3 ms·
DNA tests are used in murder trials, I would expect them to be damn near perfectly repeatable. Reading other replies there seems to be a cheaper less accurate
by benj111 8y ago
DNA tests are used in murder trials, I would expect them to be damn near perfectly repeatable.
Reading other replies there seems to be a cheaper less accurate tech used for these home testing kits.
- jcwayne 8y agoThe justice system deeply misunderstands both science and statistics.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoIt doesn't misunderstand them. It knows exactly what it's doing. It relies on judges and juries misunderstanding science and statistics in order to get results favorable to the prosecutors. Basically all forensic science has turned out to be crap or misapplication of good science except for DNA which a) exonerates a heck of a lot of people and b) was a concept that matured in biology before being adopted by forensic scientists.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fucking_tragedy 8y ago> DNA tests are used in murder trials, I would expect them to be damn near perfectly repeatable. So are other forensic methods, like fingerprint[1] and hair[2] analysis. Turns out that forensic evidence isn't very scientific nor accurate. [1] http://theconversation.com/fingerprinting-to-solve-crimes-not-as-robust-as-you-think-85534 http://theconversation.com/fingerprinting-to-solve-crimes-no... [2] https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1740-9713.2016.00897.x https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1740-9...
- shawnz 8y agoEven if the tech was the same, couldn't they just run the less accurate test several times to increase the confidence?
- hexane360 8y agoThat will reduce the random error, yes. But there's still the concern of systematic error, which has to be dealt with separately. If you're taking a biased sample to begin with, it doesn't matter how many times you repeat the test; the bias will still be there.
- shawnz 8y agoBut wouldn't systematic error affect everyone's results in the same way, meaning it couldn't result in any particular pair of people becoming more or less likely to be matched as the same person?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoDNA fingerprinting is so different from whole-genome characterization that it's hardly worth comparing them. DNA fingerprinting involves: * Sequence amplification of polymorphic sites by a panel of well-characterized primers, many of which cross-check each other by amplifying over the same locus. * These amplicons are then characterized by size via restriction digest and simple electrophoresis. No sequencing is performed, only the length of the DNA fragments is characterized. * Due to population-level variation of short-tandem repeats, analysis of ~20 loci can uniquely identify an individual with a desired level of statistical confidence. The kind of data used to confirm a match in e.g. a murder trial will be absurdly robust. DNA fingerprinting is limited by the quality of sample collection and handling (i.e. don't mix up or contaminate samples), but not the accuracy of the method.
- IshKebab 8y agoYour confusion is because you think there is one "DNA test". That isn't the case. You can sequence a genome, but that costs on the order of $1k so companies like 23andme don't offer that. They use simpler methods. Even sequencing a genome is not perfect - the current most common method works by cutting the genome into pieces, sequencing those and then reassembling them. A pretty obvious limitation is that you can't detect repeated sections. I'm not sure what method the police use but it definitely isn't the same as what 23andme do.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> DNA tests are used in murder trials, I would expect them to be damn near perfectly repeatable., So were the results of FBI hair and fiber analysis, and look how that turned out. https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/crime/fbi-overstated-forensic-hair-matches-in-nearly-all-criminal-trials-for-decades/2015/04/18/39c8d8c6-e515-11e4-b510-962fcfabc310_story.html?utm_term=.5e595dcbc227 https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/crime/fbi-overstated-fo...