3 ms·
Johann Sebastian Bach most probably never said these words. Of course, there is no absolute recording of the death of Bach, so no certitude. The witnesses were
by idoubtit 8y ago
Johann Sebastian Bach most probably never said these words.
Of course, there is no absolute recording of the death of Bach, so no certitude. The witnesses were few, and the Cantor was not very famous at this time, so there was no reason for anyone to produce a detailed account of the episode. Even a single account by a family member would not prove much. So when JS Bach's popularity started to grew, a century later, there was room for imagination. There are many apocryphal texts around Bach, including the Little Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach… written in the 1920s.
Jesus of Nazareth's final quote shows a similar situation. He became much more famous after his death, and most of the texts we have about him were written decades later. Yet the Gospel all describe the scene of his death. So what were his last words? It depends on the Gospel. There are 3 very different accounts, with only Mark and Matthew agreeing.
- 1123581321 8y agoI became curious about your last paragraph as I’d always heard that Jesus’ last words were, “it is finished.” This answer on StackExchange seems like a good summary of the issue, and concludes that “it is finished” are the last words and the other accounts don’t record everything Jesus said, or claim to. Is this new information or are you referring to research that wasn’t factored into the SE answer? Regardless, your main point about last words and Bach’s in particular makes sense, especially given we are in an age where we care a lot about last words and seem to want to apply that standard to other ages. https://christianity.stackexchange.com/a/12542 https://christianity.stackexchange.com/a/12542