4 ms·
As your quote indicates, it's not just not going at the speed of any nearby star, it's going at the particular speed of the galaxy (or galaxy's average rotation
by joe_the_user 8y ago
As your quote indicates, it's not just not going at the speed of any nearby star, it's going at the particular speed of the galaxy (or galaxy's average rotation). If an object were expelled randomly by a nearby star, it's speed would be: star's speed + random extra boost. The chances this would exactly the galactic speed seems small.
- Symmetry 8y agoBut given a long enough time and an object with a low enough ballistic coefficient I'd expect it to come to rest with respect to the interstellar medium, maybe. I don't know if that works out quantitatively in this case.
- jerf 8y agoKinda a weird speed for an alien artifact too, though. One would expect for it to be launched. Humans may in some sense have a small time horizton, but you have to have an absurdly long time horizon to fling probes out into the universe at the local average speed and expect them to encounter anything, since by definition of "local average speed" that's literally the speed least likely to encounter anything. In some sense, that's actually literally the least likely velocity I'd expect to be an alien result. (And it's also conceivable that humans have bizarrely long time horizons, if the future of all intelligence is moving into a machine intelligence on a computational substrate as fast as possible. If intelligences subjectively experience hundreds or thousands or millions of times faster, it's like dropping the speed of light by the same factor, and it still takes all the same amount of energy to launch probes. I'm not saying this is inevitably true, but I do think there's an excessively strong bias to assume that humans are as bad as possible in every possible way.)
- nerfhammer 8y agoIt's exactly what you would want to do if you didn't want someone who found it to be able to tell where it came from
- jerf 8y agoFor that, you just need the velocity vector not to be in the very narrow class of vectors that point back at you. There's no need to put it in "galactic neutral", especially given that, as I said, that's literally the worst possible speed to get anywhere. That's just one possible choice from the almost-every-possible-vector selection set that will work to disguise your origin. Of course, we also have the question of why you would care to disguise your origin for a "space probe" traveling at such a slow speed. (Pretty much every conceivable mechanism that could have something traveling at any appreciable speed and that slowed it down anytime in the recent past would be very easily detectable. Of course you can invoke inconceivable mechanisms, but as I often say, you have to understand you have left rationality and logic behind when you do that; if we're going to say this object has a magic drive that decelerates without any detectable emissions, we might as well ask why it's not just using an FTL drive, or why any alien civilization is bothering to "probe" us when they've long since landed at Area 51 and have long since been running our civilization anyhow as our secret leaders.)
- ncmncm 8y agoWhipping it around a nearby unoccupied star would be an easy way to obscure its origins. Just their bad luck that Sol turned out to be occupied, by a primitive civilization that might be able to act on knowledge of its origin vector in a few centuries or millennia. It looks slow to us, but it might be that whatever method it uses to skip big distances doesn't steer, so the only way to get pointed somewhere else is a close approach. And, of course, the method doesn't work in a gravity well, so it has to coast until it's a few hundred AU out. Will enough records be preserved through the coming dark ages (after the ecosystem collapses) for the raccoons or macaques or whatever inherits the earth to act on them?
- newsbinator 8y agoThe raccoons and macaques will likely have their own close approaches to observe and trace back.
- joe_the_user 8y agoKinda a weird speed for an alien artifact too It is a weird speed for a probe that has been recently launched to be going. It is the speed you'd expect "junk" that has been floating in speed for long time to be going, getting slingshotted from star to star until it's speed adds up to the average of the wide area it's in. Of course, does being bounced from star to star mean the thing was built for that or is it just something could happen at random.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoWell, it also is very likely to go at a speed that makes it easy to spot (easy for its class), because otherwise we would have seen the easier ones first (except if this one is a super fluke and we’ll never see its like again)