6 ms·
Don’t trust Daily Mail website, Microsoft browser warns users
- s9w 8y agoNot cool. I can see that browsers want to warn people of (technically) dangerous websites. But websites that are 'wrong'? Slippiest of slopes.
- viraptor 8y agoThis is an interesting case where the website is wrong by its own admissions. The number of redactions released for Daily Mail after publication is the highest in the UK (compared to other tabloids). It's a kind of slippery slope, but it would be much worse if they made that judgement against some vaguely reasonable paper.
- beaconstudios 8y agoeither way, browser vendors should not be the arbiters of truth. I can't think of a news source that hasn't had at least some falsities published - it's the nature of the industry. Sure, the Daily Mail is notably worse than others. But to single them out for "fake news" labelling is worryingly arbitrary.
- stingraycharles 8y agoI find it’s very interesting, because isn’t this type of thing precisely what lawmakers want Facebook and the likes to do, warn people not to trust certain content? Since they’re both tools instrumental for consuming content, what makes it different when Microsoft does it?
- beaconstudios 8y agoI don't think Facebook should do it either because fundamentally I don't want any given group to have authority over whether something is true or false. I want fact-finding to be a distributed effort where claims and counter-claims can be made by reputable news outlets or individual citizen-journalists holding evidence alike. Otherwise, we allow a single entity to decide the truth by imposition, where said entity may not know all the facts or may even have its own agenda.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> But to single them out for "fake news" labelling is worryingly arbitrary. Wikipedia did it in 2017 - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/feb/08/wikipedia-bans-daily-mail-as-unreliable-source-for-website https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/feb/08/wikipedia... It's not like this is a random bolt from the blue.
- ihattendorf 8y agoBut Wikipedia isn't my browser. I don't think anyone is arguing that Daily Mail isn't garbage, just that it isn't the browser's job to decide what is and isn't garbage.
- s9w 8y agoNewsguard already managed to get installed on school and library PCs in some US states. If they succeed, they will soon be the most powerful organization in existence, as they will have total control of information. I don't blame Newsguard - of course they want more power for themselves. But I do blame Microsoft for working with them.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoThat’s dumb. Nobody is being prevented from reading the content. They’re just being warned—correctly—that the information is unreliable.
- beaconstudios 8y agothe issue at hand is how they determine reliability and where they draw the line at acceptable vs unacceptable. I'd argue the left-leaning equivalent of the Daily Mail would be BuzzFeed, complete with regularly posting skewed or outright false information (see this example from a couple of days ago: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/19/business/media/buzzfeed-news-trump-michael-cohen-mueller.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/19/business/media/buzzfeed-n...). If they want to be consistent you could argue they should place the same warning on BuzzFeed. But then how much falsity constitutes "unreliable"? And how do we warn about places people go for news that aren't news organisations, like twitter or facebook? There's loads of nonsense on those too and plenty of people rely on them as sources.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> see this example from a couple of days ago “BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the special counsel’s office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony are not accurate.” That could mean anything from "flat out wrong" to "they got a single word wrong in the reported speech but we don't want to tip anyone's hand whilst we're still working on this". It definitely doesn't warrant being described as "skewed or outright false information" until we know more, does it?
- richardknop 8y agoThat's a slippery slope though as all publications have redactions when they print stuff that's incorrect / wrong. Arguing that Daily Mail has more redactions than others is very dangerous. New York Times had to print corrections or redactions in the past, would it be acceptable for a browser to warn users that NYT should not be trusted?
- gnu8 8y agoI agree that Microsoft in particular cannot be trusted to do this. They will inevitably display the same warning if the user attempts to view, say, the Halloween documents or visit Linux.org.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoMy understanding is the service itself isn't being provided by Microsoft.
- bb101 8y agoI suppose it might serve as a useful warning for readers from other countries, especially if their country doesn't have tabloids of their own. I would say most people in the UK know to take news from certain publications with a grain of salt, but it can be far from obvious for others.
- kingofhdds 8y agoThere are no countries where there are media, but no "tabloids" (also the term can be different). The UK is not that unique as you seem to believe.
- bb101 8y agoI beg to differ. An example is Australia. Plenty of national and regional broadsheets, but no purposefully trashy tabloids that I can think of.
- wonthegame 8y agoBut do you know about Bat boy?
- unfunco 8y agoHerald Sun? It's owned by Murdoch too.
- nbabitskiy 8y agoUK is somewhat unique. As a football fan, I know way more than I'd like to about extramarital activities of the English Premiere League players. I don't read the Sun, but this knowledge permeates /r/soccer etc. It's probably related to the fact, that almost all the commenters who have a judgement about the family life of the sportsmen they've never met are British or American. All countries have vulgar media, but generally they print personal stories only after there have been charges pressed, or someone got sued.
- kingofhdds 8y ago
- kdf83 8y agoShit. This is disgraceful. One can disagree with how the DailyMail paints stories but this is simply censorship by the left.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoNo it’s not, don’t be silly. Nobody is being censored.
- renholder 8y ago>...this is simply censorship by the left. You keep using that word, I don't think it means what you think it means.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI was 100% in agreement with you up until "the left" part. Do you have any evidence that this is some sort of coordinated effort by this mysterious political group?
- nickcotter 8y agoIt’s literally the number one thing that those of my associates who identify as right wing universally agree on: there’s some kind of free speech apocalypse unfolding. They view this as censorship.
- renholder 8y ago>...which has received investment from advertising group Publicis... Any bets on NewsGuard eventually showing ads?
- kingofhdds 8y agoMy immediate reaction to a browser giving unsolicited advices about quality of the contents is to download another browser. I'm not a kid, thank you.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI'm not a kid, thank you. Yet your response is very child like.
- kingofhdds 8y agoI don't see it that way. Could it be some sort of culturally narrow stereotyping on you side? As for the topic I'm interested if you really feel it ok for you to be a subject of a soft form of parental control from a commercial entity?
- Bendingo 8y agoOn the contrary, GP is resisting the continual infantilising of Western countries by their corporates, media and governments. "to treat someone as if that person were a child, with the result that they start behaving like one" [1] https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/infantilize https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/infantil...
- claudiawerner 8y agoThe doctrine of legal paternalism is much less commonly seen now than it was in the past, with a few exceptions.
- MadraRua 8y agoSo its Snopes for the Web? There would need to be some transparency issues sorted out (i.e, we need to know who's grading the sites and that the service is open to scrutiny) but the concept is good at least.
- JdeBP 8y agoI suggest reading an actual NewsGuard "nutrition label" before commenting on what's missing from them. * https://www.newsguardtech.com/ratings/sample-nutrition-labels/ https://www.newsguardtech.com/ratings/sample-nutrition-label... Here's someone who has: * http://www.niemanlab.org/2018/08/newsguard-considers-fox-news-a-healthy-part-of-your-news-diet/ http://www.niemanlab.org/2018/08/newsguard-considers-fox-new...
- TheOperator 8y agoI think the essential feature is to be able to change databases that determine what is or is not fake news.
- chatmasta 8y agoApparently the third party "NewsGuard" service requires browsing history to be uploaded to them: https://twitter.com/gorhill/status/1085980638405148676 https://twitter.com/gorhill/status/1085980638405148676
- ilaksh 8y agoWho decides which sites have "real" news and which sites have "fake" news? A big thing missing from these discussions is the history of propaganda. I think a lot of people who are worried about "fake news" need to research that term. Propaganda is still very prevalent especially as far as war goes. Do people really think that CNN tells them the real reasons for going to war? They will say whatever the Pentagon tells them. Why? Because no one is going to risk their lives and kill other people for some technical, strategic reason or just as part of a larger military campaign. People risk their lives to fight the "bad guys" who are "evil". They need to believe its a moral cause. Don't let some giant company (or a small one) dictate what source your information comes from. If I used a Microsoft browser I would uninstall that plugin. Assuming that's an option.