3 ms·
> Some 23% of girls drop out of school upon reaching puberty, humiliated by their peers and unable to access clean, private toilets. What I find disturbing is
by mschuster91 8y ago
> Some 23% of girls drop out of school upon reaching puberty, humiliated by their peers and unable to access clean, private toilets.
What I find disturbing is that school peers humiliate each other over menstruation. Nearly all girls get it during puberty, so why are they shaming each other? And for the boys who shame their classmates, why aren't their teachers holding them accountable?!
- whatshisface 8y agoWhat you're looking at is a cultural trait, everyone does it because everyone does it. In the US we have a few of these but they're difficult to notice because you're used to them. >why aren't their teachers holding them accountable?! The teachers grew up with and participated in the same practices.
- pembrook 8y agoIn a country without access to toilets and clean water, why would they have the resources for 1st world level teacher oversight? This is kind of like asking why water is wet. Many children (likely due to their parents) are insecure savages with under-developed empathy. Humiliating each other is simply what they do. Hence why we force them to undergo decades of education outside the home to learn how to relate to each other in a civilized, healthy way by adulthood.
- zanny 8y agoTo be fair, plenty of first world children can be perfectly competent secure savages with self-centered complexes and self-gratification perpetuated by their parents and family wealth. Kids really don't learn empathy innately. It has to be taught, and its not something to just lecture, it needs to be learned through experience.
- fipar 8y ago> What I find disturbing is that school peers humiliate each other over menstruation. Nearly all girls get it during puberty, so why are they shaming each other? And for the boys who shame their classmates, why aren't their teachers holding them accountable?! I agree its disturbing, but it's not surprising. School-age people can be very cruel. For a US (in the 1990s) perspective on menstruation-related shaming, check out the lyrics to "My red self" by Heavens to Betsy, for example. They were school-aged when they wrote that. Edit: s/Heavents/Heavens/
- winchling 8y agowhy are they shaming each other? I guess it's partly because menstruation is typically accompanied by mood swings which render the person concerned more vulnerable to bullying.
- moate 8y agoI think you're overthinking here. Children going through puberty are accompanied by mood swings, so if that was the case they'd all be shaming each other, boys and girls, for all kinds of things (To be fair, they basically are. Children suck this way). The stigma around menstruation is entirely cultural. It's about someone being unclean/icky. The mood swings feel like a complete red herring.
- winchling 8y agoWhy can't it be both? Isn't bullying just as much a cultural phenomenon as ideas about blood and ickiness? It targets those who less psychologically secure, as menstruators temporarily are, relative to their peers.
- elliekelly 8y ago> those who less psychologically secure, as menstruators temporarily are Source?
- winchling 8y agoIf you search for 'premenstrual syndrome' you'll find symptoms reported include things like anxiety, irritability and mood swings.
- elliekelly 8y agoPMS doesn't make women "less psychologically secure." Full stop.
- iicc 8y agoTragedy of the commons. Individually, perpetuating the status quo is the "better" option.