4 ms·
Curious how this compares with Chocolatey
by tracker1 8y ago
Curious how this compares with Chocolatey
- alexeldeib 8y agoI’ve been converting as much as I can from Chocolatey to scoop, mostly because the install experience (no admin/uac). I had a great experience, especially after adding the “extras” bucket. The last time I tried (a year or more ago) I found a lot of apps missing. Seems that has improved quite a bit.
- skrebbel 8y agoLinux dependency managers are just that: they manage dependencies. Most Linux programs expect particular libraries to be installed system-wide. Chocolatey was modeled after this concept, with packages that need other packages, volunteer package maintainers, a hosted package repository, etc. All this comes with a fair amount of complexity. Most Windows applications, however, are fully self contained. They ship their dependencies right inside the installer. The key insight behind scoop is that on Windows you don't need a dependency manager. You just use need something that can download and extract installers without all the next, next, ok nonsense and without needing admin rights. So that's scoop. It downloads an installer from the program's website, extracts the files to a directory under your homedir, and sets up a few PATHs and symlinks. It has no repository that needs to be hosted and maintained: after all, installers come straight from the source. And the definitions of which program can download which version from where and what should happen next are tiny JSON files managed on scoop's GitHub repo. Want to tell scoop about a new version of your favorite program? Create a PR. Chocolatey is a great effort that has taught many Windows users that yes, we can have that apt-get goodness too. But I hope that Scoop takes over as the de facto install-software tool. It's so much simpler with very few downsides. Its design is spectacularly good.
- Zekio 8y agoScoop has support for dependencies, and it is really easy to fit into PowerShell scripts :)
- skrebbel 8y agoTrue, but its dependency support is much simpler than that of competing tools. I don't think it has fancy version resolution stuff and I don't it needs it. It's usually dependencies on other programs, eg scoop itself depends on git (to pull install instructions from GitHub). That's different than having a system wide shared libffmpeg.
- toyg 8y agoFrom what you say, it seems to be like Arch Pacman as opposed to Debian Apt (chocolatey): upstream is largely untouched and the package managers is basically just orchestrating. Is that correct?
- skrebbel 8y agoI guess - I have no experience with Pacman. Scoop doesn't even (currently) have the concept of package maintainers. Anyone can make a PR with bumped versions or other fixes (though I understand that as Scoop's popularity increases, some cracks in that model are starting to show).
- rococode 8y agoI was curious too, turns out it's addressed in the wiki: https://github.com/lukesampson/scoop/wiki/Chocolatey-Comparison https://github.com/lukesampson/scoop/wiki/Chocolatey-Compari... Short version: - Installs to ~/scoop/ by default. - No UAC popups, doesn't require admin rights. - Doesn't pollute your path. - Doesn't use NuGet. - Simpler than packaging. - Simpler app repository. - Can't always install a specific version of a program. - Focuses on developer tools.
- fxfan 8y agoCan I install MS office using scoop? Or other proprietary software that usually install globally and need admin permissions? Choco can do that (not that I am affiliated). Also, I like my "path being polluted". The least these programs can do is symlink to a single binary directory so I can run them from anywhere. Simpler repository is just a euphemism for- we have little. As an end user I have no business whether it does it doesn't use nuget. I'm not trying to diss - I respect and appreciate not players in this space but its important to say it like it is. Also, given how "open" choco ecosystem is- I'd love to see non-official tools on top of that.
- amanzi 8y agoI gave up on Choco because it got too hard. I could never tell which package I should install, I was never sure if I should be installing from an elevated prompt or not, and then they added a bunch of premium plans to choose between with a confusing feature matrix.
- GordonS 8y agoI really want Chocolately to suceed, but so many packages are outdated, and there are a lot of duplicates, so you often don't know which one you should get. I find the web UI very clunky too.
- yyyymmddhhmmss 8y agoHave you ever tried to uninstall Chocolatey? When I tried doing that for the first time, it was a terror so I never looked back.
- mhd 8y agoThe important metric here would be package activity. If you don't have the package or its out of date, all other benefits don't really matter. Granted, in the Windowsing world, package count is a lot lower, as it's all about big applications and not minor libraries and utilities as in Unix (or worse). So it's easier to catch up. The best thing for a Windows packager would be some kind of automatic change detecting site powering it -- so if there's a new release for WinWidget appearing on the Download section of Frobnicorp. Inc, the recipe for the previous release is tested and updated.
- setquk 8y agoChocolatey repository is a mire of abandonment and nuget is utterly unreliable so the first thing that comes to mind is "favourably"