8 ms·
I've never understood why people seem to love these surveillance devices that rely on an external service. Besides the privacy issues, if the service disappears
by userbinator 8y ago
I've never understood why people seem to love these surveillance devices that rely on an external service. Besides the privacy issues, if the service disappears or even the Internet connection goes down, they become useless. A DVR and a set of "old school" network cameras in an internal network have none of those problems, but it seems all the big companies are eagerly pushing "cloud" centralisation instead of making easy-to-use local solutions.
- jbob2000 8y ago> A DVR and a set of "old school" network cameras in an internal network have none of those problems Ring is a $300 purchase and takes an hour to install. This would take me a few weekends and would cost thousands of dollars. Cloud centralization makes things easier and cheaper, by orders of magnitude.
- e1ven 8y agoWhy would it be so difficult to connect to locally? A company could drop a camera and a small NAS box, and have it all work over the local WiFi. I haven't looked into it, but I suspect there are several vendors who already do this. It would get more complicated to support accessing it while away from home, admittedly. I don't know if that's an important feature for this application.
- ASalazarMX 8y ago> It would get more complicated to support accessing it while away from home, admittedly. I don't know if that's an important feature for this application. That's the killer feature. What good is a home surveillance system if you have to be there to use it?
- cordonbleu 8y agoi can drop a link right now that will let you look around at my driveway, if i get to know you better i could give you a login so you can see it works.
- mulmen 8y agoThis feels like one of the huge benefits to true widespread adoption of IPv6. A firewall is still required but without NAS it becomes much easier to connect to individual devices on arbitrary networks from anywhere.
- mulmen 8y agoNAS? NAT.
- jbob2000 8y ago> A company could drop a camera and a small NAS box, and have it all work over the local WiFi. If you setup a company to do this, you will quickly find you are a customer service and call center company, NOT a security tech company.
- Mister_Snuggles 8y ago> It would get more complicated to support accessing it while away from home, admittedly. I don't know if that's an important feature for this application. This is a huge feature which I've solved using an IPSec VPN. This is not something that's easy for regular people to do though, so it's not a universal solution. If someone made a router that could easily provision VPN access for a device (e.g., generate a sensible OpenVPN config or something) it would make this setup a LOT easier.
- bradknowles 8y agoSynology has IP camera support out of the box. For one camera. If you want more, you have to buy more licenses, which are only available from them. In hard copy form. And they take a week or more to arrive. Been there, done that.
- Mister_Snuggles 8y ago> > A DVR and a set of "old school" network cameras in an internal network have none of those problems > Ring is a $300 purchase and takes an hour to install. This would take me a few weekends and would cost thousands of dollars. Cloud centralization makes things easier and cheaper, by orders of magnitude. I have a number of "old school" network cameras and an on-site DVR, it doesn't take "a few weekends" to set everything up. Adding a camera is simply a matter of following the instructions to connect it to the network. This would be the same process for a Ring or an "old school" camera. Adding a camera to Blue Iris is a 5-15 minute job, depending on how much tweaking you want to do to the motion detection settings. In terms of implementing from scratch, I picked up a refurbished Windows 10 Pro machine, set up and updated Windows, installed Blue Iris, and added my cameras, in an evening. Cost-wise, my setup is more expensive than a single Ring camera. However, my incremental costs are a lot cheaper since I can buy sub-$100 cameras instead of $300 ones. There's also no monthly fee, which is nice.
- syphilis2 8y agoThere's no monthly fee, but you do have the cost of running that Windows 10 machine. What does that amount to? At 100W and $0.14/kWh I calculate about $10, which is competitive with something like Nest Aware.
- Mister_Snuggles 8y agoThis really depends on the machine and how you deploy it. I picked up a refurbished SFF business desktop type of machine and the power draw is only 40-60W (with Blue Iris running and recording from all of my cameras). This is definitely a consideration though. More cameras and/or higher resolution cameras will result in more power consumption or require a beefier machine.
- illumin8 8y agoNot to mention if you get robbed they're going to take the PC that has your recordings on it, so good luck giving the police footage of your robbers...
- bradknowles 8y ago
- Lammy 8y agoI know this is going to sound a lot like “Why would anyone use dropbox when they could roll their own with an rsync shell script” but it’s not that bad. Please don’t spread FUD about the difficulty of freeing yourself from cloud surveillance. A copy of Blue Iris is $60, and you seem to be able to get 1080p indoor WiFi cameras for about another $60 each. Anyone who can connect a device to their wireless network, run a program, and forward a port can get equivalent functionality, and from my experience even a lot of non-tech-focused people are familiar with doing that for e.g. Xbox Live
- jbob2000 8y agoIKEA can't get people to assemble a fucking box, and you're here telling me that it's totally possible for people to set up their own networked camera system? Yes, it's possible. No, it's not easy. I've been working as a software dev for like 10 years now and I would happily purchase Ring instead of pulling my hair out for a whole weekend trying to yak-shave[1] my way to a hacked together security camera system. [1] https://seths.blog/2005/03/dont_shave_that/ https://seths.blog/2005/03/dont_shave_that/ Edit: Everyone, just read the replies to my original comment and you will see why Ring is better. There's a million different ways to setup a home camera system, each with their own intricacies and challenges. THIS is why Ring is better. It's the ONE solution that ties together all this technical bullshit that nobody really wants to deal with (unless you're passionate about networking. Which is probably a lot of the users on this board. Which is why I'm probably getting crushed with downvotes).
- mimixco 8y agoThe problem is that the original intent of buying such a device has now been subsumed under a tech company and government agenda, the surveillance state. When you see Ring on the shelf everywhere, it isn't advertised as a way to surveil you and your family, to scan your face and report your video and audio to cops. This reminds me of 23 and Me which acts like it's helping you but, by signing up, you agree to help Big Pharma and cops keep track of you.
- austhrow743 8y ago
- pwaivers 8y agoI assume if the internet goes down, then they can start storing video locally. Just replace your DVR with a hard drive.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoA DVR typically is the hard drive.
- underbluewaters 8y agoI've setup a homebrew system for my cameras and while fun initially it was a pain to maintain. Rather than spend a weekend getting the system back up and running before a recent trip I just bought a 150.00 baby monitor that supported Homekit. Way more convenient.
- hitpointdrew 8y ago>I've never understood why people seem to love these surveillance devices that rely on an external service It is simple really. With the cloud people don't have to worry about properly managing a server. If they want to access cameras remotely, well with a self-hosted solution then I need to have a proper firewall, security, etc. I need to monitor and maintain the system, perhaps setup fail2ban or something similar, a reverse proxy would also help. This is all a lot of work, or I can just outsource this to the cloud and not worry about it. That said, I would never ever, ever use ring or a system like it (ring directly partners with law enforcement agencies and gives them access to their customers cameras). I recently did a Camera installation at a clients house using Ubiquiti cameras. They cameras are great, and I trust Ubiquiit a hell of a lot more than Ring, to not share video with anyone. The web portal makes it great for management, the iOS app is a huge selling point to my client who loves that she can check the cameras from anywhere. TLDR: cloud isn't inherently bad, you just need to find the right cloud provider, or be willing to take on all the risk and responsibility of running everything on premises.
- mulmen 8y agoWhy is network security not important to your camera? Even without a server on premise you still don’t want random people on the internet to look up your webcam, right? So network security is important to all networks.
- hitpointdrew 8y ago>Why is network security not important to your camera? It is, but you don't have do very much to secure a camera. The camera is going to call out to whatever cloud provider, which is fine. You can easily just set your firewall to deny all incoming connections from outside (and you should) and the camera will still work fine, since it is calling out (the cloud isn't calling in). This makes it very easy to secure and manage. Self-hosting a security system you want to access remotely is a whole new ball game. Now you dealing with outside connections coming in, exposing ports on your firewall, and now you dealing with needing a static IP address and or figuring out a way around a DHCP address from you ISP. Making sure whatever server you have running your system is patched (both the OS and client software), since that machine is accessible to the outside world. You also need to setup SSL if you don't want your logins to be in clear text. Or all of that can be managed by a cloud provider that you (hopefully) have a degree of trust in. The cloud provider will already have SSL setup, they will have a team of security people monitoring and maintaining their servers. Personally I would never even consider a self-hosted solution, unless one of the follow two were true 1) I didn't care at all about remote access and just closed the system completely so it was only accessible on premises. 2)I was setting up a security appliance with VPN so the remote access could all go through a VPN.
- tptacek 8y agoFor outdoor monitoring, where my privacy concerns are minimal and where my security concerns are maximized, it's pretty straightforward: plug in a camera, get a many-days-history high-res video feed with alerting. What's not to understand? On my neighborhood Facebook groups, people need help just getting Nest and Ring cams set up. The idea that they were going to set up their own local DVR camera systems is pretty silly. I don't understand why people install speaker systems (like Alexa) and cameras in their houses; I wouldn't trust third party, even Google, to manage a feed of audio or video from inside my four walls. But outside, the privacy/security tradeoff is radically different, and the devices have been (for us) super valuable.
- jxcl 8y agoEh, I don't know about privacy concerns being minimal at the places where ring devices are installed. The ring doorbell is installed at your front door. It records pretty much all movement to and from your house. It records audio at the doorstep, so if you're having a conversation with anyone at your doorstep, that gets recorded too. If you have a porch and are sitting on it and speaking with people, etc etc etc.
- tptacek 8y agoI referred to the privacy/security "tradeoff", not an absence of privacy concerns. But for similar reasons, I'm unlikely to have an especially sensitive conversation at my doorstep anyways: my neighbors will be able to hear it. Obviously, they can also see who's coming and going at my house, as could anyone else who cared to watch. Meanwhile, the devices have been super valuable for spotting and reporting criminal attempts.
- tombrossman 8y agoAgree one selling point of the devices is ease of use, however for someone like me who is equally concerned about privacy, streaming video from my front door is a non-starter. In your scenario, "anyone else who cared to watch" includes anyone with an internet connection, versus some random prowler at high risk of being spotted casing your place due to their physical proximity. If some rando gets my ring doorbell footage and figures out where I live, that's hard to undo. If someone steals my stuff and gets away with it because I didn't have a ring doorbell, that's annoying but much easier to recover from. We are talking about the difference between an insurance claim and moving house. The right product for me may not exist yet, but I'd love to have a video doorbell system that I self-host. If I need remote backup I already have that covered, I'm on gigabit FTTH and use client-side encryption for data backups. I'm pretty nerdy and would enjoy setting this up but can't make it a priority now. Neither your points nor OP's conflict, I think you each just have different criteria and values for privacy and security.
- chaostheory 8y ago> I've never understood why people seem to love these surveillance devices that rely on an external service The same reason people love any external service such as email and calendars: convenience. There's a lot more work involved with video security system if you don't use consumer friendly versions.
- rhizome 8y agoTo be sure, SAAS companies put more resources into making the implementation convenient to setup and use, and to provide revenue, but there's no reason that setup and usability issues wouldn't also be dealt with in generic DVR systems if the same effort was expended.
- fomojola 8y agoTrue statement, BUT: in general most generic DVR systems are driven by people who are looking for advanced features. Convenient setup for non-expert users is (at best) a distant second.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- babypuncher 8y agoMost people don't even know what it means to forward a port on their router. They aren't going to know how to build a DVR and give it the same feature set as a Ring doorbell camera.
- autoexec 8y agoI assume it's because they want to mine the data they collect. Amazon can watch everyone who comes to your front door. They can easily learn things like how many people live in your home, if you are single, when you are dating, if you have children, how often you have food delivered, what types of clothing people in your area are wearing, what they talk about as they pass by etc. Tons of valuable data to collect if you can convince people to install a camera for you and hand over access to the feed.
- thinkling 8y ago> Amazon can watch everyone who comes to your front door. They can easily learn... No need to do difficult and processor-intensive video & audio analysis. They can get most of that from the products you're ordering from them. Remember when Target outed a young woman for being pregnant based on the things she was buying? That was 6 years ago.
- ab_io 8y agoOne of the biggest selling points of these services is that you can view your live video feed from anywhere via mobile device -- A savvy tech enthusiast might be able to create such a setup by hand, but the majority of people wouldn't know where to begin.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoIt makes sense for security. If someone breaks in and steals your camera and local storage, what good is it? I would like to see a camera where I can control the S3 account that the data is uploaded to.