fiction is that you have something to do with those guys who kick the ball around.
- learc83 8y agoThere was an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation that explored a similar concept. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darmok https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darmok
- flippyhead 8y agoI love this episode but was surprised that wikipedia said this: > It is often cited as one of the best episodes of the both The Next Generation series and the entire family of the several Star Trek television series.
- RegBarclay 8y agoAgreed. I would grant that Darmok is in the top 5 TNG episodes, but I haven't seen that kind of praise for Darmok across the entire series.
- joshuaheard 8y agoIt was definitely the most innovative episode. My favorite was the first Borg episode where they finally met someone they couldn't defeat that wanted to destroy them. OP: an example of shared fiction he uses in the book is the law. The law is a fiction in the sense that it is not a physical object, but a group of shared concepts that allows society to be built to a higher order. "Sapiens" is a great read.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> It was definitely the most innovative episode. How so? I always hated that episode because it's a straightforward story of developing communications through a language barrier, except that Star Trek is very clear that language barriers don't exist. So it just ends up being an incoherent plot hole. But the concept of a language barrier isn't exactly new.
- joshuaheard 8y agoWell, I don't think a language barrier is something that doesn't exist in the ST universe. They have the universal translator, and I only remember a couple of episodes where it didn't work. Certainly they ran into completely different life forms, such as silicate based and energy based where presumably communication would be a challenge. This episode explored the language barrier as the other language was referentially based and unlike our own language. It was difficult for Picard to learn. To make that the basis of an episode was unique, I thought. My other favorite episode was where Picard got shocked by a probe and lived an entire life in only a few minutes. The probe was a device to teach others about a lost culture.
- NotAnEconomist 8y agoThis seems like a technology enabled by our capacity for language and abstraction.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- e40 8y agoI think the shared fears, or propensity for fear, is what rule us in the internet age. And some people seem to have an innate hatred/distrust of others, which probably served humans well thousands of years ago, but now it just gets in the way.
- cgriswald 8y ago> And some people seem to have an innate hatred/distrust of others, which probably served humans well thousands of years ago, but now it just gets in the way. I think the places where it serves us well and the places where it just gets in the way are just about the same now as they were thousands of years ago. If you doubt that, put yourselves in the shoes of someone who distrusts your particular set of tribes. Even if they are better off trusting you or any individual member of one of your tribes, are they better or worse off trusting that tribe as a whole? And if you think they are better off, does the potential advantage conveyed outweigh the potential risks?
- sonnyblarney 8y agoIt's right ... but those things are not really 'fictions'.
- keeper7777 8y agoNetflix is hosting Joseph Campbell and 'The Power of Myth' with Bill Moyers which wonderfully details how this idea of shared fiction works. [0] It's amazing how deep it permeates our culture including how Disney adopted Campbell's ideas as not only a vehicle for story telling but also as a matter of social responsibility creating a unified view among all the billions of Earth's human inhabitants.[1] You and I have a shared fiction that is also the same as a person buying a bootleg copy of Star Wars or Frozen on the street corner in Moscow, Beijing, Mexico City, or New Delhi. [0] https://www.netflix.com/title/70281117 https://www.netflix.com/title/70281117 [1] https://livingspirit.typepad.com/files/chris-vogler-memo-1.pdf https://livingspirit.typepad.com/files/chris-vogler-memo-1.p...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- felipemnoa 8y ago>>> Surprisingly, it’s not our shared language or even our ability to dominate other species that defines us but rather, our shared fictions. Shared fictions seems to just be a euphemism for culture. I wonder why he doesn't just call it that.
- jasode 8y agoIf you're only going by the short snippet lordnacho quoted, yes it might seem like it's just "culture". Culture would be shared rituals like language, food preferences, music etc. YNH's "shared fiction" idea is about humans' ability to deliberately create new abstract entities that compels humans to act together in service of that entity. Examples of his shared fictions would be a "company" or "fiat money". These "fictions" somehow organize humans to cooperate and multiply their power over the world. Culture, on the other hand, like regional food recipes, would accumulate organically and accidentally.
- quadrangle 8y agoBecause culture also includes something like how we construct and decorate houses, and there's nothing fictional about that. Same with the types of food we eat or music we make. Only some parts of culture are shared-fictions.
- x3tm 8y agoSocial construct is closer to what he talks about. As for why he had to use a non standard formulation for this ... I believe it's marketing.
- InitialLastName 8y agoI actually like the way he uses "intersubjective truth"(on a spectrum with "objective truth" and "subjective truth) to describe things that are only true because enough people agree that they're true.
- pesmhey 8y agoWe’re being seduced into believing in social constructs. His language is much more palatable. For the record, I’m fine with it.
- uhtred 8y agoA better example is that before our cognitive revolution humans could only really cooperate in groups no larger than 100. When we developed the ability to imagine shared fictions, such as countries, money, law, religion, we gained the ability to cooperate on some level with every other human that also believed in those fictions. Money, even back when it was something like sea shells that were money, meant many disparate groups could cooperate as long as they shared the belief in the fiction of those shells being more than just shells.
- dwd 8y agoI find the term "shared fiction" just doesn't convey it adequately, at least in English. Fiction is a loaded word that says "not real" where maybe shared truths, shared beliefs (in the sense of the Greek: hupostasis rather than pisteuo) would be better. We can conceptualise and communicate about thing that are immaterial like trust, honor and promises.
- yesenadam 8y agoWell, it's shorter than "wampeters, foma & granfalloons" - A "wampeter" is an object around which the lives of many otherwise unrelated people may revolve. The Holy Grail would be a case in point. "Foma" are harmless untruths, intended to comfort simple souls. An example: "Prosperity is just around the corner." A "granfalloon" is a proud and meaningless association of human beings. - Kurt Vonnegut Jr, Wampeters, Foma & Granfalloons