3 ms·
I think you're not understanding how to use this. I've played with one, and it works just fine, subject to the theoretical aspects, which also exist with compa
by ColinWright 8y ago
I think you're not understanding how to use this. I've played with one, and it works just fine, subject to the theoretical aspects, which also exist with compass and straight-edge constructions.
As designed you lay it flat on the paper with the hinge at the intersection. You open out the arms so the points on the outer arms lie on the lines. You mark where the two inner points lie, and there you are, angle trisected.
But all that seems fairly obvious to me, and I thought it would be fairly obvious to you. So if that's not what you're thinking then I don't know where our thinking diverges.
Not that it matters - it's a device to trisect and angle. It works when used properly, but it's of no real mathematical interest.
- Dylan16807 8y agoThe points will dangle over the paper. This keeps you from making a mathematically precise point. It works to approximate a trisection in practice, but in the realm of pure geometry it can't give you an exact result. You can make a precisely curved version to overcome this, but that loses a lot of the elegance. Especially when all you need to trisect an angle is a straightedge marked to measure a single fixed distance.
- ColinWright 8y agoIn the case of the actual device, one of which I've held in my hand and actually used, no, the points don't dangle over the paper. The points descend to make contact with the paper. Perhaps that's what you mean by: > You can make a precisely curved version to overcome this, but that loses a lot of the elegance. For me, it doesn't lose elegance, but that's a matter of taste. > Especially when all you need to trisect an angle is a straightedge marked to measure a single fixed distance. Although that, in turn, requires sliding the straight-edge along and jiggling it about to match a distance to the one marked on the edge. But we're arguing about nothing. The device exists, works, is precise, in my opinion is elegant. Feel free to disagree.