4 ms·
Which is kinda just how capitalism "works". In certain circumstances, once the means of production are created [most of] the workers are no longer needed, but
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Which is kinda just how capitalism "works".
In certain circumstances, once the means of production are created [most of] the workers are no longer needed, but the means being privately held (by a narrow group of owners) means they alone can benefit going forward.
You can make a feast together and share it; or you can make a feast together, kick out most of the helpers and gorge yourself.
Capitalism says the second option is better because you get to have more.
- roenxi 8y agoStrictly speaking, Capitalism says that the Capitalists get to choose which option they go with. In a system with healthy incentives, we might expect Option 1 to be the sensible capitalist equilibrium, because capital needs to be maintained and the builders/maintainers become the same people. Don't forget that, in theory, the workers can become capitalists themselves if they aren't getting a good share of the benefits. In my view usually when they don't it is because of government interference (eg, the pre-Uber situation in taxis, or how regulation tends to entrench existing players).
- ambicapter 8y agoYou don't "become" capitalist, a capitalist has capital, and if you don't have any capital, you're not a capitalist.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoAnyone saving/investing a portion of their income is becoming a capitalist.
- FakeComments 8y agoI disagree. As an example, someone who switches from working as a landscaper to running a landscaping business has switched from a worker role to a capitalist role — even though they likely spent less money doing so than a software engineer worker owns. Being a “capitalist” is defined by capitalizing ventures, not the mere volume of capital. I would argue that the reason society has become so disequitable is that we’ve made it difficult to transition between worker and small capitalist — that is to say, that we’ve undermined small and lifestyle businesses.
- CryptoPunk 8y ago>>but the means being privately held (by a narrow group of owners) means they alone can benefit going forward. No, capital expanding has social benefits in reducing consumer prices, which increases purchasing power.