9 ms·
The Tech Revolt
- cpr 8y agoCould this possibly be any more obvious in its virtue-signalling?
- murph-almighty 8y agoIf anything this is a set of stories about putting actions behind your words- people resigning over or refusing to comply with policy they disagree with. This is nothing like the implication you're trying to make.
- untog 8y agoIt fascinates me that "virtue signalling" is used as such an easy dismissal of people's opinions because they dare to actually talk about them. The whole point of taking a stand on an issue is to inspire others. If you, as an individual, quit your job because of ethical concerns you know full well that losing one developer is not about to make the company change course. But talking about leaving, why you left, and what you want to change, is the way of spreading that message to others. To dismiss that as "virtue signalling" is baffling. Or just extremely lazy.
- sayno3 8y ago"Virtue Signaling" or "SJW" as derogative implies useless or hypocritical sense of the terms. Of course it's a good thing to signal positive virtues or fight for social justice. Used negatively, "virtue signaling" implies that one is using perceived virtue as a way to dog-whistle for a specific tribal group, for a trendy but ultimately counter-productive virtue. It is disingenuous and not the point of actual virtue, which is selfless and not using virtue to primarily increase one's social standing. Like SJW is used for someone tilting at windmills and going out of their way to attack someone for views which are only 'bad' through a lot of mental gymnastics. Like the phrase "make america great again" or "freedom fighter" can ostensibly be a positive thing, but in actual practice is often used to disguise negative things.
- Terr_ 8y agoSlightly rambling here: I think the charitable interpretation of "virtue signalling" is that the person sees "bragging", "showing off", or "holier than thou." In contrast, there are some people out who use it to mean "that subject is taboo because it makes me uncomfortable."
- tenaciousDaniel 8y agoliterally dripping in it
- lordnacho 8y agoYou have to wonder if the key ingredient in this is the fact that tech jobs are booming. There's so much written about the job market, you tend to feel confident that you're in high demand. I know a lady who was working for a startup that folded. She got told, then walked down the hallway in the same building, got hired by another startup. Boot camp grad. There's even a person mentioned in the article who refused to work at Amazon, which I guess pays over $200k. Some people would do it out of principle regardless, but many more would find it easier to protest if they had high confidence they could find another job in that bracket. I've seen sexual harassment suits happen in finance, and it hasn't led to any form of mass movement. People just get paid off and let out the back door. In addition you have to ask about the effect of that hiring cartel being broken.
- AznHisoka 8y agoYou're right. It's also because we live in 1st world conditions, and once your basic needs are met, we strive to address the higher ones, like fulfillment and meaning. I've worked with programmers who live in 3rd world countries like the Philippines, and notice a huge difference in the way they treat their job. When I give them a boring task, they don't ask what is this for, or why am I doing this? They just do it - on the flip side, they don't care about the product, or the company mission. I'm not saying this because it's good or bad, but this is just what I've noticed.
- charlietango92 8y agointeresting. Sometimes I wish I was more like them, and things didn't bother me if they seemed boring or pointless. Seems like an innately selfish view, but one i'm having trouble rectifying.
- jriot 8y agoAfter serving in the military (Air Force air traffic controller, so military lite) I align more with the 3rd country workers mentioned. Take the task, complete it to the best of my ability, move on to the next task. I don't care about the mission or domain. Im paid well, work from home and have relatively little stress compared to 11 years in the military. Searching for more meaning out of my work would create undue and unnecessary stress trying to find that unicorn role, which in reality doesn't exist.
- taraploughman 8y agoThis seems a good time to point out that a few of us been organizing a revolt against HN. I wish it wasn't so, and the drama is mostly uninteresting. Suffice to say, expressing concerns about HN on HN is a quick way to end up beheaded. If you're looking for an alternative: https://www.laarc.io/ https://www.laarc.io/ You may find the site a welcome change of pace. We just had our first Show post today. There is a good chance that this account will be quickly banned, this post killed, and this account marked as "uncommentable", meaning this is the last comment I am likely able to post under this handle. But you may also know me as sillysaurus. I've missed you guys.
- ProAm 8y agoWhy the revolt over HN?
- untog 8y agoI can't speak for the OP, but I've been frustrated to find that any time a controversial topic comes up on HN (say, sexism) it is immediately flagged off the homepage. A small cohort of HN users get to dictate what the site at large discusses, and I'm not sure that's for the betterment of the industry.
- bilbo0s 8y ago??? So is this basically a revolt by the more political oriented people? I mean, the people who want to discuss the political type controversial stuff and not so much tech and science? Just wondering why I never heard of it until I read that comment?
- malvosenior 8y agoNever to be mentioned: All of the engineers who won’t work at Google because of what they did to Damore. Techies aren’t as politically mono cultural as this (and most other pieces) would have you believe. Many would happily build something for ICE as another example.
- lordCarbonFiber 8y agoI'd be surprised if there's a statistically significant number of engineers making a stand because "company fired engineer hired to do machine learning because he demonstrated an impressive ignorance of statistics and applied that knowledge to make a public ass of himself". Sure the number is nonzero, but I'd look beyond you're own bubble if you think that's a population worth mentioning in a discussion about larger trends.
- zozbot123 8y agoIt would sure be nice if researchers who work on machine learning were less ignorant of statistics! But singling out one employee for this seems rather disingenuous, doesn't it?
- lordCarbonFiber 8y agoAre there many (any?) jobs where you can go and publicly announce that you're not only unqualified but extremely proud to be so and not suffer consequences?
- IOT_Apprentice 8y agoI guess they are working at Palantir instead.
- m0zg 8y agoProtesting Chinese censorship, I get that. But they lost me at "protesting projects with ICE". I happen to think that immigration and customs enforcement is a net positive. Those people deal with human trafficking, seize a ton of dangerous drugs (2370lbs of Fentanyl alone in 2017), and send a lot of people who shouldn't be here back to where they should be (or to jail if they've committed other crimes).
- throwanem 8y agoYeah, I'm really happy to be protected from all those hardened criminals they've been keeping in baby jail. That's exactly the kind of thing I want to support in my federal agencies!
- HumanDrivenDev 8y agoI happen to think that immigration and customs enforcement is a net positive. I guarantee those people would be as well if they were effected by it personally. If you're not personally doing the kind of jobs an illegal immigrant can do for less, then you can only benefit - it lowers the cost to you for many things in your life. As a bonus, you get to pretend that makes you a good person. An episode of South Park addresses this brilliantly, though people conveniently only remember the first part. Time travellers from the future come into South Park and take all the menial jobs. The blue collar americans yell "they took our jerbs!" Randy - a geologist - admonishes them as racists, until he finds out his own white collar positionhas been given to an alien, and then he too is complaining about how they took his job. The day the wealthy Californian tech companies start hiring illegal immigrant developers at a lower cost is the day the echo chamber changes its tune.
- IOT_Apprentice 8y agoHave you heard of outsourcing? Or the term Offshoring? Or Tech Companies using H1B Visas? I mean it is already happening, perhaps you just missed it.
- drankula3 8y ago
- hydrogenglow 8y agoI'm interested in seeing whether we begin to see more unionizing among tech workers and therefore more collective action. It'd be like the incidents detailed here but to the Nth degree.
- jbob2000 8y agoBig companies have this thing called “segregation of duties” which protects the company from organized labour. You can organize all you want, but the job has been cut up in to so many pieces, it’s easy to replace whoever forms a union.
- ForHackernews 8y agoThat's why solidarity mattered, historically.
- jbob2000 8y agoCan't have solidarity if you coworkers all speak different languages than you.
- hydrogenglow 8y agoIt'd be hard for someone like a Google to function well if their software engineers all walked, regardless of how they are split up across departments. This kind of technical talent is extremely hard to find, making it to more difficult for the company to replace them if they do get fired for forming a union.
- ForHackernews 8y agoNeveragain.tech is silly to me because they pledge: > We refuse to participate in the creation of databases of identifying information for the United States government to target individuals based on race, religion, or national origin. But then you have people signing it who work for companies like Google and Facebook that obviously already have built huge databases to target individuals based on race, religion and national origin to show them ads. If the US government really wanted to go full fascist, these companies have conveniently collated all the data for them. It's like saying "I'm happy to work on building nuclear bombs, as long as you pinky-swear you'll only ever use them for digging harbours."[0] [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Chariot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Chariot
- arcaster 8y ago"How I refused to take a $200k+ job because I can and because my privileged principles told me to" - entitled attention seeking "activist"