4 ms·
> can handle calls/text, and that's it The number of people who just want a phone to call and text is I'd imagine vanishingly small now. It won't replace anyon
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> can handle calls/text, and that's it
The number of people who just want a phone to call and text is I'd imagine vanishingly small now. It won't replace anyone's proprietary smartphone like that.
- nerdponx 8y agoThis is probably true, but how many people need a mini-HDMI port?
- ploxiln 8y agoTrue, but good video drivers, and good calls/texts, are often the very hardest parts for an open-source phone project. The rest can be improved later, by community contributors even. Historically the case has often been "well it can do wifi and browse the web, has some built-in chat apps, it's just a bit slow to scroll around, cellular data kinda works sometimes ... not worth trying to call with it, maybe next rev will have better modem support". Without calls and texts you really need another phone, so the project never gets a big enough community.
- voltagex_ 8y agoIt's got a low res screen and a slower processor than 2018 phones, and it costs $700 US - I don't think it's going to get a big community. I owned an OpenMoko and a N900, too - but sometimes you just need to get stuff done.
- adontz 8y agoBut what else do you need? Facebook App?
- chrisseaton 8y agoI would imagine most people hardly use phone calls or SMS. People need maps, a browser, WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Twitter, Instagram. They consider these absolute basics of a phone these days. Before you say 'all I use my phone for is phoning' well that's not what most people do by any stretch.
- adontz 8y agoI will say, why you need open phone if you install Facebook and WhatsApp into it?
- chrisseaton 8y agoWell you don't, do you. Not many people will need or be able to use an open phone.
- marcosdumay 8y agoJust because you have Facebook software running at it does not automatically mean Facebook can do anything with the phone. Getting Facebook sandboxed can be a great reason to get an open phone. It's certainly more reasonable than displaying video out.
- noobermin 8y agoWhy the need for purity? Firefox released an add-on to sandbox facebook tabs, you can easily make things better without having to turn yourself into a hermit.
- baroffoos 8y agoThe librem 5 is not a phone for most people. Its a phone for mini stallmans who want to still be contactable. I doubt anyone who spends $1000 on this phone with the specs of a $300 phone is planning to install Instagram on it. The core features people care about on this device is open source firmware, encrypted messaging, open source OS, replaceable parts, headphone jack, and sd card slot. This is the phone for the people who are not being represented by all the devices made for "most people"
- kgwxd 8y agoSorry, data too. I figured that's a given. So, more specifically, Linux with a touchscreen, wi-fi and cell data/call/text. Anything else is unnecessary to get me to buy one. And it doesn't have to replace my existing phone right away. There's a trend of people opting for feature phones instead of iPhone/Android. That is what I'm going for next if something like Librem doesn't make it out soon. Now is the time to just get something out, while people are weary of the whole corporate-controlled smartphone thing, because, if that trend fades, no one outside of the Linux community is buying a Linux phone, no matter what it comes with. Just get it out, no gimmicks, not even a camera (one less thing to secure), sell it at a premium price and let the community figure out where to go from there.
- jay_kyburz 8y agoYes, but this thing is $700. A feature phone is $50. The Librem 5 needs to be something special.
- kungtotte 8y agoBeing free and open is something special... This is more about providing freedom in an otherwise totally un-free market instead of competing with the latest iPhone.