10 ms·
It's interesting to see contrasting articles on taxes & growth. There's this article about how South Korea raised taxes in a bid to grow faster and failed, but
by nostrademons 8y ago
It's interesting to see contrasting articles on taxes & growth. There's this article about how South Korea raised taxes in a bid to grow faster and failed, but there are also plenty of articles about how Kansas's attempt to lower taxes in a bid to grow faster also failed [1], as well as predictions that California's high taxes would hamper growth (which hasn't really happened yet).
What if the actual conclusion is that it just doesn't matter. Growth is driven by other factors, like when a brilliant but insufferable physicist moves back home to be close to his mother [2], and is a function of individual, private firms performing functions of the economy more efficiently than existing incumbents. Tax policy follows as a consequence, and can go in either direction: either the newly-rich individuals think "Oh well, I've got plenty of money to spare, I can afford to burn some to ensure the people around me live decent lives", or they think "I want to keep more of this money to myself so I can decide how to allocate it." Regardless, wealth brings power, and so they have the ability to shape local government policy based on their particular worldview.
If this is correct, tax policy is a huge distraction, and if governments really want to jump-start growth they should be funding basic research, ensuring that the results are public (to their citizens, at least), and encouraging bright young people from across the world to immigrate to their jurisdictions.
[1] https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/kansas-provides-compelling-evidence-of-failure-of-supply-side-tax-cuts https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/kansas-pr...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Shockley#Career https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Shockley#Career
- 40acres 8y agoAgreed, tax policy overall is just an ineffective lever for growth. It may help on the margins (tax break to build a factory, tax break on electric cars, tax increase to fund national health and education programs) but it doesn't spur the fundamental earth shaking innovation that advanced economies need to grow at a clip above 2-3%.
- ddebernardy 8y ago> If this is correct, tax policy is a huge distraction, and if governments really want to jump-start growth they should be funding basic research ... which requires taxes, which makes tax policy not a huge distraction.
- nostrademons 8y ago... but much less than what any current government currently spends. The entire DARPA budget is $3.44B this year, half as much as the wall that's currently shutting down our entire government, and less than 1/1000th of the total federal budget. The NSF gets $7.8B, a little more than the wall and about 1/500th of the budget. NASA gets $20B.
- jtuente 8y ago> NASA gets $20B. Which is about 3.5 walls and about 1/200th of the budget.
- OscarCunningham 8y ago> 3.5 walls The $5.7B that Trump is asking for isn't enough to build the whole wall, it's just the amount he wants now. Cost estimates for the wall vary but they're all larger than $20B.
- zozbot123 8y agoThe silver lining is that $20B is still a tiny fraction of the cost for the Iraq war (a cost that one notable presidential candidate was historically quite comfortable with paying. No, I don't mean Bernie) That's progress, I guess!
- r00fus 8y agoYeah instead we spent it on a 1.1T tax cut for the 1%.
- ddebernardy 8y agoAs I understood, estimates for that wall range between 25 and 75 billion USD depending on who you ask. And this being government contracts, it might very well balloon to 100 billion or more if you factor in surprises and corruption. Other than that, I agree... NASA isn't getting enough funding. As are climate initiatives in the US. And the same goes for similar agencies and initiatives in the EU where I live. I'm more skeptical about DARPA, but to their credit they're not just enablers of death; they're also working on some certifiably good stuff, like fighting human trafficking [1]. [1]: https://www.darpa.mil/program/memex https://www.darpa.mil/program/memex
- mathattack 8y agoVery different to compare a country’s policy versus a state in the context of a country with a much larger % share of taxes. To your point - other things matter too: access to great engineering schools that are open to professors moonlighting, flexibility of labor and capital, etc.
- jvreeland 8y ago> If this is correct, tax policy is a huge distraction, and if governments really want to jump-start growth they should be funding basic research, ensuring that the results are public (to their citizens, at least), and encouraging bright young people from across the world to immigrate to their jurisdictions. Which could be accomplished by raising taxes. Raising taxes, particularly in the US to pay for social services like healthcare and education would also have a huge effect on growth and productivity. It's not really the level of taxes that matters it's that you spend money on things that enabled people to pursue innovation/employement/art/etc and not get burnt out on administrative bullshit and constant stress from preventable things.
- dv_dt 8y agoIt's funny that the model we ended up with is that social activities of government can only be funded by budget-constrained financing where deficits are viewed with alarmism, with taxes not really causing strong growth/shrink effects. On the other hand commercial activities can be funded via issuing currency through fractional reserve banking - causing national and global asset bubbles with periodic recessions and terrible effects on growth and productivity. I think we need to move to different mental models of both to advance past our current economically induced problems.
- chii 8y ago> social activities of government can only be funded by budget-constrained financing > commercial activities can be funded via issuing currency through fractional reserve banking It's because the benefits of social activities cannot be captured and its value extracted. Commercial activity can - and therefore, there's motive for somebody to fund it to get richer.
- microcolonel 8y agoWell, I think it is a matter of scale. It's not that tax policy isn't important, it's that the things people tend to change most easily are not as important as the things which are more difficult. When people say hyperbolic things about changes which are small in the grand scheme of things, it gives you the impression that nothing could matter as much as they're saying it does. As for California in particular, I can tell you that their tax policy (along with all of their other policies, including firearms policy which is somehow more asinine than here in Canada, and their policy on corporate boards which is profoundly unjust) is a major turn-off for myself, and if you look at migration between states in the U.S, you'll find that a lot of other people feel the same way. People aren't leaving California because of the weather, you know.
- jdlshore 8y agoYour claim about California migration sounded biased to me, so I looked up the US census data [1]. 2010: -130,416 (net migration out of California) 2011: -94,122 2012: -73,864 2013: -96,915 2014: -79,892 2015: -129,409 2016: -142,932 2017: -137,895 Compared to population [2], we get: 2010: -0.35% 2011: -0.25% 2012: -0.19% 2013: -0.25% 2014: -0.21% 2015: -0.33% 2016: -0.36% 2017: -0.35% Conclusion: migration out did spike up starting in 2015. Now, what is it correlated with? You said it was due to taxes, firearms policy, and board policy. Tax changes in 2014/2015: I didn't see any major tax changes [3]. Firearms policy changes in 2014: Long gun serial numbers required to be recorded on new sales. Police can confiscate guns from high-risk individuals for three weeks (signed in 2014, took effect in 2016). [4] Firearms policy changes in 2015: Firearm Safety Certificate required for all guns (previously only required for handguns). [4] Board policy change: Passed in 2018. [5] My take: Migration out of California has increased, but it's not clear why. My personal guess would be cost of living. [1] https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/geographic-mobility/state-to-state-migration.html https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/geograph... [2] https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=kf7tgg1uo9ude_&met_y=population&hl=en&dl=en https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=kf7tgg1uo9ude_&... [3] http://www.library.ca.gov/Content/pdf/crb/reports/FinalVersion_kjh_10192016ONLINE_Accessible.pdf http://www.library.ca.gov/Content/pdf/crb/reports/FinalVersi... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_California [5] https://www.wsj.com/articles/california-moves-to-mandate-female-board-directors-1535571904 https://www.wsj.com/articles/california-moves-to-mandate-fem...
- perfmode 8y agoTaxes are one of the weakest ways to influence an economy (a complex system) or society at large for that matter. Donella Meadows: PLACES TO INTERVENE IN A SYSTEM (in increasing order of effectiveness) 12. Constants, parameters, numbers (such as subsidies, taxes, standards). 11. The sizes of buffers and other stabilizing stocks, relative to their flows. 10. The structure of material stocks and flows (such as transport networks, population age structures). 9. The lengths of delays, relative to the rate of system change. 8. The strength of negative feedback loops, relative to the impacts they are trying to correct against. 7. The gain around driving positive feedback loops. 6. The structure of information flows (who does and does not have access to information). 5. The rules of the system (such as incentives, punishments, constraints). 4. The power to add, change, evolve, or self-organize system structure. 3. The goals of the system. 2. The mindset or paradigm out of which the system — its goals, structure, rules, delays, parameters — arises. 1. The power to transcend paradigms.
- wwweston 8y agoI like this list enough that I intend to read more by Meadows, but it seems to me that tax policy isn't just limited to #12, but can play a notable role in #11 down through #5. Particularly #5 and #6. In fact, a lot of the items on the list aren't entirely distinct from one another. That doesn't mean the list is bad -- I think it's powerful enough to try and articulate as many semi-distinct inflection points for a system as one can. Just that I'm not sure that the ranking is pure.
- germinalphrase 8y agoAre those ranked by perceived impact?
- Jtsummers 8y agoYes. The closer to 1, the greater the impact to the fundamental system. The purpose of those leverage points are not just to change the external behavior of a system but to change the system itself. You can change the external behavior of an economy by increasing/decreasing taxes. But this may not alter the fundamental system itself. Consider #9: Length of delays relative to rate of system change. This is precisely what the Agile and Lean movements wants (OODA and PDCA loops). By reducing the delay (compared to Waterfall and comparable approaches) between doing something and getting feedback, they can adjust their processes and systems to meet customer demands more reliably. This is much more impactful than parameter changes (#12) which is: hire 10 more people, or give the best devs a 25% bonus. Those may help to motivate people, but they don't alter the fundamental system (ok, mass hiring can alter the fundamental system, but often not in the desired way). On the other hand, introducing delays can stabilize a system. So reducing delays isn't the right choice for every circumstance.
- rossdavidh 8y agoWhat fixes an economy is...to fix whatever is broken about it. If your tax rate is 99% and it is causing massive tax accounting shenanigans to suck up otherwise valuable time and energy, reducing the tax rate is good. If your tax rate is 1% and your government can't do anything to maintain law and order, raising the tax rate is good. If your tax rate is not the problem, then neither raising nor reducing it will fix the problem. Perhaps, in South Korea, the tax rate was not the problem.
- User23 8y agoThe US had its lowest recorded murder rates (the most reliable crime statistic, since bodies are hard to either fake or ignore) recorded a decade before the 16th amendment was ratified[1][2]. Interestingly, the passage of the Dick Act[3] immediately preceded an at least fourfold spike in murders that has persisted ever since. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate_by_decade#1900s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention... [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_Uni... [3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militia_Act_of_1903 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militia_Act_of_1903
- gimmeThaBeet 8y agoThat was a time where America was rapidly urbanizing, where the populations of NYC, Chicago were increasing by like 30% a decade. The cities of the south really came into their own at this point, think Atlana. LA tripled in population from 1900 to 1910, and nearly doubled again from 1910 to 1920. We had absolutely massive demographic shifts over the initial decades of the 20th century, and you're seriously going to pick income tax as the culprit of crime rising? Compared to 1900, 1920s America had a much different identity.
- User23 8y agoMy point wasn't to prove that income tax causes murders, it was to disprove that income tax prevents them.
- nkrisc 8y agoPerhaps I'm just naive with regards to tax policy, but the idea of raising or lowering taxes in order to drive growth always seemed strange to me. I've always taxes were a way to fund a functioning government and pay for all the common infrastructure and services that make life pleasant. If you have excellent public schools, and well-maintained roads, and an efficient governing body, wouldn't that be a place ripe for growth, regardless of tax rate?
- Spooky23 8y agoIt is. Most of the places where people live and work are higher tax places. The lowest tax places are usually places dominated the lowest value-add businesses -- like resource extraction. They don't really care about people because they don't need them.
- nybble41 8y agoMore money spent on government projects does not guarantee a proportionally greater benefit, and comes at the expense of other factors which are necessary for growth, such as private investment. Most of the things a healthy economy needs do not come from government and are not paid for via taxes. As a simple counter-example, let's say 100% of income were taxed and spent on the best educational and transportation systems money can buy. You'd have excellent schools and the best roads, but zero incentive for anyone to work, much less start a business. The capital needed to produce the goods people want would be consumed without replacement. That's a recipe for economic collapse, not growth.
- dv_dt 8y agoThe response to both dramatically increased taxes (as in South Korea), and dramatically decreased taxes (as in Kansas and the US), would seem to point to the fact that taxes as they affect growth mostly don't matter.
- make3 8y agoeconomy is a clusterfuck of causality. trying to find what caused something is super hard
- doctorpangloss 8y ago> What if the actual conclusion is that it just doesn't matter. You're probably right with respect to growth. Other commenters are going to glibly point out that you need taxes to pay for basic research or whatever. Yeah, I think they miss the point too. If the country wanted to, it could not raise a single tax dollar and 10x its research spending. A country isn't a household, its balance sheet can have debt permanently, etc. etc. No, I think taxes matter for justice and equality. And the whole reason cost effectiveness entered our debate is that rich people, like you're correctly pointing out, have opinions, and tax policy is a consequence of that. But if overall rich people are aligned against higher taxes, which is the case in history most of the time, they're effectively aligned against equality and justice. And save me the downvotes if you don't understand how property taxes, for example, that differ between neighborhoods, can be about justice as much as they are about funding school districts. Or that the healthcare mandate was absolutely about justice, and that calling it a tax was a workaround precisely for the reasons I described: that we've become obsessed with positivist or legalistic (instead of normative) dialogue, so it was the only way to get ACA passed. I love tax policy on HN, because it really brings out of the woodwork people who do care about what's good for the country, and people who don't.
- the_af 8y ago> A country isn't a household, its balance sheet can have debt permanently, etc. etc. > I think taxes matter for justice and equality Thank you for saying this. I wish the president of my country (which is not the US!) understood this. And that running a country is also not like running a business.
- jedmeyers 8y ago> I think taxes matter for justice and equality. There is nothing inherently just or equal about coming with guns to people and taking a percentage of their earned resources. > I love tax policy on HN, because it really brings out of the woodwork people who do care about what's good for the country, and people who don't. And I love it because it brings out holier-than-thou virtue signalers, who think that they know better than everyone how to spend other people's resources, while denigrating their contributions. The road to hell is paved with good intentions. "Caring about what's good for the country" is not nearly enough to be able to bring positive change even to a subset of people in the country. But it does bring some virtual internet points, I concede that.
- redahs 8y agoTax policy has a huge impact on growth. However what matters much more than quantity of tax is the quality of tax. Money is public credit and varies in quality depending upon what it is secured by. Broad-based sales and payroll taxes are the worst possible quality of tax which undermine their own base. Sales taxes destroy commerce and payroll taxes which shift the tax burden from old savers onto young workers make it harder for families to afford having kids as early. Land value and property income taxes are the best quality of tax, because the state simply confiscates a portion of the free lunch which would otherwise be privately captured by landlords, without discouraging any productive economic activity. Louisiana is an example of a state with very poor tax "quality": low property tax, large property tax exemptions for businesses, and high sales taxes. It has negative real GDP growth per capita. The public is frequently malinformed by experts as to what taxes are the best quality, because many tax 'reform' advocacy organizations actually advocate that the governments use the worst possible quality tax because they hypothesize that it will cause voters to advocate for lower government spending.
- skookumchuck 8y agoTaxing pollution, instead of taxing productive activity, is a quality tax. Instead of spending money to combat pollution, people are incentivized to find solutions. Instead of punishing productive people to get government money, polluters are punished.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoPollution taxes can only work for post-industrial countries that are able to run on mostly service industry and import everything that requires manufacturing. As thus, they would be fine for most European countries but crappy for industrializing countries like India.
- zozbot123 8y agoEven in a developing country like India or China, a pollution tax would be an effective (and lucrative) defense against opportunistic "race to the bottom" behavior. There are plenty of emerging industries, even in manufacturing, that don't depend on polluting the environment for their viability.
- jeromebaek 8y agoEconomics is, as the first economist for Google put it, "intellectual prostitution". You can justify any policy with the right amount of jargon. The interesting bit isn't really the economics but the moral assumptions behind it. To tax or to not tax the rich, to raise the minimum wage, to redistribute wealth, are all moral issues. And nothing gets people more riled up than differing moral opinions
- clairity 8y agoin this case, the correct conclusion is probably "it's too early to tell". economies can take a while to equilibriate, and the article mention a 1-year timeframe from which they draw their conclusion. i'd also guess that south korea, while more developed than many countries, is not quite developed enough to extract surplus value from the various value chains its economy participates in. that would matter because their businesses would have less profit leeway to absorb costs like a higher minimum wage in the short term.
- philwelch 8y agoIt’s not really a comparable situation. US states compete for resources within a national economy. South Korea is a national economy. And California and Kansas differ in many ways other than tax rates. California’s high state taxes are a mechanism for monetizing California’s other economic advantages to fund their state government, while lower state taxes in states like Kansas are a mechanism for attempting to compensate for their other economic disadvantages. The mistake is in focusing obsessively on any one variable rather than addressing the entire system. California is definitely economically worse off in some ways than alternate-universe-low-tax California, but in exchange they have more tax revenue and hence potentially better schools and highways. It’s all tradeoffs and matters of degree. Confiscatory 90%+ income tax rates were not sustainable after the immediate postwar era, and might have even been a bad idea at the time, but it doesn’t make sense to overreact to that mistake when it’s long been fixed and there are more obvious bottlenecks.
- nonbel 8y ago>"It's interesting to see contrasting articles on taxes & growth. There's this article about how South Korea raised taxes in a bid to grow faster and failed, but there are also plenty of articles about how Kansas's attempt to lower taxes in a bid to grow faster also failed [1], as well as predictions that California's high taxes would hamper growth (which hasn't really happened yet)." Should this be surprising? I thought that was pretty much what the laffer curve was about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve
- refurb 8y agoThe reason for the contradictory findings is that tax rates are one of what, hundreds or thousands of variables to economic output? It shouldn’t be surprising that a change in tax rate can be overpowered by other factors.
- cc439 8y ago>Growth is driven by other factors, like when a brilliant but insufferable physicist moves back home to be close to his mother [2], and is a function of individual(.) This is true in the short term as the individuals already exist and their prior experience is already locked in. The long term problem is that of failure to create a new generation of high performing individuals, either through a collapse in birthrates (already underway for at least 1 full generation) or a failure to entice high potential individuals to participate in meaningful endeavors (arguably happening right now). Humans have a defined lifespan and their life trajectory is largely determined by outside factors even if their potential isn't.
- csomar 8y agoI agree. I used to live in a shitty city, filled with pollution, rather expensive, bad roads, high crime rates, etc... For various reasons, the central government decided (that was like 15 years ago), to invest in another city that is 130km from the said city. It invested in infrastructure, schools, cleanliness and tourism. 15 years later, the clean city is practically a ghost town. The shitty city is shittier but it has gone through an economical and population boom. Turns out, people from the shitty city were more successful on average; and they decided to stay where their families are. People from the nearby cities didn't decide to move to the shitty one but did so because that's where jobs are. If there is anything that I learned by traveling cities: 1. Jobs matter. More than you think. They are what attract people to a city. 2. Family relations matter. More than you think. It seems it is what attract people back and make them invest their life savings in a house, small business, etc...