5 ms·
Hooking up three monitors, 2 of which are 4k onto Ubuntu is the most frustrating thing I've done with that OS. It just works on OSX though. Rough spots is a go
by Waterluvian 8y ago
Hooking up three monitors, 2 of which are 4k onto Ubuntu is the most frustrating thing I've done with that OS. It just works on OSX though.
Rough spots is a good way to describe it. Overall it works... But not without effort and competence.
- InitialLastName 8y agoThat doesn't "Just work" on Windows 7 or 10, though, so not sure it's a failure on the part of Linux as much as a success on the part of macOS.
- raesene9 8y agoAnecdata incoming, multi-monitor on Win 10 works just fine for me. I've got 2 screens attached to my laptop and they're just fine, even with different scaling on each one.
- joombaga 8y agoIt does work though. X can't be configured with 2 different DPIs at all.
- cr0sh 8y agoAre you sure? http://wok.oblomov.eu/tecnologia/mixed-dpi-x11/ http://wok.oblomov.eu/tecnologia/mixed-dpi-x11/ I can't say I've played around with it, but the above seems to indicate that such support is available - but that you might have issues with apps not supporting it (or reporting their DPI properly). There also might be problems with other layers above raw X (?) - but it seems like X itself does support it in some manner? I once had X supporting two mice on dual monitors (this was a while back - I had a couple of CRT monitors at the time); seeing that made me think X could do almost anything I asked of it (depending on how I "asked").
- joombaga 8y agoNope! Looks like I was wrong. I was never able to get it working on Gnome without the upscale/downscale workaround suggested in your link (resulting in terribly degraded image quality), but perhaps that is the fault of Gnome/GTK. It wouldn't have occurred to me that the fault could lie in any other layer than that which controls the resolution/DPI, but I'm certainly no expert on the Linux graphical stack.
- zrobotics 8y agoHow does that fail? I've never had issues with multi-monitor, and they've always been 3 different resolutions (with one rotated 90). I'm not doubting you, as my current win10 install won't let me change the default JSON association away from visual studio and I can't find anyone else with that problem. I'm just curious what fails, since I haven't encountered problems with multi-monitor since XP.
- stevehawk 8y agoI hate running multiple monitors in Windows 10. I was running 24" + 27" BenQ monitors (same model/specs, just diff sizes) and Windows would reboot and ignore both. On my laptop I would go into the display settings and try to turn them on and just get a "Failed to save settings" message. This usually resolved itself after a reboot or two. I honestly got so tired of it I just invested in an Alienware 34" monitor. I haven't had the problem since.
- stevehawk 8y agoI should add that while Ubuntu did not have this problem.. because the monitor configuration is apparently loaded post login screen I had other issues - like my login prompt being on the wrong monitor. Especially if I was using LUKS on my primary drive, but that one is a bit more obvious as to why. *setup is an Alienware 15 laptop which supports dual monitor out for up to 3 active displays if including the laptop monitor
- Waterluvian 8y agoI can boot my system into windows 10 right now and it all just works.
- Groxx 8y agoSince there are counter-anecdotes, I'll throw in my supporting anecdote: I've had endless problems with multi-monitor on Windows 10. Especially if they're different display densities. Windows that go out of bounds and are un-retrievable, permanently glitched window-content rendering when moving between densities, inaccurate mouse positions, desktops that resize to like 320x200 and then to the actual (shrinking every window and mashing all icons together, and breaking the notification area and status bar area in the process), I don't think I've ever had it work out-of-the-box even once on multiple machines and multiple monitors / projectors / etc. Some of this only occurs the first time it learns a new setup, but much of it just keeps happening randomly. On macs for like the past 5+ years? Almost perfect behavior, for almost every OS version, except on apps that clearly do their own thing (e.g. IntelliJ sometimes shrinks to nothingness, and Steam is just hot garbage much of the time).
- walterstucco 8y agoI've dropped OS X because of multi monitor setup not working, but works great on Linux with KDE
- willtim 8y agoWell, in my office, we have both OSX and Linux users and it's only the Linux users who can daisy chain our monitors using displayport MST!
- Lordarminius 8y ago> Hooking up three monitors... My exact same problem! How did you solve it ?
- eeperson 8y agoI've set this up before. How many video cards are you trying to use to connect these monitors? I've always had it just work if you are only using one card. In the past I've had to invoke xrandr with the --setprovideroutputsource flag (or was it --setprovideroffloadsink ?) to get multiple monitors to work with multiple video cards. Note, this only works with the open source drivers and you must be using an X server that supports randr 1.4.
- kugelblitz 8y agoI had a similar problem the last days. I have an Alienware 15 R3 with GTX 1070. Using Ubuntu 18.04 (LTS... kernel 4.15, I think) didn’t work, also the latest Manjaro (kernel 4.19) didn’t. Using Ubuntu 18.10 (Kernel 4.18) I was able to hook up 2x 4Ks (1x USB-C to HDMI and 1x Mini-DP to Display Port) and 1x QHD (1440p) via HDMI; I was also able to use the laptop screen (1080p). I think only the Mini-DP to DP is outputting at 60 Hz, the other 2 screens at 30 Hz. I think turning off Thunderbolt 3 on the USB-C port was possible in Ubuntu 18.10 which made the difference (I also read in a forum that this made a difference for someone else; but I couldn’t turn off Thunderbolt 3 in my BIOS). I think in the latest kernel developments there have been lots of updates on USB-C and ports in general. But that’s why I like Linux as well; it gives me the options to use different distributions and environments. It might be messy sometimes, but I’m not locked in to one vendor.
- callinyouin 8y agoNot exactly your experience, but using a single (non-4k) external monitor is slightly painful for me with my MBP. It sometimes takes ~10 seconds for my display to work after plugging it in, with lots of intermittent flickering as the OS "figures it out". And afterwards, the menu bar on the external is a bit glitchy looking on the right side until I click on it. With my other laptop running Fedora the experience is much faster/cleaner. Not a big deal, but just thought I'd mention that macOS isn't exactly perfect when it comes to external monitors.
- csomar 8y agoThe usb ports of the MBP delivers too little Wattage. Try having a hub with power. It solved my problems.
- plussed_reader 8y agoUSB =/= MiniDisplayPort/Thunderbolt
- emilecantin 8y agoThis is an area of macOS that's gotten slightly worse over the years. It used to work much better than that, even El Cap used to flicker only once.
- pfranz 8y agoApple introduced some issues in recent generations of hardware that I haven't heard many people talk about. A recent Macbook and Macbook Pro with USB-C using an Apple's USB-C to HDMI adapter had terrible connection issues for me. I did hear a few references online from others with the same issue. Using a 2009 and 2011 Thunderbolt to HDMI the same monitor worked fine. I fixed the issue by using a USB-C to DisplayPort adapter made by a third party. I think that also allowed 4k at 60Hz. I later switched to a multi-port adapter with HDMI out and didn't have this problem. This problem was horrible noise and loss of connection. People hate dongles for the convenience and price factor, but I think everyone underestimates how it introduces technical and compatibility issues.
- jasondclinton 8y agoIt sounds like you hit the point in Linux where this is painful: mixed DPI displays with mixed display scaling. Wayland fixes that. And soon, we'll finally have fractional scaling, too. GNOME is close to delivering that. So, it's getting better.
- Waterluvian 8y agoThat's the best thing I've heard all week. Thank you!
- matwood 8y agoFinally! When I was searching for solutions to this issue a couple of years ago one response was 'no one needs 4k displays' smh.
- pfranz 8y agoI've always heard these were fundamental problems because of how X is architected. Something like everything assumes the desktop is a single, contiguous grid. Everyone built tooling top of X and tried to mitigate the problems. I thought it was odd when Apple got a lot of heat for not using X and writing their own thing. It sounds like Apple had evaluated X and determined it wouldn't fit their needs. The same thing happened when things like Wayland started getting written.
- cmurf 8y ago15" Laptop has a 1920x1080 display that's not quite hidpi. So I'm using layout.css.devPixelsPerPx value in about:config of 1.4, and in GNOME Settings > Accessibility, enable large text. This does make things a bit too big on the 24" external display which has nearly the same resolution, but it's not distracting. Some websites I use CTRL-+ and CTRL-- to change the scaling, or rather fine tune it, depending on more than +-20% and the rendering gets wonky. Firefox seems to remember this per site even after a relaunch or reboot. The biggest problem I have is Bluetooth, my mouse is always disconnecting on Linux, dozens of times per day, but the same laptop+mouse rebooted to Windows 10 - no problem.
- soperj 8y ago>But not without effort and competence. Which most people in this forum have plenty of. This isn't a post saying "Linux is ready for everyone on every laptop", it's that it works for this person using a pre-approved set of hardware, just as MacOS is apparently terrible on other hardware.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoIt certainly doesn't just work on my Macbook Pro. Sometimes only one monitor wakes up. Sometimes the touchbar wakes up but there's nothing on the laptop screen or external monitors. Sometimes when the lid is closed it never wakes up. Sometimes the OS forgets which monitor is which and I need to move the mouse off the left edge of my left monitor to get to the right edge of my right monitor.