17 ms·
Some paint it as if the main reason to switch was privacy (https://www.imore.com/duckduckgo-switches-apple-maps-because-privacy https://www.imore.com/duckduckgo
by mtmail 8y ago
Some paint it as if the main reason to switch was privacy (https://www.imore.com/duckduckgo-switches-apple-maps-because-privacy https://www.imore.com/duckduckgo-switches-apple-maps-because... "DuckDuckGo switches to Apple Maps, because privacy"), but the previous map provider was mapbox (openstreetmap plus commercial sources) and I doubt mapbox collected more data than Apple is now.
- gowld 8y agoDDG's main marketing model is talking about how they believe Google is privacy threat, so they'll highlight that angle in any change.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoOr Apple's marketing team lead to a donation to DDG to make it possible
- st3fan 8y agoWhy does the glass always have to be half empty? Maybe Apple simply was the better choice?
- jhall1468 8y agoDDG's entire schtick was privacy and they are switching from open data + commercial sources to a commercial company.
- godelski 8y agoIs it though? A few months ago Apple Maps gave me wrong directions going from Custer State Park to Mt. Rushmore (two major tourist locations relatively near one another).
- atomwaffel 8y agoAt least here in western Norway, Mapbox’s directions are incredibly buggy, to the point where they’ll send you on a 150-kilometre scenic drive (including two ferries) to avoid a tunnel instead of going 15 kilometres straight through the mountain. This is apparently because they’re rolling their own telemetrics-based data on top of the OSM road network. Then again, Apple Maps (on DuckDuckGo) seems to think I that want my maps labelled in Indonesian, so you may still have a point.
- ams6110 8y agoPrivacy aside, Apple maps, in my experience, are definitely worse than Google in terms of actually corresponding to reality. Apple Maps navigation also takes me on convoluted routes far more often than Google does.
- itwasntandy 8y agoMy own experience ( North east US) has been somewhat different recently. Yes routes from Apple maps, may appear longer or more convoluted at first glance. However after using it ( due to CarPlay) for a while on routes I had previously regularly done using google maps, I inferred a reasoning for that. On the ~90 minute journey to my in-laws, the predicted journey time, is generally advertised as being quicker on google, but in practice the time difference is marginal. What was different in my experience anyway, is that Apple maps seems to try to minimize left turns where appropriate. The benefit being a noticeably less stressful journey. Has anyone else noticed this?
- macintux 8y agoI can’t speak to left turns, but someone attempted a careful evaluation of the turn-by-turn options and Apple’s estimates were generally more conservative, leading to the conclusion that you point out, that Apple looked slower but wasn’t.
- maxerickson 8y agoTo be fair, the glass is often full of gasoline.
- SEJeff 8y agoThat and from a purely data privacy angle, Apple is legitimately better than Google.
- taf2 8y agoAre they or do you just believe that because of what you think you know about the difference between the two companies?
- ad-hominem 8y agoApple's business model is not selling your data for advertisements. They make their money the old-fashioned way - charging customers for their product (hardware).
- Kye 8y agoI'm currently on my first iPhone. They spell out what they do with data in just about every app and setting. There's an almost annoying number of modals related to privacy and general control of data. Maybe it's all for show, but they seem to take privacy seriously.
- foepys 8y agoAfaik Apple went above and beyond to make sure their original iPhone fingerprint sensor never leaked the fingerprint to any app or even the OS itself. Android always just did whatever with the print. If that's the same philosophy now, Apple is definitely better than Google in terms of privacy. Full disclosure: I own an Android device and no Apple product except an iPod from 2009 or so.
- cronix 8y agoIs it really private though if it's all being collected, encryption and all, to be decrypted at a future date when the technology is available? All data on the net is captured by the NSA and stored at multiple data centers. One's in Utah. No company can really claim privacy if their product touches the internet since all of the pipes are tapped. It's all semantics. Maybe saying "we don't directly..." or "we don't make it easy..." would be more accurate. There is no privacy on the net, period. It's temporary privacy in the immediate present at best. 5 years from now? They might be able to decrypt everything from the last 10 years that they already have stored. It's guaranteed at some point. 6 years ago Snowden also revealed Apple was on board with the data collection. They are lying, and people don't care and go along with the show. https://appleinsider.com/articles/15/01/21/nsa-leaker-edward-snowden-refuses-to-use-apples-iphone-over-spying-concerns---report https://appleinsider.com/articles/15/01/21/nsa-leaker-edward...
- jakewalker 8y agowhy would it be a "donation"? DDG isn't a charity.
- mda 8y agoHow much do you think DDG will pay apple for this?
- aylmao 8y agoOr a deal. Perhaps DDG will help Apple out as provider of search data of some kind (like WolframAlpha, or Yelp). Not sure what this could be that Apple can't do themselves though. If Apple wants to focus more on services it makes sense to onboard people into using their APIs and challenging Google on this developer front too.
- willio58 8y agoThe best kind of marketing is marketing based on universally known truth.
- mda 8y agoOr.. DDG is just a tool in a bigger war in the background. It feels like it can exist only because its benefactors allow it to exist.
- ameister14 8y agoIt's independently profitable, though.
- bduerst 8y agoBecause it's basically a reskin of Bing search. They say they index a handful of "sources" which are just individual websites, and also redundant because Bing also indexes them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chappi42 8y agoGoogle _is_ a privacy threat. Completely unrelated to DDG, marketing or believe. One Google with thousand tentacles...
- tramGG 8y agoA vote for Google is a vote for death.
- nolok 8y agoWhether it's true or not doesn't change anything to what the parent comment said.
- Aunche 8y agoI'm a bit uncomfortable with how much DDG's marketing is focused on trashing their competition. They deliberately obfuscate privacy issues to strengthen their narrative. Sure duckduckgo is a good company right now, but that's only because they're small. I doubt they'll stay that way when they capture a significant market share.
- anth_anm 8y agoWhy? That's the differentiator they chose to go for. You can argue that's it's dishonest, but i don't see the problem with the marketing.
- kiriakasis 8y agoPersonally I find their writing mean... I do not love the super optimistic marketing lingo, but DDG sometimes sounds too vicious in their blog. (I still use them as main search engine, but I am not sure I would like them to go mainstream)
- morganvachon 8y agoThey don't just believe Google is a privacy threat, they know it. We all do. You don't have to use weasel words when discussing a known quantity.
- kerng 8y agoIs Google not a privacy threat?
- awkward 8y agoI think an interesting question is how much of it is because of Apple starting to lean on privacy as a differentiator, rather than DuckDuckGo continuing to do so.
- Krasnol 8y agoIs it just me or does the map-link go to yelp.com? Why are we even talking about Apple here when it's yelp getting the clicks? This is terrible...
- maxerickson 8y agoAt some point their place search was powered by Yelp. The flip side with Mapbox is that they probably weren't collecting any less data either.
- spectre256 8y agoWhether or not Mapbox collects more data is an interesting question. My guess would be they do, by a lot. If you look at their website, Mapbox is all about "live" location data, insights, etc. The days of them just being a provider of nice services built around (mostly) open data are probably over. They have a huge userbase and can leverage all that data to do powerful things.
- rmc 8y agoCEO of Mapbox said at State of the Map US 2018 that they are continuously collecting lots of location data (which they use to improve the map). They do not believe this amounts to the collection of personal data.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sjg007 8y agoApple needs it's own search engine. This is step 1.
- aurea 8y agoWhat if they just bought DDG?
- wjoe 8y agoI expect most DDG users would stop using it. Apple may be the "least bad" of the big players when it comes to privacy, but I have no trust in them and no interest in using their services. It would probably make a lot of sense for Apple though, and I'm sure they'd convince more Apple loyalists to switch to DDG from Google by putting their name on it.
- neallindsay 8y agoThen Apple would have to give up the truckloads of money they get from Google for making them the default search engine on Safari.
- loxs 8y agoWow, I hope they buy DDG
- Yuval_Halevi 8y agoGood point. I like DuckDuckGo, but lately, their decisions make me wonder what's their direction. The only way they promote themselves is only by comparing DuckDuckGo to Google
- metz999 8y agoAs a user, the deciding point is quality of google maps versus the reality of the claim of privacy with apple maps. I have a hard time believing that current users of duckduckgo completely escaped google's data collection over the decades and by choosing to use apple maps have dramatically reduced their privacy exposure with a measurable impact on their lives.
- niutech 8y agoAccording to Mapbox Privacy Policy (https://www.mapbox.com/privacy/ https://www.mapbox.com/privacy/), they collect a lot of data, including: (a) IP address, (b) device and browser information, (c) operating system, (d) the content of the request, (e) the date and time of the request, and (f) limited location and usage data.