7 ms·
Also ex-Netflix, and no, that was not ideal. We worried about those folks because they were the ones most likely to quit and the least likely to tell others ab
by jedberg 8y ago
Also ex-Netflix, and no, that was not ideal. We worried about those folks because they were the ones most likely to quit and the least likely to tell others about the service.
The cost of actually delivering the video was so tiny it didn't matter. To put it another way, you could watch for the entire month continuously and it would make no difference to the bottom line.
The videos were fixed cost licenses, not per view, so it didn't matter who watched it or for how long. The actual cost of sending bits over the wire was trivial.
- JoshuaRLi 8y ago> The cost of actually delivering the video was so tiny it didn't matter. To put it another way, you could watch for the entire month continuously and it would make no difference to the bottom line. Truly amazing times we live in!
- phreeza 8y agoHasn't the same been true for premium cable channels for a long time?
- elcomet 8y agoI think cable tv is much simpler to deliver as you only have a few channels. Netflix has tens of thousands of videos so they can't just broadcast everything (I don't think cable TV is broadcasting all their channels either, I don't know how they do it in practice).
- datenwolf 8y ago> (I don't think cable TV is broadcasting all their channels either, I don't know how they do it in practice) Actually they do. Just a whole lot of MPEG-PS, several of which multiplexed into a single frequency channel (sometime called transponder channel, even in the context of cable, although the term comes from satcom), and then on the order of hundreds of frequency channels between 100MHz to 1000MHz (roughly speaking, it depends on the regulatory domain, frequency allocations, and doesn't stretch all the way to the limits of the range).
- elcomet 8y agoThanks for the insight !
- samsonradu 8y agoYour ISP would disagree about streaming for the entire month, they bear that cost.
- skrebbel 8y agoThey bear no more cost for that than Netflix. A connection has two ends.
- ahmedalsudani 8y agoThe customers are paying for the service. They bear the cost. The idea that ISPs bear the cost of Internet traffic which benefits tech companies is at the centre of their agreement against net neutrality, and it's a fallacious argument. The ISP is free to decide the price and the quality of the service offered. That's how they recoup their costs, by charging their customers the correct price for the service.
- samsonradu 8y agoMaybe I was not clear enough, I was not defending ISPs. What I meant was that they will bear the extra cost if every subscriber maxes out their bandwidth usage so the cost (and prices therefore) will go up. What customers pay is an averaged out bandwidth usage from my understanding.
- hnnh44 8y agoThe customer has already paid for a dedicated bandwidth. If the ISP has used an outdated model that doesn't account for current usage, that's their problem. That's how business risk and models work. They can, and should, respond by modifying their plans accordingly. Once the consumer's contract is up, renew them with a more modern usage model. Until then, you eat the cost for not doing your only job. The theory that "we didn't build in a margin of error and therefore someone else is responsible" is dangerous to society. ISPs SHOULD see losses. Their investors aren't entitled to guaranteed profits.
- 8y ago
- avar 8y agoIf the cost is so tiny it doesn't matter, why does Netflix have that annoying "Are You Still Watching '<showname>'?" pop-up that's shown after a few episode have auto-played? It's annoying when binging shows, and I always assumed it was a money-saving measure.
- stouset 8y agoIt's in case you've fallen asleep, so you don't suddenly wake up to find you've "watched" three seasons of whatever show you were on. This is only displayed if there's been no input on the remote for some number of hours.
- smallbigfish 8y agoI still fall asleep and it will go on for 3-4 episodes. It solves nothing other than to annoy me from time to time.
- Retric 8y agoIt’s still much easier to figure out which episode you last watched.
- mcv 8y agoI think it does this after 3 episodes of no input. It's a compromise; they don't want to do this after every episode, but they also don't want you to wake up having watched every season of the show. It would be nice if it was configurable, though. In fact, it might well configurable; I've never really checked, because the current setting is fine by me.
- jemfinch 8y agoThey have it so their watchtime metric is accurate, obviously.
- coke12 8y agoThere might be data limits/throttling on the consumer's side.
- setgree 8y ago> The cost of actually delivering the video was so tiny it didn't matter. By one accounting standard, yes. By another, if you include the costs of producing Netflix's (actually really great) original content, no.
- Ensorceled 8y agoProduction, licensing and delivery are all different expenses by any accounting standard.
- adambyrtek 8y agoYou missed another important piece of the comment you quoted: "The videos were fixed cost licenses, not per view, so it didn't matter who watched it or for how long" In other words this was about the marginal costs of delivering content to additional viewers, not fixed production costs.
- Svenskunganka 8y ago> The actual cost of sending bits over the wire was trivial. If that's the case, is there any particular reason Netflix is charging more for access to 4K content, or is it just an artificial increase?
- lscotte 8y agoThe plan that gives you 4k also gives you 4 parallel streams instead of 2 (or 1 for the cheapest plan), so it's popular with people who share the account with others. But 4k/HDR is also a value-add that they charge for, but it doesn't mean that it costs more to provide it.
- jedberg 8y agoWhile the cost of video delivery is negligible, there are definitely increased costs for delivering 4K video. It takes more storage on the CDN box, and also takes more bandwidth on the outbound network port. That means you need more CDN boxes and more hard drives, which means renting more space and power and cooling. Also, you need to be closer to the customer for the 4K video since it's so high bandwidth, so that means more CDN deployments. You also have to get the 4K video to the CDN, which is more costly because of the extra copies and the large files. You also have to create all the 4K video files for all the devices, which takes a lot more processing time in the video pipeline. You also need higher res files from the studio, so of course they charge more for that since it costs them more to move the large files around, store them, and create them in the first place with better camera equipment and editing equipment.
- jogjayr 8y ago4K content is better than HD content - to someone, on some axis of "better". How is that an "artificial increase" then? The customer is receiving a higher quality product for a higher price but isn't forced into the more expensive plan; it seems perfectly fair.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "The cost of actually delivering the video was so tiny it didn't matter..." I don't want to get off topic but isn't this the ISP argument __against__ net neutrality? That is, they (and their collective) customers are bearing the cost of delivery, not (e.g.) Netflix.
- richardwhiuk 8y agoThe cost to an ISP of delivering a single bit is also trivial - the capability to deliver a bit very quickly is the cost - which is what their customers are paying for. Net neutrality is about being able to charge both ways.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoSingle bits might be trival, but the volume is far from single. Regardless, Netflix doesn't bear the cost of delivery. Imagine if USPS couldn't charge Amazon for delivery.
- jogjayr 8y ago> Imagine if USPS couldn't charge Amazon for delivery. Imagine if USPS charged both Amazon and its customers for delivering the same package.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI think, in a way, USPS does.
- jogjayr 8y agoWhich way, specifically? Do you have details? Have you ever sent someone a package and then they had to pay to get the package as well?
- chiefalchemist 8y ago
- meuk 8y ago> We worried about those folks because they were [...] the least likely to tell others about the service. Are there still people who don't know Netflix? ;)
- shaklee3 8y agoWell, with the openconnect boxes the cost of Netflix sending it over the wire was literally zero, since they were not sourcing it.