5 ms·
Hearing aides are also insanely cheap to produce, they are not complicated devices and that market is only surviving due to the medical device status of them ca
by munk-a 8y ago
Hearing aides are also insanely cheap to produce, they are not complicated devices and that market is only surviving due to the medical device status of them causing a high barrier to entry.
- zrobotics 8y agoThere are actually some decent alternatives avaliable on alibaba and other Chinese outlets. I helped my father with getting a pair, they were 125 and have been performing well for 1.5 years now. Sure, I wouldn't trust alibaba for most medical devices, but something like hearing aids should be safe enough. His insurance wouldn't kick in anything, and while he could afford the price he would never spend it. Since he so badly needed them, I suggested he try a pair of the cheaper ones, and the difference in quality of life was staggering.
- throwaway2048 8y agobeware of cheap hearing aids, hearing loss is almost never uniform, so if they aren't adjusted properly they can be far too loud in the parts of the audio spectrum where hearing is less damaged, and can in fact cause further hearing loss. Not that this is any excuse for them costing $20,000, but its something to keep in mind, cheap abibaba ones likely just make all frequencies louder.
- rhinoceraptor 8y agoIt seems like this could easily be solved by selling the hearing aids with a smartphone app to test your hearing and tune the aids, and a pair of flat frequency response headphones for testing.
- pkaye 8y agoRead about the OTC hearing aid law signed 2 years ago. http://www.hearingreview.com/2017/08/president-trump-signs-otc-hearing-aid-legislation-law/ http://www.hearingreview.com/2017/08/president-trump-signs-o...
- computator 8y agotl;dr: The gist is that, by near year I think, people with mild-to-moderate hearing loss will be able to buy hearing aids without having to see a doctor or get a prescription. (I'm always amazed when the bureaucracy makes something easier rather than more difficult.)
- Scoundreller 8y agoRetirees have lots of time to vote.
- chris1993 8y agoThis is essentially the system sold by Blamey Saunders in Australia. My pair work reasonably well.
- rhinoceraptor 8y agoWow, it's crazy that those are still $3000 for essentially a microphone, DSP chip, maybe a small microcontroller and a BLE chip, and a driver. Something like the Airpods are probably on the same level of technical complexity, but an order of magnitude cheaper.
- Karupan 8y agoCan you post a link to the model you got? Looking for alternatives for my dad as well. Thanks.
- klodolph 8y agoI wouldn't say "insanely cheap", from what I understand the production costs are something like $50-$150 per unit (not per pair!) and that's with cheap overseas labor, although cheaper devices exist. They are not complicated devices inasmuch as we don't consider circuits complicated, any more. There's a lot of R&D that has gone into making those things work the way they do. I do think that the prices are inflated, and will drop, I just also think that they're complicated devices that aren't so easy to make.
- loeg 8y agoThose are similar COGS to like, iphones, a luxury good. If they only cost $600-1000 I think that'd be significantly less egregious than $2000-3000.
- patentatt 8y agoI’d take issue with “not complicated.” They are very tiny, have to be very low power, and they run a surprising amount of real-time DSP. Then the whole electronics package has to be integrated with an acoustics package including multiple microphones and transducers. And the higher quality all of those acoustical components are, the more transparent the end product. And it all has to be durable enough for continuous wear by a human for multiple years. I wouldn’t diminish what cutting edge hearing aides do, they can be quite impressive technically.
- abecedarius 8y agoI doubt the size constraint is pressing (as modern electronics go) unless you're trying to hide them. My decades-old high-power analog aids fit behind the ear.
- skybrian 8y agoPower constraints seem pretty tight, though. Modern hearing aids have radios in them for continuously sending audio data between the left and right sides, and they run for a week on a hearing aid battery.
- bluGill 8y agoHearing aids are sold to hunters at a much lower price (as noise protection and low noise enhancement). The same work goes into them, but they are not medical devices so they have to be affordable.
- burntwater 8y agoThose hearing aids aren't even remotely close to the $3,000 hearing aids a full-time wearer uses. It's kind of like comparing a free solar-powered swag calculator to a TI-84 graphing calculator. Although, much like the TI-84, $3,000 hearing aids probably are overpriced.
- malikolivier 8y agoComparing these two types of hearing aids is similar to comparing a magnifying glass with normal glasses. A magnifying glass might do the job good enough, and I know people who decided to not buy glasses but just use a magnifying glass to read.
- mmosta 8y agoDecent hearing aides are quite expensive, complex devices with a substantial amount of R&D and non-trivial silicon. For those who are interested, The Amp Hour has a great episode with Jørgen Jakobsen who talks about his experience in the industry and its quirks. https://theamphour.com/338-an-interview-with-jorgen-jakobsen/ https://theamphour.com/338-an-interview-with-jorgen-jakobsen...
- pkaye 8y agoHow are hearing aids priced in other countries compared to the US?
- IWeldMelons 8y agoI live in the former USSR, in a very poor country. Hearing aids here are primitive, no fancy schmancy DSP bad really cheap. $10-20 or smth.
- badwolf 8y agoBose just recently got FDA approval for their first non-prescription/self fitting hearing aids.
- afarrell 8y agoI think this is why Bose entered the market with “hearphones” to help hear people in crowded bars. So they could try to market them without spending the money to be a medical device.
- dzhiurgis 8y ago> help hear people in crowded bars. It's a tall people problem too. You can hear everyone in the bar except person in front of you, 30cm below.
- EamonnMR 8y agoThis applies to all medical everything.