10 ms·
A new documentary addresses the stigma of menstruation in India
- AmericanChopper 8y agoI’d highly recommend the movie mentioned in this article, Padman. It’s incredibly heartwarming, and the guy it’s based on is truly remarkable.
- trhway 8y ago>Indian women can be barred from entering the kitchen and handling food, kept away from family members and shunned from offering prayers during what is sheepishly referred to as “that time of the month”. sounds similar to Judaism and Islam. My pet theory is that in a warm climate with limited access to good hygiene resources (like clean running water) the "separation" practices naturally emerged as something like a way to protect the woman from infection and the others from probably things like blood borne pathogens, etc. (not that ancients knew about infections, pathogens, etc - it is just in the typical way of natural selection the societal groups who didn't practiced the "separation" fared much worse). Of course religion as always hijacked the situation and made it into another tool of oppression.
- xvilka 8y agoReligion damaged so many women lives that it is hard to even count. Probably more than war. Still most of the people don't care.
- kcmastrpc 8y agoReligion had nothing to do with it. Egomaniacs and sociopaths did, in the name of religion.
- xvilka 8y agoThe rest of the involved people are guilty for silent approval.
- tomhoward 8y agoOr, they were all living under the same tyranny.
- jessaustin 8y agoWho do you think invented/supported religion? What do you suppose their motivation was?
- sidmitra 8y agoNot sure why you were downvoted. I think you made an interesting point that i hadn't considered. You said it's your "pet theory" and people don't have to agree with it or provide counter facts. I would rather infer that it was probably to protect others around her from the so called "infection" rather than the woman herself. Either way doesn't preclude the fact that religion and societal structures(and just all around ignorance) have to share the majority of the blame here.
- kcmastrpc 8y agoprobably had something to do with the comment in the end. i agreed with everything up to that point. it's like blaming the car/alcohol for all the alcohol related car crashes that happen. just because some sociopathic asshole decides to be oppressive and they happen to follow a certain religion all of a sudden their religion is to blame?
- krapp 8y ago>just because some sociopathic asshole decides to be oppressive and they happen to follow a certain religion all of a sudden their religion is to blame? Yes, when that religion and the culture around it not only encourages that oppression, but discourages negative consequences for that oppression, and propagates that oppression across generations, and sometimes defends it with the force of law, then religion should justifiably carry the blame. In the case of menstruation and other women's issues, what should merely be medical and hygiene concerns are conflated into "the will of God" because a holy book or scripture says that women and their bodies are impure, and as a result the imposition of religious dogma upon society has had a direct and negative consequence for women that it hasn't had for men, or that it likely wouldn't have in a purely secular context.
- nailer 8y agoEverywhere, pads and tampons should be looked at like toilet paper. Not taxed, put in toilets by whoever runs them, and in the rare case someone steals them - then OK they're obviously dirt poor no big deal.
- dankiz 8y agoFirst, toilet paper is taxed at the same rates pads and tampons are. Second, stealing is not OK. And if they put pads and/or tampons in toilets they'll disappear in a matter of minutes. If you think only a dirt poor woman would steal them, you are wrong.
- mcv 8y agoStealing is wrong, but there are products where, if someone were to steal them in small amounts, I'm kinda okay with it. I have no experience with pads and tampons and I don't know if they belong in this category, but when I buy bread, I leave it in my bike while I buy other groceries. If someone were to steal my bread (hasn't happened yet), I'd assume they probably need it more than I do.
- dankiz 8y ago>there are products where, if someone were to steal them in small amounts, I'm kinda okay with it. Okay. I am not. We could have a national referendum, "are you okay with people stealing your stuff?". Let's see what happens. The day the bread disappears from your bike, I can assure the chances that someone is going to eat it are slim. He'll probably just throw it away for laughs.
- dijit 8y agoThis is a really odd stance to take; and a horrible argument. It's not "OK" to steal anything, but you risk toilet paper being stolen by having it in a public place. The loss of a roll (or 2) of toilet papers is very low compared to the convenience of not having to bring your own toilet roll everywhere. We live in a society and that involves a certain level of (policed) trust, if the cost of having a great convenience is that it sometimes gets stolen then if the cost is low enough and the convenience is high enough it's worth it.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoThe story of the entrepreneur behind this is a stunning example of sheer not-giving-up-ness - he lost his wife, his job, became a social outcast but built a social company - keeping funds in local areas, giving jobs to local women not multinational pharmas He's pretty much a hero I look forward to watching this. An older reference: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-26260978 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-26260978
- deepaksurti 8y agoThat is Arunachalam M, his story was also made into a movie. [1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pad_Man_(film) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pad_Man_(film)
- hycaria 8y agoI hate how the push (even lobbying I'd say) for pads and tampons is never questionned. It's expensive, it produces tons of waste, but most of all it creates dependent customers. Yet it's acclaimed as selfless ? Give these women cups and they're settled for life.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI don’t understand why tampons and pads are the primary recommended methods for dealing with period blood (at least in the US). Cups are more sanitary, better-suited for extended internal use, and are often reusable. Some cups can even be worn during sex. I think it’s largely a matter of being uninformed, in turn likely because of the stigma associated with a perfectly natural bodily function.
- hycaria 8y agoThere's little profit to be made for a $30 lifelong purchase.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> I think it’s largely a matter of being uninformed, in turn likely because of the stigma associated with a perfectly natural bodily function. There's a lot of stigma there. Some women can't find comfortable cups, some have flows too heavy to use a cup, and some don't like the idea of washing out a bloody, clot covered menstrual cup in a public washroom's sink.
- webninja 8y agoShare a product link?
- mschuster91 8y ago> Give these women cups and they're settled for life. Comparing to sterile-packaged pads/tampons, cups need access for the wearer to a sterilization source - be it a microwave, clean (!) hot water, or chemical agents. Cups are something for Western populations where reliable access is given, but not for unsanitary conditions in developing countries.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Some 23% of girls drop out of school upon reaching puberty, humiliated by their peers and unable to access clean, private toilets. What I find disturbing is that school peers humiliate each other over menstruation. Nearly all girls get it during puberty, so why are they shaming each other? And for the boys who shame their classmates, why aren't their teachers holding them accountable?!
- whatshisface 8y agoWhat you're looking at is a cultural trait, everyone does it because everyone does it. In the US we have a few of these but they're difficult to notice because you're used to them. >why aren't their teachers holding them accountable?! The teachers grew up with and participated in the same practices.
- pembrook 8y agoIn a country without access to toilets and clean water, why would they have the resources for 1st world level teacher oversight? This is kind of like asking why water is wet. Many children (likely due to their parents) are insecure savages with under-developed empathy. Humiliating each other is simply what they do. Hence why we force them to undergo decades of education outside the home to learn how to relate to each other in a civilized, healthy way by adulthood.
- zanny 8y agoTo be fair, plenty of first world children can be perfectly competent secure savages with self-centered complexes and self-gratification perpetuated by their parents and family wealth. Kids really don't learn empathy innately. It has to be taught, and its not something to just lecture, it needs to be learned through experience.
- fipar 8y ago> What I find disturbing is that school peers humiliate each other over menstruation. Nearly all girls get it during puberty, so why are they shaming each other? And for the boys who shame their classmates, why aren't their teachers holding them accountable?! I agree its disturbing, but it's not surprising. School-age people can be very cruel. For a US (in the 1990s) perspective on menstruation-related shaming, check out the lyrics to "My red self" by Heavens to Betsy, for example. They were school-aged when they wrote that. Edit: s/Heavents/Heavens/
- latchkey 8y agoI'm in Vietnam and friends with someone who built a business around promoting and selling silicon re-usable cups for women in VN. She said that a lot of what she goes up against is the train of thought that a woman will no longer be a virgin. I find this really depressing and sad as it makes no logical sense at all.
- waterpowder 8y agoHi! could you share the name of the business, please?
- latchkey 8y agoPlease contact me privately. I don't think HN takes kindly to advertising... even for a good purpose like this.
- tway111 8y agoAh, the good old "superpower by 2020" strikes again.
- amriksohata 8y agotrust me, look at america and the states living in poverty, you dont need to have good sanitation to qualify as a superpower, you need money
- rishav_sharan 8y agoIts a developing nation with its share of problems. Was this snark really necessary?
- sctb 8y agoWe've banned this account for trolling.
- tway111 8y agoOf course you did.
- growlist 8y ago'On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.'
- pferde 8y agoHas it ever occurred to you to simply... not click on an article that does not interest you, and simply move on? Shocking, I know.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago"anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity."
- mahin 8y agoMy partner and I face similar challenges in Pakistan. We sell cups instead of pads, so we get the stigma of menstruation being a taboo as well as the reluctance to insert cups because they are thought to make a women lose her virginity. The virginity issue doesn't make any sense, but it's a big part of the culture here. It's good to see posts like these showing the way people think about menstruation in places like India.
- codecrusade 8y agoA marketing pitch for sanitary pads. Cloth and traditional alternatives worked wonderfully in India for thousands of years, but who listens.. >>Nielsen, a research firm, estimates that around 70% of women in the country cannot afford sanitary products: 300m use unhygienic alternatives like newspapers, dry leaves and cotton rags.
- vict00ms 8y ago>>70% of all reproductive diseases in India are caused by poor menstrual hygiene From the article. I don't agree with your assessment that these "traditional alternatives" are working "wonderfully".
- codecrusade 8y agoHave you been in India? Do you know anything about menstural hygiene?
- adrianN 8y agoI'm not so sure that dry leaves work just as well as pads.
- codecrusade 8y agoMore here Disposable Pads Are A Hazard, A Look At Some Alternatives https://www.outlookindia.com/magazine/story/disposable-pads-are-a-hazard-a-look-at-some-alternatives/301031 https://www.outlookindia.com/magazine/story/disposable-pads-...
- thisisit 8y agoAt the YC Bangalore event last year, we had a guy who was developing a disposable and water soluble pad. The pricing was too high for these things to be mass market, though. Unfortunately I don't remember the name. But it would have an interesting product for a startup.
- codecrusade 8y agoI was penalized by some idiot from HN for saying cloth based alternatives are more safer and eco friendly than sanitary pads. HN is one Soviet marxist den with no freedom of speech.
- sctb 8y agoAt the risk of sounding authoritarian (luckily only in the domain of trivial internet comments), could you please not post like this and follow the guidelines instead? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- raubtier 8y agoOkay, it was a shame for them. But why would any Westerner bother? Such things are just an unconscious way of shifting the focus from the disintegrating Western society.
- lawlessone 8y ago>Such things are just an unconscious way of shifting the focus from the disintegrating Western society. What are you on about?
- RankingMember 8y agoYes, instead of giving any shits about anything outside our borders, let's all look inward and think real hard about the long-foretold-with-wailing-and-gnashing-of-teeth "disintegration of Western society", to which a rigidly self-centered mindset certainly couldn't be a contributor!
- moate 8y agoSome of us don't care about "Western society" as much as "humans". Also, some of the people on this site are, spoiler, from Asia! They might be interested in this. But you do you bro.
- thewhitetulip 8y agoAs recently as 70yrs ago, women needed to drain all blood in a utensil. That's why the tradition was formed of 'women staying in one room one corner during periods' This was due to obvious reason that if she moves then it'll make everything bloody. The issue is, people don't understand the reason behind such traditions. Funny anecdote. A guru had 4 students. They used to meditate together by lighting a small bonfire. Now the guru had a cat so he asked his students to bring a rope so he could tie the cat. 50yrs later guru passed away and now their tradition is 'have meditation near bonfire' but bring a cat and a rope and tie it outside the room. Failure to understand the reason behind traditions makes ppl think women r impure. They used to be impure during periods when there weren't sanitary napkins. But now its not the case.
- hartator 8y ago> They used to be impure during periods when there weren't sanitary napkins. Are you saying women used to be impure before pads? Are you serious?
- meestaahjoshee 8y agothats not what he/she is saying
- hartator 8y agoRe-read parent.
- elliekelly 8y agoThat's exactly what they're saying: > They used to be impure during periods when there weren't sanitary napkins. But now its not the case.
- thewhitetulip 8y agoYou seem to not understand what you are reading. If you bleed then the blood is on your body. That makes you technically "impure" The same logic is being peddled by retards in this century to say women r imoure during periods. Learn to read objectively and if you can't then keep your ignorant thoughts with yourself otherwise you go around announcing your ignorance.
- vinayms 8y agoI wonder how many of the posters here pontificating on various methods/products are women, and how many men have actually discussed this topic in depth (no pun) with females they know personally. As a man, I think men must stop being opinionated wrt two specific matters about women - menstruation and childbirth - as its impossible for us to imagine/simulate the real ordeal.
- fgheorghe 8y agoWhere are feminists when you need them.