7 ms·
A while back I was reading a stack of financial books, and in one of them the author (I think it was William Bernstein) wrote that he'd had the opportunity to i
by DennisP 8y ago
A while back I was reading a stack of financial books, and in one of them the author (I think it was William Bernstein) wrote that he'd had the opportunity to interview a member of one of these families, and asked how they'd managed to hold onto their wealth for 600+ years.
The answer was "art, gold, and land." If you had a rich estate back then and a foreign army was on the way, you could roll up your art, put your gold in sacks, and ride away. The title to the land would still be yours, and after the foreign army is expelled you just return home with your stuff.
I can think of some risks with this plan, and some improvements that could be made today, but basically these people aren't chasing returns, they think about preserving wealth for the long haul through worst-case scenarios.
- Tade0 8y agoThis idea ultimately didn't work in eastern Europe. My family used to own some land but after WW2 it became Soviet territory and was lost. We received some compensation eventually, but it was a pittance comparing to the original value.
- twooclock 8y agoLuckily at least you're alive. In my country whole social class was wiped out after ww2.
- zokier 8y ago> After World War II, Czechoslovakia, the predecessor of the Czech Republic and Slovakia, acting to seize what they considered to be German possessions, expropriated the entirety of the Liechtenstein dynasty's hereditary lands and possessions in Bohemia, Moravia, and Silesia which compose the Czech Republic. The expropriations (which were the subject of an unsuccessful court case brought by Liechtenstein in the German courts and the International Court of Justice) included over 1,600 km² (which is ten times the size of Liechtenstein) of agricultural and forest land mostly in Moravia, also including several family castles and palaces. Yup.
- Brockenstein 8y agoI would say it worked until the world changed in such a way that old systems were entirely dismantled. But even in previous eras that system of wealth preservation only worked when it worked. If the invading army was never expelled, your land could be lost. And carrying all those valuables around with you while fleeing, well I'm sure people still got robbed sometimes. So it wasn't a foolproof solution. But there were limited options, and maybe not a better options. Even now, what's the solution for wealth preservation in times of upheaval and displacement? I have no idea. Right now most of us trust in the banking system to some degree and that's only good as long as the system stands. If it collapses we're all boned and might wish for a bit more art, gold, and land to fall back on.
- matthewaveryusa 8y agomy family was in the same boat but never got any compensation, probably partly due to the territory being swapped to a different sovereign nation ( old Poland -> contemporary Ukraine)
- Tade0 8y agoExactly the same kind of shift here. That being said the compensation, IIRC, didn't cross 10k PLN, so divided between all people entitled it wasn't much.
- systemshutdown 8y agoRelevant Article: Poland's lost property https://www.ft.com/content/be98d9aa-360d-11df-aa43-00144feabdc0 https://www.ft.com/content/be98d9aa-360d-11df-aa43-00144feab...
- InitialLastName 8y agoSo maybe "art, gold, land, and 600 years of government that respects the continuity of property holdings of their subjects".
- Tade0 8y agoThat's a pretty rare occurrence. IIRC France and Italy(or actually various states occupying this territory throughout history) qualify here. Not sure about Germany with its cycles of partition and unification but everything east of Berlin to the Ural mountains is out of the question.
- silexia 8y agoWe need to tax wealth, not income, to increase social mobility. Taxing income hurts entrepreneurs, taxing wealth pushes the idle rich to work harder.
- koheripbal 8y agoTaxing wealth will only increase the mobility of the wealthy.
- pc86 8y agoThis does all sort of go out of the window once the worst case scenario becomes "the government steals everything from you and kills you if you resist."
- rebuilder 8y agoCareful with the terminology there. "Stealing" is only really meaningful in the context of a legal framework, which happened to change in most places in Europe around the turn of the 20th century. I'm more inclined to frame it in terms of an outdated, inegalitarian social order being overturned, resulting in massive upheaval and atrocities due to the power vacuum being rapidly filled again by the most ruthless actors.
- petre 8y agoIt's still stealing even if it's called "eminent domain" or "civil asset forfeiture". It's basically stealing backed by little green men with guns.
- mattferderer 8y agoReminds me of a great post on here a while back from some accountants. They argued (ultra) wealthy families care more about preserving wealth for generations than high interest rates.
- gowld 8y agoHigh interest rates is how wealth is preserved in the face of spending.
- rtkwe 8y agoIt depends on just how much money the family has. If the pile of cash is big enough even conservative interest rates/rates of return can cover a really good life.
- ThirdFoundation 8y agoI remember a similar discussion on here about hedge funds. The goals of the ultra-rich investors are often very different than average people. In a 401k investment account we try to find the best ways to get a return on investment and increase the value of assets. There's risk involved, but for many it's the best chance they have for a true retirement. Ultra-rich, on the other hand, often go to their hedge fund manager with the simple goal of "can you make sure I'm never not rich." They aren't focused on the upside of their investments (though they probably at least want to keep up with inflation) -- they're concerned with the __downside__ and the risk of becoming 'not rich.'
- gowld 8y agoThat requires land to run to, and sanctuary that doesn't relieve you of your gold when you arrive. It only works for the 0.001% . Chasing returns is not incompatible with wealth preservation; they are strategies for different scenariors. No one is chasing returns when the bullets are flying into their face.
- Passthepeas 8y agounless you sell guns of course
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- marnett 8y agoFinancing wars has always been lucrative, and remains lucrative to this day.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoso the richest families in Florence in 1427 were the 0.001 percent? At any rate it seemed to have worked for them.
- rock_hard 8y agoIts called survivor bias :)
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoso you're saying that there are a number of formerly rich families at the time who have not made it to the present with wealth intact? I guess that seems reasonable, but don't have any data yet. On the other hand there should still be some wealth today that was not among the wealthiest then? (of course I wonder how much of that maintaining wealth was - instead of gold, art, and land - strategic marriage)
- 8y ago
- Spooky23 8y agoI wonder if the Italian states had a hands off attitude on inheritance and titles because of the church?
- normal_man 8y agoThis seems to rely pretty heavily on the "title" to the land being respected. Works fine until the foreign army ISN'T expelled.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoOf the foreign army gets expelled by a force that has zero interest in respecting whoever was there previously. At that point you might as well throw in the towel and open up a cheap Chinese buffet restaurant in a former mill town in upstate NY (or something like that).
- PurpleRamen 8y agoIf the title is not respected, they still have their art and gold. I think the real statement here is: have something that afterwards still has some value, which you can use to build upon. Other sources of wealth like money, will more like be gone when the state folds, or time goes on. Timeless wealthes are the way to stay rich over the ages.
- njarboe 8y agoFor most of those 600 years gold was money.
- PurpleRamen 8y agoCoins were money. Gold was just one of the materials they were made from. There also was copper, silver, and others. Raw gold alone was somewhat useful, but AFAIK usually not as valuable as local gold-coins. Usually trading something golden meant accepting some loss, like today.
- njarboe 8y agoAnd even then it sometimes works. Many (but not all) large Spanish land grants were respected in the US southwest/California after the Mexican/American war.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThat's a nice anecdote, but it's really bad science.
- Supermancho 8y agoThat's a nice anecdote, but it's also really bad buttering.
- wahooligan 8y agoThey took advantage of diversification. Unfortunately most of us don't have access to more esoteric asset classes (e.g., fine wine, art, high end cars).
- pc86 8y agoThat's not the point at all. The point was that their wealth was in assets that do not depreciate, and are hard to take by force.
- kamaal 8y ago>>these people aren't chasing returns, they think about preserving wealth for the long haul through worst-case scenarios. Once you make a non-trivial amount of money. Preserving it becomes way more important than adding deltas to it. Not getting famous, keeping low key and not breeding exponentially also helps.
- yellowstuff 8y agoI believe you are paraphrasing James Rickards, EG from US News: > When one inquires of family members and representatives as to what it takes to preserve wealth over centuries and not just cycles, the frequent reply is "a third, a third, and a third." This is shorthand for dividing one's wealth into one-third land, one-third gold, and one-third fine art. https://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/economic-intelligence/2012/04/16/the-three-ways-old-money-holds-on-to-its-riches https://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/economic-intelligence/2... Since I'm fairly familiar with finance and could not find this rule anywhere else I assume he means "a lot of people say" in the Trumpian sense, IE he made it up. There's no data backing the idea that families that have stayed rich invested in those particular assets. While it's fun to think about escaping from the invading hoards with you sack of gold and a rolled up Old Master in your sack, my guess is that the continued wealth of the Florentine families has more to do with passing on education and cultural advantages, and being lucky enough to live in a relatively stable society.