3 ms·
I know mathematical logic but I don't know much about conventional philosophy. The Gettier argument seems to indicate that a system of false propositions used t
by joe_the_user 8y ago
I know mathematical logic but I don't know much about conventional philosophy. The Gettier argument seems to indicate that a system of false propositions used to arrive at a conclusion could be called "justification" in normal epistemology - that seems a bit disturbing. Being "justified" in believing X means just having some reason, maybe utterly bogus but existing and convincing to you, for believing X (and then X becomes knowledge even if X happens to be true entirely different reasons). How could no one have commented previously if that was how the system was?
Edit: the main practical implication of the argument seems to be that one cannot assume that when you have argument for X and when you then you get empirical evidence for X, you cannot take that a proof your argument for X is true. It might be suggestive of the truth of the argument but the structure of the argument also has to be taken into account. But that's been a given scientific and statistical investigations for a long time.