4 ms·
> The "eat ugly fruit!" movement is classist as FUCK. You've got to have a debilitating level of ignorance to assume that if Whole Paycheck Market doesn't stock
by feross 8y ago
> The "eat ugly fruit!" movement is classist as FUCK. You've got to have a debilitating level of ignorance to assume that if Whole Paycheck Market doesn't stock ugly fruit, it must be getting "wasted."
It is possible to not know much about the agricultural industry without being "classist as fuck." There are an infinite number of things one can learn about and a finite amount of time. While the content is interesting, I find the condescending tone off-putting.
Are there advantages to this communication style that I'm missing?
- dankusmcmeme 8y ago>Are there advantages to this communication style that I'm missing? Wokeness points
- zeroname 8y ago> It is possible to not know much about the agricultural industry without being "classist as fuck." If you start a social movement, that's the point where you should do some basic research. > While the content is interesting, I find the condescending tone off-putting. Pack it up fellows, the tone police has arrived! > Are there advantages to this communication style that I'm missing? Ordinary people love it when affluent urban do-gooders get teared a new one. That just can't happen with minced words. As a leftist, you had better find some common ground with common folk when you're carrying around a PhD.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoAmen also being straight and to the point is not always condescending
- giancarlostoro 8y agoAs long as you share useful information instead of just hateful ranting with nothing for any reader to gain I don't mind it.
- teekert 8y agoWell, she does say it's "enraging" and I can imagine (if her story is true) so it gives some real emotion to the story. Is it most effective? I don't know, depends on the goal I guess.
- jeswin 8y agoI guess the author was upset that a great many people parroted the 'ugly fruits get disposed' line without doing any research. I might have mentioned it myself, because it was all over the news. I can understand why someone who works in the industry would find this frustrating - it's basically just fake news and the damage is real. A rebuttal would get nowhere near the press the sensationalist original story would get. The lesson from this is - share stories only within your area of expertise.
- vasco 8y agoWhat is the damage? What does it matter which fruits are bought first at the supermarket?
- icebraining 8y agoThe ugly fruit movement is much bigger than that, and has its own markets and sale areas. Farmers (often in collaboration with startups (not all for-profit)) will divert this produce to sell to the middle-class people worried about this, since they pay more than the jam makers, but at the end of the market day some will throw away leftovers which are not worth the time to haul back, sort, etc. So it can actually increase food waste.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoAre not you assuming the varieties used for canning etc are the same for sale in supermarkets.
- frobozz 8y agoThis is precisely what the OP (with expertise in this field) is stating. See the statement about Honeycrisp apples. Yes there are varieties more suited to different purposes, and there may be some that are grown specifically for those other purposes (e.g. a variety might be selectively bred with higher pectin for jam-making), but commercial producers of things like soup, pies, jams etc are a prime destination for ugly instances of supermarket-shelf varieties.
- philwelch 8y agoIf you start a massive flame war, you get a bigger audience. People come for the drama and once they're there, they're listening to you.
- pizza 8y agoThe author is just expressing their frustration of having to constantly correct this particular strain of naivete. Contained naivete (e.g. keeping incorrect opinions to oneself) is mostly harmless to everybody, but if naivete spreads that's bad. Of course, there's also the "outrage gets you likes" aspect, but I guess if I were in the agriculture field I might have reason to genuinely be somewhat outraged. I probably wouldn't call it classist af for someone to not understand efficiencies of agricultural logistics, though..
- coldtea 8y ago>The author is just expressing their frustration of having to constantly correct this particular strain of naivete Why do they have to "constantly correct" it? What is their business? Besides, it's not really "naivete". Eating uglier fruit and vegetables is still good advice, to not get sucked buyinh tasteless but nice-looking produce that selectively breeds for size and color over taste, and even uses BS tricks like coloring and such to make it more appealing.
- crispyambulance 8y ago> Eating uglier fruit and vegetables is still good advice... The OP was describing the "naive" people who shop at Whole Foods (or other premium grocery stores) and then complain about the wasted or missing "ugly" produce. They're thinking that if the ugly stuff isn't at their fancy grocery store it must have been thrown away when, in fact, the "ugly" produce has merely been diverted away to other vendors and uses which they're simply not aware of. The irony that is lost upon them is that by walking into their fancy grocery store, they're basically signalling to the grocery store that they're willing to pay a high price for what the grocery store and their demographic has deemed "unblemished" produce that meets certain criteria for size and appearance. In a sense it is totally fair to call out such naivete. Instead of complaining to Whole Foods, these folks should just shop elsewhere. The price will be lower, the flavors will be different (usually better), and yes, there will more blemishes and unexpected size and appearance. To actually find that "ugly" produce one needs to go to the discount/ethnic groceries. In the Northeastern US, that just means finding the Asian and Hispanic produce vendors and going there for produce. There are _some_ other vendors which are beginning to catch on, "Produce Junction" comes to mind.
- caymanjim 8y agoIgnorance is no excuse. You might not be classist if you're too ignorant to understand the thing you're passionately protesting, but you're many other voluntarily bad things.
- alexashka 8y agoTwitter has had enough people posting in anger, that it has become culturally acceptable for anyone to do it. I can't help but wonder about the upbringing of the folks who act out in anger, in public (posting on the internet is public). Would you talk this way around your parents, peers, kids? I hope not. The internet is not any different - they're someone's parents, peers and kids, reading your posts.
- zeroname 8y ago> I can't help but wonder about the upbringing of the folks who act out in anger, in public... Come on, man. It's just a rant. I seriously have to wonder about your upbringing. > The internet is not any different - they're someone's parents, peers and kids, reading your posts. So what?
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI’m guessing the kind of folks who post in anger care more for the drama they create and the followers that come with that, than their public image.
- jchw 8y agoI think it's pretty simple: People absolutely love drama. Calling someone out feels good, and people love to follow along. It gets irritating when people make super broad accusations like this, but I believe it's in a similar vein to how politics on Twitter is mostly people trying to out snark everyone else. In this situation I'd say the consumer is the victim of being misled, but you stir up a lot more people by accusing both parties! Others are pointing out that the author is rightly frustrated. Of course, but most people don't accidentally make broad accusations of problematic isms, either.
- beaconstudios 8y agoThis is a pernicious problem in modern politics in general. Sell the easy-to-react-to emotional story to people and they'll turn it into some big movement without stopping to check the facts. This leads to people believing lies and advocating for existing sensible systems to be changed because they believed those lies. > Of course, but most people don't accidentally make broad accusations of problematic isms, either. Have you been on twitter before?
- chasd00 8y ago"Dirty little secrets Dirty little lies We got our dirty little fingers in everybody's pie We love to cut you down to size We love dirty laundry We can do "The Innuendo" We can dance and sing When it's said and done we haven't told you a thing We all know that Kraft is king Give us dirty laundry!" Dirty Laundry - Don Henley
- iNerdier 8y agoI work for a farmer who makes apple juice of various varieties. He used to use raspberries that were ‘seconds’ which wouldn’t fit supermarket criteria for selling by themselves. He pressed and used them for juicing for one variety he made. As of last year the farm he bought them off no longer bothers to harvest seconds because it’s not worth it to them in the cost of labour to pick, sort and sell them. So yes in certain cases this fruit is being wasted and people paying more for it would cause less of it to rot.
- oasisbob 8y agoHow is the farm harvesting? Raspberries are especially perishable - especially when damaged. Eventually I think everyone involved needs to admit that the economics just don't work, and that at smaller scales, composting isn't awful. For large raspberry growers here in WA, most berries are mechanically harvested and sent off to be processed into juices, extracts, concentrates, etc. One producer I know ships them over the Cascades in milk tankers. (Faster, fresher, less handling.) They can go from the farm to the factory line in under eight hours. Berries by the pint, and even IQF (individually-quick frozen) berries command a HUGE premium, and are often hand harvested. You can't take those labor costs downmarket and make the economics work.
- threwawasy1228 8y agoI just wanted to chime in and comment further on your statement. >that at smaller scales, composting isn't awful. And note that in cases like this, having worked on an organic fruit farm, it is often very difficult to actually compost the unused fruit seconds. Very acidic fruit in large quantities does not generally make for a good compost. It requires a lot more work to deal with a mountain of lemons for instance in a compost to get a usable soil composition. Most people don't ever encounter issues like this because a households normal compost is varied enough that you won't have this problem. A lot of times nothing will grow or you won't get a very good yield out of really acidic soil for the most part. All this is to say that the fruit in your example is probably literally being put to no purpose whatsoever and is almost assuredly not being composted.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 8y ago>Are there advantages to this communication style that I'm missing? It does make the author feel superior, which saves on psychoanalysis bills.
- yzb 8y agoBy calling something classist you're showing you're a leftist, which is necessary in certain circles where not being politically aligned is a death sentence; see "virtue signalling": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_signalling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_signalling
- icebraining 8y agoI (as a left-wing sympathiser) actually agree this is signaling; the people who make up the ugly fruit movement are mostly on the same circle as those who use "classist", and using the same language will get them to pay more attention.
- aaron695 8y ago> It is possible to not know much about the agricultural industry without being "classist as fuck." That's fine, so you won't be in anyway part of the "The "eat ugly fruit!" movement" would you? Unless you're a classist fuck who just likes the arrogance of the appearance of eating better fruit and veggies than others.
- lucideer 8y agoThe offputting tone wouldn't be quite as objectionable (imo) if the argument wasn't so FUCKing wrong. > Most "ugly" produce gets turned into soups, sauces, salsa, jam, ice cream, etc. You think that stuff gets made from the pretty fruit & veggies?! jeebus, think about it for a minute I've thought about it, and yes, that stuff gets made from the pretty fruit & veggies. Sure, a LOT of it gets made from the rejected "ugly" fruit from other supply chains, and—also—even in cases where it's being made from the pretty ones, they're not filtering out the "ugly" ones, so generally all the food is used in those cases. BUT, no, we don't have a perfect interoperable system where every ag supplier has equal and complimentary arrangements with supermarkets and salsa factories. Not every packing house is the same (not every one separates out the uglies), and not every one supplies salsa makers. There is PLENTY of waste in between. > The amt of produce wasted bc of labor problems (can't get a crew to harvest) & bad weather (melons that rot in the field bc it's too hot & wet, etc) WAY outstrips produce thrown out bc it's "ugly." She may be right here (would like to see some data, but still—the statement seems plausible), but in what way does that nullify the fact that plenty of produce is still thrown out? In what way does labour/weather-problem-related waste mean we shouldn't also try to reduce waste in areas where we very easily can? > IT GOES TO THE GROCERY STORES THAT POOR PEOPLE SHOP AT This sentence from the same person who just used the phrase "classist as fuck"!?
- ryanlol 8y ago>This sentence from the same person who just used the phrase "classist as fuck"!? There's nothing classist about acknowledging the fact that poor and rich people often shop in different stores.
- krustyburger 8y agoThe notion that frugality implies poverty is classist, not to mention inaccurate.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoDo you deny that there are both rich people and poor people? Do you deny that there are high-end, expensive grocery stores, and low-end, cheap grocery stores? Do you believe poor people shop at those high-end stores? If you answered 3x NO, then nitpicking this point as being "classist" is, to paraphrase, dumb as fuck.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoIt seems like pretty normal Twitter style?
- dxq 8y agoignorance doesn't make your assumptions less classist. similarly, no matter how ignorant you are of their meaning, racial slurs are still racist. if you're perpetuating a prejudice of class, you're participating in classism. if "fuck" hurts your feelings, or if the tone is too "off-putting" to bother understanding the message, maybe that's a You Problem.
- kristianc 8y ago> Are there advantages to this communication style that I'm missing? Invoking an offended identity group is a necessary condition of getting something to fly on Twitter.
- dkarl 8y agoI think what this quote is responding to is people disseminating some first world millennial's first uninformed guess about an issue as if were a revolution and a blessing to the world, instead of stopping to think that their precious intellectual virtues are not limited to people of their class, education, and supposed intelligence. The idea that our enlightened attitudes set us apart from the rest of unwashed humanity is our fake news -- the stuff we consume unreflectively because it flatters us and plays nicely with our prejudices. Presented in a neutral context, the idea that the agricultural industry was throwing away significant quantities of produce because of aesthetic flaws would meet a lot of skepticism. Presented in the context of you are special because you understand how wrong this practice is and special people like us can help save the world by fixing this problem the idea gets uncritically accepted and widely shared on social media. Calling people "classist as fuck" is designed to startle and threaten exactly the people who tend to accept these narratives uncritically, and put them in a frame of mind to consider that they might be wrong. Whatever the truth of the issue is, we won't get there unless we stop seeing ourselves as the hero of the story.
- subjectsigma 8y ago>...and put them in a frame of mind to consider that they might be wrong. You are entirely correct, but I think what GP is saying is that there's a very specific kind of person who goes from being insulted on the Internet to open to reflection and it's not most people.
- dkarl 8y agoThat's true when they're reacting to criticism from outside their tribe, but "classist as fuck" (and the whole rest of the rant) sounds like it comes from the same perspective that people were trying to inhabit by buying into the "rescue ugly produce" story. This creates a "the calls are coming from inside the house" moment that makes people nervous that they're on the wrong side of the issue, so when the issue comes to their doorstep (somebody is marketing some "ugly produce" product or service to them) they might look into the specifics instead of blithely accepting it at face value.
- 8y ago
- vertex-four 8y agoA behaviour can be classist, whether there is intent or not. Similarly, some hiring practices wind up preferring men over women or vice versa, and are thus sexist. Whether that was the intent or not, the outcome is the same.
- peterwwillis 8y agoBut the irony is so good! She's being a dick to the people she's supposedly trying to inform, telling them that their misguided acts to try to "save the wasted food" are for naught, and that they are classist. Yet claiming everyone who isn't informed has "a debilitating level of ignorance" and is classist, is classist itself! (And ableist!) I think social media is designed to perpetuate superiority complexes. The vocal minority that post most often seem to think a lot of themselves and not much of everyone else.
- mimixco 8y agoThe most heavily funded "ugly produce" subscription box got all the way through their Shark Tank episode without anyone even bringing this up.