6 ms·
'Monopoly' seems to have become a completely meaningless word. I think it now sort of vaguely means a marketplace or any number of successful companies doing th
by chrisseaton 8y ago
'Monopoly' seems to have become a completely meaningless word. I think it now sort of vaguely means a marketplace or any number of successful companies doing their own thing, and people complaining about a monopoly just seem to be complaining that there are any number of existing successful companies in a space they'd either like to be in as well, or that a company won't do exactly what they want.
- meddlepal 8y agoI've noticed this as well. Really weird change in the words meaning.
- droopyEyelids 8y agoIt'a not that weird if you follow the literature. One of the fundamental aspects of a monopoly is the ability to set prices and therefore extract money from customers without providing additional value- like a tax or a rent. Whenever few enough competitors exist that a company can begin to tax or collect rent without providing additional value, it takes on monopolistic characteristics.
- zzzcpan 8y ago> in a space they'd either like to be in as well But that's exactly what monopoly means, i.e. you can't get in and compete with those players. It sounds like you are justifying monopolized markets for whatever reason.
- dragontamer 8y ago"Mono" means ONE. Literally the number 1. Monopoly generally means ONE supplier that controls the entire marketplace. There are other forms of market failure relating to a small group having too much power in the market: Monopoly, Cartel, Oligopoly, Monopsony, etc. etc. Oligopoly or Cartel are far closer to what the article is describing. To use the word "Monopoly" here is simply incorrect English.
- firethief 8y agoEtymology provides a good basis for guessing the general meaning of words you don't know, but it's hardly the authority on nuances of meaning. Many words have taken tangentially-related or even opposite senses from their roots in other languages.
- dragontamer 8y agoThe meanings of words shifts based on their usage. I'm old enough to recognize that the meaning of words change. Nonetheless, economic principles have a precise, technical definition for Monopoly, Duopoly, Monopsony, Oligopoly, Cartel, and Oligopsony. Each situation requires a different policy to handle. So its important to choose the right word to describe any particular problem.
- firethief 8y agoOh yeah, I agree with the conclusion. Weakening of technical terms makes clear discussion of these abstract topics in a casual context exponentially more difficult. I just don't see that argument-from-etymology is a productive way to get there since it doesn't seem to generalize.
- zzzcpan 8y agoLiteral meaning of the word is absolutely irrelevant. Historically monopoly was about granted status, but it's mostly a theoretical concept today, where everyone is in the middle between monopoly and perfect competition. You can say that if it's not competitive enough, it's a monopoly.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> You can say that if it's not competitive enough, it's a monopoly. A market that is not competitive enough is an 'oligopoly'. That's the word you want. Why do you want to move the definition of 'monopoly' when we already have the word 'oligopoly'?
- jdpedrie 8y ago"Monopoly" literally means there is only one player in the market, or that one player has a hugely dominant position. If the suggested "Cartel" doesn't work, there's also "Oligopoly"[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oligopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oligopoly
- zzzcpan 8y agoBoth cartels and oligopolies are just more specific ways to achieve monopolies.
- dragontamer 8y ago> Both cartels and oligopolies are just more specific ways to achieve monopolies. "Market Failure" is the word you're looking for. And there's LOTS of ways to achieve Market Failure. Your vocabulary of economic terms is limited and imprecise. If you study economics more, you'll certainly appreciate the amount of work that the field has put into definitions and policies. These details are important, especially in a democracy where we voters are the ones who ultimately decide upon the fate of our country. We all have to have basic economic knowledge of these Market Failure conditions, as well as the policies available to combat them.
- nothrabannosir 8y ago> ... monopoly ... players. Crucially, the "mono-" bit means "one." One seller. 1 < n ⪅ 5 is "oligopoly". If they collude and conspire it's a "cartel", but technically a cartel can also be a subset of players in a "polyopoly" (which is "many sellers", i.e. a healthy market). It's just way easier if the cartel = everyone :)
- chrisseaton 8y ago> But that's exactly what monopoly means, i.e. you can't get in and compete with those players. This isn't exactly what monopoly means. Have you tried looking in a dictionary to see what it does mean?
- mfoy_ 8y agoI tried to help him out, to no avail: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18941848 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18941848
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoMonopoly seems to refer more to "monopoly power" in general and the barriers to entry that exist to protect entrenched interests from competition. Duopolies and oligopolies all have a degree of "monopoly power" without being a true monopoly.
- notSupplied 8y agoIt has lost its ring because too many people are casually throwing it around. I'd prefer "entrenched rent extractors" followed up with some evidence of how they're rent seeking rather than competing. Sure it doesn't have the same ring to it but it is more specific about what kinds of symptoms of disfunction to look for.