5 ms·
I think you could get away with a UBI which is substantially less than that. $12,000/person/year seems like it should be easily sufficient - since I live on tha
by gpm 8y ago
I think you could get away with a UBI which is substantially less than that. $12,000/person/year seems like it should be easily sufficient - since I live on that much excepting tuition in downtown Toronto (not cheap), in CAD (so really a lot less), just fine.
Keep in mind that when you are counting per person that means you are allocating that much for people not in the workforce like children too. A 4 person household is getting $50,000/year with the above number.
Expecting people who are just living on a UBI to move somewhere with a low cost of living also seems reasonable to me, I suspect you could substantially slash even the $12,000/person/year number and still have it be sufficient.
I also think that a partial UBI (e.g. $3000/year) would likely be nearly as beneficial as a full one, but it does increase overhead costs because then you can't get rid of the rest of the social services.
(Other people have addressed the fact that a comparison to GDP isn't valid because of taxes).
> not counting in any overhead / administrative costs to give out the handouts.
These costs are negative, in the sense that it allows us to remove the other low income services with much greater overhead.
- tokyodude 8y agoWhat will happen with the people who can't manage their money and blow their UBI other things?
- dllthomas 8y agoThe same thing that happens now when people who can't manage their money blow their salary on other things, except that it's marginally clearer what the problem is.
- tokyodude 8y agoRight now those people get food stamps and welfare
- softawre 8y agoYou'd dole out UBI biweekly or whatever to solve the same problems that food stamps solve? I agree it's a good question though.
- hexane360 8y agohahahah what? Those are directly based on salary, not on "salary after you spend most of it". How would you even implement a system like that?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jpindar 8y agoWow, talk about living in a bubble. Do you really think that a person who runs out of money can just go and get more from the government?
- tokyodude 8y agoMy sister gets food stamps. Food stamps are for food (generally) where as money is for anything. UBI is often held up by proponents as a replacement for all other support. Given them $1k a month cash instead of whatever they get now. But what they get now is trying to solve a problem not solved by UBI, namely that they can't be responsible for themselves (for whatever reason, physically unable, mentally unable, kids, etc...) UBI doesn't fix that problem so the existing programs will still need to exist.
- flukus 8y agoAnyone unable to be responsible can receive their UBI via a cashless welfare card (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cashless_Welfare_Card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cashless_Welfare_Card) which quarantines where the money can be spent. It deals with issues like problem gamblers and people with substance abuse problems.
- gpm 8y agoOne proposal I've heard for this is spreading it over the year, have the government deposit money in a back account once per week (this requires a system where everyone has bank accounts to get UBI, but that shouldn't be too costly).
- jpindar 8y agoThere are already benefit programs that distribute money by putting it on a debit card, eliminating the need for a bank account.
- gpm 8y agoDoesn't a debit card require a bank account, at least behind the scenes?
- jpindar 8y agoIt doesn't require the person who gets the card to have, or be eligible for, a bank account. You don't need a bank account to use a pre-paid gift card either. I suppose they would have an account number within the organization that is distributing the money, but that's not quite the same thing, and surely has less overhead.
- skrowl 8y agoThat's a good point, the US population of people 18 years or old is ~252 million, so if you only gave people 18+ a UBI handout, you'd cut your costs to 7.862 Trillion dollars per year.
- petey283 8y agoExactly this. And once you get into the 7.862 Trillion range you find that it's much more reasonable.
- coldtea 8y agoAlso one could remove the UBI part already covered by pensions -- e.g. the millions of government employees getting X pension money, can get (X - UBI) + UBI (so the same as they already get).
- dragonwriter 8y agoThat's not a UBI, then, because it's not unconditional. Also, I suspect the formula you intend is X + max(UBI - X, 0)—or, more simply max(UBI, X). Consider what your formula does for pension < UBI.
- mcguire 8y agoThat's going in the right direction, but keep in mind that the entire federal budget is about $4 trillion. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#/media/File:CBO_Infographic_2017.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#/...) A UBI that pays a portion of a living wage might be a very good idea, but it's not going to allow the majority of Americans to lay on their butts all day watching TV and eating cheesy poofs.
- est31 8y ago> because then you can't get rid of the rest of the social services. Some you can get rid of, others you shouldn't. Even if you have UBI, some medical procedure might cost an individual more than they are getting in 10 years. So a proper healthcare system is still important.
- skrowl 8y agoAgreed. Even the most zealous socialists aren't suggesting UBI handouts could replace healthcare insurance.
- oihfklasfsd 8y agoThere are zero socialists who are for UBI because UBI does nothing to stem the inherent exploitation of capitalism.
- krapp 8y agoOpponents of UBI, at least in the US, will never accept it on moral and definitely not on socialist grounds - only possibly as a means of cutting Federal expenditure and reducing or deprecating existing social programs, which they disagree with on principle. If Americans want UBI, they'll either get it with the repeal of the minimum wage, medicare, medicaid, federal student loans and the complete privatization of healthcare - basically the dismantling of the entire social safety net with the exception of programs to aid the military and agriculture - or else opponents will sabotage what futile efforts are made the way they did the ACA, and then work to repeal it as soon as possible.
- gpm 8y agoThat was sloppy wording on my part but the idea stands. "The rest of the social services" should be interpreted as only the social services that serve a similar purpose. I'm a Canadian and basically think you all need to fix your healthcare system anyways, but for simplicities sake I'll just declare that to not be part of what I meant by the rest.
- nostrebored 8y agoExcept your suggestions here ignore that the surplus given by UBI will be amortized into rent and staples costs. It's all well and good until you get into the weeds and realize that a lot of price fixing or pseudo price fixing needs to happen before UBI becomes realistic. If the argument is getting rid of legislative and bureaucratic bloat, it's definitely not quite so easy or quite so effective, choose one.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoWhy would you expect inflation to occur? As long as UBI is payed for via taxes and not deficit spending than the money supply isn't changing. And as economists say, inflation is a monetary phenomenon. Supply & demand aren't radically changing either. America's poor eat too much, not too little. And while there are homeless people in America, most sleep in shelters. If anything, you might expect the price of the cheapest staples and crappiest housing to go down as UBI enables the poor to upgrade their food and housing.
- nostrebored 8y agoMoney supply isn't the issue here. If everyone has another x+12,000 dollars, the amount of money available for low income housing has strictly increased. Landlords are then in a position to raise prices proportionally. The "America's poor eat too much" line is also not strong. You might argue that they eat the wrong things; this is the food desert/education argument that's commonly made. Regardless there is already artificial price fixing of many staple foods like milk and bread, which is a much better argument.
- idontpost 8y ago> Money supply isn't the issue here. > If everyone has another x+12,000 dollars, the amount of money available for low income housing has strictly increased. Landlords are then in a position to raise prices proportionally. You're contradicting yourself through sloppy thinking. If everyone has another x+12,000 dollars, the money supply has increased. That's the definition of money supply. It's also a total strawman and not what UBI proposes to do. For example, my wife and I make about $150,000 combined. UBI would basically do nothing for us because of the taxes we'd pay to support it. If anything we'd have less money, not $12,000 more. The only people who'd have $12,000 more are the totally unemployed and homeless. The point of UBI isn't that everyone gets more money, it's that everyone is guaranteed to have the means not to starve or be homeless at a minimum. People who support UBI (including myself) do so not because they would have more money (as stated, I personally would almost certainly lose money), but because they would have less RISK. That's what UBI really does. It lowers the risk of life choices and gives people the freedom to make choices that otherwise they could not have made. If I'm one of the lucky (which so far, I have been), UBI does nothing for me. But if tomorrow I'm crippled in a car accident and can no longer work, UBI guarantees a certain minimum standard of living.
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoThere was a study somewhere concluding that as little as $500/year could have huge impact.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Expecting people who are just living on a UBI to move somewhere with a low cost of living also seems reasonable to me Not unless you are providing means-tested relocation assistance (which is against the spirit of UBI), and ignoring that UBI and the associated taxes to fund it will: (1) reduce CoL in high CoL areas and, (2) raise CoL in low CoL areas. And assisted relocation actually magnifies this effect.
- gpm 8y agoNo. The cost of relocation is the cost of a bus ticket, suitcase, and a few phone calls, something that $12,000 already easily supports. The rest of the money people spend is to bring their existing wealth with them, something that society doesn't need to assist with.