4 ms·
Is it impossible to do this safely? Just like with my car, it would be really convenient when holding kids and a load of their stuff to not have to fish out th
by lordnacho 8y ago
Is it impossible to do this safely?
Just like with my car, it would be really convenient when holding kids and a load of their stuff to not have to fish out the keys.
I suppose there's the issue of your landlord locking you out if they're unhappy with something, but surely that is not purely a technological issue.
- who-knows95 8y agoit's more just the huge risk right? so many factors become part of the threat model, when you could stick to the physical lock, and really limit it. https://twitter.com/internetofshit?lang=en https://twitter.com/internetofshit?lang=en is a pretty good example. you could make a rfid chip reader part of your lock, but even that has weakness. http://www.astclock.com/astclocks-blog/advantages-of-rfid-door-locks/ http://www.astclock.com/astclocks-blog/advantages-of-rfid-do... tldr: limit your damn threat model/inconvenience.
- Thorrez 8y agoI don't think security of entry to the apartment is the main concern (because most locks can be picked fairly easily, and criminals force doors regardless of lock). I think privacy, network security, and availability are the bigger issues.
- who-knows95 8y agowell, i do agree, the network and availability are my main issues. if a criminal is going to break you door, it's going to happen. but, i think people would be more suspicious of someone picking a door lock, rather then waving a Chip and the door allowing them access. i know, alot of hotels weren't surprised to learn their room doors were amazing weak. https://www.wired.co.uk/article/hotel-hack-digital-lock-door-system-fsecure-assa-abloy https://www.wired.co.uk/article/hotel-hack-digital-lock-door... if you want a good physical lock the ANSI Grading System is a good place to start.
- Lazare 8y agoIn theory, yes, it's possible to do this safely. But offhand I can think of several horror stories about smart locks, and no good stories. The tech just seems absurdly immature at this point. And this product, in particular, is apparently known for glitching and not working, so...
- daxterspeed 8y agoOn top of the software aspects many smart locks neglect the actual locking mechanism leaving the lock vulnerable to easy tricks like shimming. Smart locks also have to consider how they'll function without electricity. An exposed slot for a battery could let an attacker instantly fry the lock from the outside.
- 300bps 8y agoAn exposed slot for a battery could let an attacker instantly fry the lock from the outside. A long time ago I got drunk at my birthday party so my wife drove us back to the beach house we rented. She parked my car so that it was about five inches overhanging someone’s driveway. Their driveway wasn’t blocked but it was a dick move and they retaliated by shaving off candle wax into my car’s door locks. Fortunately I always used remote unlock but back then most people still used physical keys to unlock their car. People can mess or destroy any lock. There are legitimate concerns about electronic locks for sure but I don’t understand setting the bar so much higher for them than mechanical locks.
- michaelt 8y agoI don’t understand setting the bar so much higher for them than mechanical locks. Based on the smart lock reviews I've seen on youtube channels that review locks, rejecting 98% of smart locks on the market doesn't require that you hold the smart locks to a higher standard than the mechanical locks. Because the reviews I've seen indicate almost all smart locks fall a long way short of the security of equally priced mechanical locks.
- daxterspeed 8y ago
- KingMachiavelli 8y agoKey code locks are pretty convienient since you don't even need a phone yet aren't connected to any externel network and they allow a normal key to be used as a backup. A lot of them can be hooked up to the internet vie Z-wave or similar but they don't have to be.
- TarpitCarnivore 8y agoEven better are the ones that are keypads + smartlock. We'll probably be swapping over to one of the Yale locks which has a keypad & uses August's tech for the smart part.
- detaro 8y agoJust local RFID tokens without internet connection? If you use a system with properly secure tokens that's probably a relatively safe option. Same with key codes: internet management is not really needed for that. Of course access could be properly secured, but vendors have a really bad record of actually getting that right.
- johannes1234321 8y agoThe tokens being secure is not enough. The system also has to check latency etc. to prevent repeater attacks. Imagine a scenario like that: You leave your car in a parking lot. One attacker follows you with a repeater. Once you're around the corner the second attacker approaches your car and opens it via the repeated radio signal and starts it. A while ago there had been a small debate on this topic, as attackers actually used such an approach to break into cars (sometimes even stealing them) https://www.wired.com/2017/04/just-pair-11-radio-gadgets-can-steal-car/ https://www.wired.com/2017/04/just-pair-11-radio-gadgets-can...
- smileysteve 8y agoA code repeater seems like a lot of work when standard tumbler locks are bypassed by a credit card, $10 lock pick set, a strong kick.
- johannes1234321 8y agoAccording to that wired article the repeater is $10 as well and lockpicking needs a little practice and skill, using a repeater not. :)
- tialaramex 8y agoYou can sidestep this if the token needs to be explicitly activated. Unlike turning a key in a mechanical lock this needn't be something that requires dexterity, just any positive action e.g. pressing a button.
- skywhopper 8y agoCar locks are one thing. They are hackable, but only in a very targeted and location-specific manner, basically the same risk as a physical key. But this is a centrally controlled system in which your landlord and a third party you have no control over are monitoring your movements and can remotely unlock the door via an Internet-connected device. So it's remotely monitorable and hackable. And since there's no physical presence required to monitor or hack it, it's actually a much bigger risk than remote car locks. Also, cars are very different than homes. Typically we don't store truly valuable and irreplaceable items in our cars, unlike our homes. Typically we don't sleep in our cars, unlike our homes. You can easily see if someone is approaching your car, or trying to get in, when you are in it. Not necessarily the case with your home.