4 ms·
> The practitioner there did an electrocardiogram and said the left side of my heart was slightly enlarged, but my discomfort was probably just gas. Don’t worry
by agumonkey 8y ago
> The practitioner there did an electrocardiogram and said the left side of my heart was slightly enlarged, but my discomfort was probably just gas. Don’t worry, I was told: “Your heart’s not just going to stop. You’re not going to drop dead tomorrow.” But that’s what almost happened.
This is worrying. The habits of doctors can kill. They're not cautious enough. My grand mother was misdiagnosed (not coronary but cardiovascular). My aunt was misdiagnosed and sent home. I had clear cardiovascular issues but got laughed at by half the people I talked to.
Non invasive diagnosis is one the few places where I do want tech to get one or two more decimals of precision.
- cm2012 8y agoToo much caution makes doctor advice useless. If they tell you to go waste time and money at the hospital every time there's a 1% chance of an issue, you won't actually go when it matters. That's one reason I try to ask doctors to estimate % risk. On this note: WebMD is not a doctor but has the same issue. There's no differentiating between a real emergency issue and a CYA liability one.
- baddox 8y agoDo doctors have any training that would equip them to give a remotely accurate risk probability estimate?
- arcticfox 8y agoIn my experience doctors are terrible at this, although it's supposed to be basically their entire job. I really think they should get more training in it, or some type of Bayes-esque tool to make what they're thinking explicit.
- XorNot 8y agoBut the reality is the patients don't understand the numbers, and in the OPs case a % risk doesn't mean much if it happens to you.
- Alex3917 8y ago> really think they should get more training in it, or some type of Bayes-esque tool They have those online. If you're in your 30s and have a reasonably healthy lifestyle and don't smoke, then your risk of dying from a cardiac event over a ten year period is likely somewhere between 0.25% and 0.5%, depending on how much you exercise and genetic factors. If anything, Bayesian logic is what leads doctors to ignore signs of heart attacks in young people in the first place.
- cm2012 8y agoMy wife's current psychiatrist is awesome at this - he quotes the scientific literature for relative risk levels when talking about medicine changes or interactions.
- agumonkey 8y agoThat's why I'm asking for more non invasive diagnostics and not experience based "you're fine [and it would cost too much to check further]". I won't die because or someone's habits.
- carbocation 8y agoThat's not a resolution to the disagreement, though; that's just one side of it. The disagreement is about how to balance the cost of false negatives against the cost of additional testing. As an aside, an EKG is not remotely the most important part of diagnosis for myocardial infarction; that's the job of the person taking the history. (Myocardial infarction cannot be diagnosed purely from ECG.)
- agumonkey 8y agoCost is fallacious. Medical world is stuck in pre advanced electronics era where any device would cost a ton and they rely on companies to make new devices but it's a lucrative market with twisted incentives. We need a musk like character to shake the medical diagnosis status quo. ps: I don't want to spend my life obsessing about monitoring my vitals but I'd still prefer to have the option rather than relying on blind faith.
- ui-explorer12 8y ago>> We need a musk like character to shake the medical diagnosis status quo. You first to trust your life and your loved ones to the SpaceX or Tesla of the medical world. But - disruption! Fake it till you make it!
- agumonkey 8y agoTesla used to be very safety focused. Not that much since autopilot. SpaceX is still extremely impressive in terms of progress/accident ratio.
- carbocation 8y ago
- austincheney 8y agoI started running aggressively last year and developed bracycardia for the first time. The change to my physiology was pronounced. I was faster and stronger than ever before (even compared to high school performance as I was almost breaking a 12 minute two mile) and my resting pulse rate was in the 40s. I was almost 39 then. I learned some things from that were never clear before. It’s more about the journey than the goal. I was running on a treadmill and started after recovering from surgery. I started at an 8 minute mile pace and could barely run a mile. My goal was to increase the distance instead of speed and gradually worked up to a 10k (50 mins) 5 days a week. Then I was able to work on speed and resistance here and there. I have asthma and remember running through an attack on one occasion to make my distance goal and break from a performance plateau. At the time I was eating a lot of fatty, greasy, meaty foods. The foods were heavy and high in cholesterol. I had tried the ketosis diet the summer before and lost 25 pounds, but I was not intentionally practicing any diet at this time I was running. You don’t achieve performance over night. It’s similar to programming in that it takes practice solving hard problems and listening deeply to your environment. With enough practice and persistence you make goal and are changed as a result.
- travisoneill1 8y agoThey are guessing based on memory and emotion. The industry is primitive. There may be relevant research published that could help your specific case but they will never see it. When they leave the room they aren't going back to the office to start Googling and thinking about what additional data to collect to diagnose and solve the problem. They are going to see the next patient and will not think about you again. If your problem isn't obvious or catastrophic, you are SOL.
- agumonkey 8y agoBeing SOL is nothing, what's worse is the slight authority play going on. Letting people going back home thinking there's nothing serious or nothing that can be done is criminal IMO. State it clearly: to my best knowledge I can't see anything, keep looking if you feel the issue is still there, here are some other names or places.
- nradov 8y agoSometimes there is something serious that needs further investigation. But others times it's nothing and following your advice would be feeding hypochondria. Additional testing and diagnosis is expensive, and often carries risks of its own. It's hard to know where to draw the line.
- agumonkey 8y agoYou see, I do wonder about my tendency to bias due to anxiety, hypocondria etc etc But this is part of my tone in my above messages. I've seen doctors lie. I did have swollen ankles and hands. When mentioned to them, they'd say "yes that's a cardiovascular issue" just to switch stance the minute after. They, too, have biases.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoHistorically, doctors were some of the most educated people in town and you and your entire family saw the same doctor for many years. They had a lot of context for what was going on in your life. Now, people move around more, are less likely to see the same physician for years on end, are less likely to see the same physician as their relatives who may live elsewhere, etc. I don't know how to fix it, but I think these changes are a very big part of the problem. I don't care how brilliant and dedicated you are, having less overall context is going to undermine your ability to draw accurate conclusions about what's really going on.
- agumonkey 8y agoThat's true, social dynamics changed dramatically. More stress, less stable human relationships, more pollution, less activity .. what was working fine before probably need a revamp. Either that or we go back to slower and more local lifestyles (not bad in my book)
- MisterOctober 8y agoalso, doctors in recent decades have been horrendously overworked, particularly with regard to pressure to see many more patients daily than was the norm a generation ago. Less time with patients = less chance for listening to background and contextual information that may be useful in evaluation.
- nradov 8y agoPerhaps so, but do we have any evidence that the frequency of diagnostic errors has increased?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoNo clue and it's entirely possible diagnostics have improved in some ways, in part due to improvements in testing and in part due to patients being better educated. But I'm old-ish and I remember when it was pretty normal for Mom to show up with all three kids and a couple of their cousins and get them all treated at the same time. In contrast, in recent years, I routinely hear that people in the family pass the same crud around repeatedly because they get treated as individuals and it leads to recurrent or chronic issues. I've also dealt enough with chronic health stuff that I'm quite confident that when doctors decide "This is your normal. Just get used to it." it becomes self-fulfilling prophecy. From what I gather, obesity and chronic health issues are vastly more common than they used to be. To my mind, that's probably evidence that something has gone very wrong with our health mental models/practices overall and the change in how we interact with physicians is probably just one grain of sand in a beach of changes. (However, it will also be confounded by medical advances leading to people malingering when, historically, they would have simply died. We often can't cure them, but we can keep them alive longer than we used to.) But I'm sure that's a case of "Other people won't necessarily see what I see and if they don't, there will be no winning them over." (shrug)
- jazoom 8y agoDisclaimer: I'm a doctor You say this because you are unaware of the risks of overscreening, overtesting and overdiagnosis. Pre-test probability is important to take into consideration. Getting patients worked up over a 0.00001% chance event causes undue stress.
- agumonkey 8y agoPlease elaborate. I understand that some test procedures (coronarography etc) are too heavy to be used randomly. What else ?
- ui-explorer12 8y agotonnes of cancer screening; many biopsies. It hurts to quantify it this way, but the pot to fund health care is not bottomless in either a pure public or privately insured system. It needs to be spread across the entire population, and across all of the potential issues an individual may face.
- jazoom 8y agoIt's different for each test and intervention, and different again depending on why you're doing them. Balancing risk vs benefit is a major job of the doctor. One example: the humble chest X-ray. You may think the main risk is radiation, but IMO you'd be wrong to think that. The main risk is finding something. We call them incidentalomas. You would never have found it if you didn't do the CXR. It would never have caused you worry or morbidity. But now we know it's there, you need to get a lung biopsy. And that leads to a pneumothorax. That leads to a longer stay in hospital. That leads to time off work. You end up with no benefit to a patient who now has less trust in the medical system because they got a pneumothorax for nothing.
- petercooper 8y agoI am not a doctor, just someone who reads too many medical stories, but the thing that convinced me was an explanation by Henry Marsh, one of the UK's leading brain surgeons. A brain aneurysm poses a certain level of risk based on its size and location. So let's say you have an asymptomatic aneurysm with an annual mortality risk of 0.5%. Now let's say you decide to randomly have a full body MRI and the aneurysm is discovered. A neurosurgeon tells you that you can have an operation to clip or coil the aneurysm with a 10% risk of fatality due to its location. Do you have the op? Apparently most people do, despite the overall odds of immediate death. A 0.5% annual risk of death would ride most people out to their age of natural death rather than the 10% risk of the op, but people hate having even a tiny risk hanging over their head long term. As such, there's a school of thought that you shouldn't have such types of screening (or at least to not know the results if they are minor) unless you are symptomatic.
- gamma-male 8y agoYou have no idea about what it is to be a doctor and you are just reacting to one sided story
- agumonkey 8y agoPartly true, I just saw too many errors. I don't blame people much. They're already doing a lot. That said I want a tad more, forgive me for that.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoYou have no idea about what it is to be a doctor and you are just reacting to one sided story. On the other hand it’s ressonable as a patient not to care what it’s like being a doctor, your job as the patient is to be honest, give complete answers, and advocate for yourself. I’m not interested in a public policy perspective as dictated by the realities of insurance company profit, hospital profit, pharmaceutical company and medical device company profit, and so on. It’s the same thing with letting an intern take their turn with the scalpal. If it’s someone I care about under the knife, I’m making sure the surgeon got enough sleep and no intern or first year resident who’s half asleep touches the person I care about. Arguments that “they have to learn somehow” are reasonable, but so is my reaction that it’s your problem, not mine. I don’t care about how you’re educated, or your burdens except as they impact results. Life is unfair, utilitarian calculations must be made, but that sets up an adversarial relationship on one level, and only a fool ignores that. You feel free to fight for public policy, I’m fighting for the people I care about, not their doctors. That’s also part of life being unfair.
- Fomite 8y agoThe problem with this is when what you think you're fighting for and what you're actually fighting for don't align. I've encountered patient advocacy groups who are actively, and passionately, pushing for the wrong thing, that while emotively satisfying, will not help the problem they're trying to solve.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 8y agoDo you have any medical training? There are at least two HN users commenting on this thread who do; one of them is a cardiology fellow(!). What they're saying seems to be getting drowned out by a lot of HN-style axiomatic reasoning. Have you read much about overtreatment in cardiology? There's currently a minor scandal in the US about unnecessary cardiac procedures being performed. [cardiology overtreatment] is a good Google search term for this. It's easy, on a message board, to say "I want the extra attention, damn the cost". That's especially true when you just read an article about a "widowmaker heart attack", so that the upside of excess attention is the only thing about the issue that's cognitively available to you. But these procedures can do harm as well as good.
- dwild 8y agoYou talk specifically about over treatment but what the previous comment seems to refer is about misdiagnosis. Diagnosis where because it's very unlikely, doctor simply prefer to ignore this possibility. My SO nearly died because she was "too young" to have a thrombophlebitis, yet every signs pointed to that, yet they could have simply tested for it. She not only is incredibly lucky that a better doctor was not too far and heard her complains, she was incredibly lucky that even though it took so long for her to be treated correctly, that she still have her legs. Maybe over treatment is an issue, maybe cardiology is an inexact science right now and it's impossible to get a good diagnosis. It doesn't change the fact that misdiagnosis is bad and we should do everything we can to improve this, in every side of the coins, including mentioning when doctor just prefer to ignore conditions, because it's unlikely.
- tptacek 8y agoYou keep referring to "misdiagnosis" when I think you mean to say "underdiagnosis".
- mr_toad 8y ago> Your heart’s not just going to stop. A heart attack is not actually your heart stopping. It’s caused by a lack of oxygen to the heart tissue, causing pain and damage. It is often not immediately fatal. It can lead, sooner or later, to cardiac arrest, which is when your heart stops completely, and often is fatal.