6 ms·
As impressive as this toy sounds, I don't see how it is related to robotics. The comparison between a vibrator and a full sex robot does not make sense to me; a
by jeroenhd 8y ago
As impressive as this toy sounds, I don't see how it is related to robotics. The comparison between a vibrator and a full sex robot does not make sense to me; a sex bot needs to articulate joints and show human expressions, a vibrator needs to make some ver slight movements in very specific places.
I don't blame the author for being upset about this because I can't see a reason to retract the submission to the contest. I do, however, feel like these kinds of sex toys are only minimally related to robotics, so I think they shouldn't have been able to submit their device in the first place. That's another fault on the end of CES. As sibling comments note, there's been vibrators on the robotics section before, but it might be that they slipped through the submission process as well and, to prevent controversy, let through unscathed. Now that more of these submissions come through the board seems to have decided that enough is enough and actually speak out against these just-if-not-nearly robotic devices.
Their defence that the product has been designed with the help of roboticists is very strange. If me and a few aerospace engineers build a fence that fence does not qualify as a space craft, no matter how many heat shield we stick to the side of it.
Spending half the page blabbering about empowerment of women and LBQTI+ only detracts from their argument. Their baseless claim of mysoginy and homophobia distracts from their reasons for why they should be included in the first place and should not have been included in this response. It makes the author of the piece look very unprofessional and desperate for help from some of those action groups that take to the streets the moment they see the word "discrimination".
- undecisive 8y agoThat sounds plausible. And I think if the first communication on the matter had been about the difference between robots and devices containing robotics technology, that would be correct. However the first communication (according to the original post) was about indecent / not in keeping with CES image. The "Oh well, it's not even a real robot" seems like an afterthought. So not really a "baseless claim". A stretch, maybe, but a pretty reasonable one, all things considered.
- jeroenhd 8y agoTo me the first response sounds very much like a canned PR response written by someone with little knowledge of what goes on inside CES. CES has allowed vibrators before so I don't see why they wouldn't stroke with policy now. As another comment in this thread states, OhMiBod has been showcased for years. I think at first someone at the top (or middle management) just said "that's not relevant, someone get that project out of here", which got passed down the chain of the company to some intern writing a standard email with a useless explanation. Then, when that blew up, an actual response was formed by the PR department, then by the top of the company, complicated further by the authors of this piece contacting people unrelated to either statement and getting another explanation from them. Just a corporate communications cluster fuck. "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity" and all that.
- foldr 8y agoThe chain of events you're describing illustrates how sexism actually works. It's not usually the result of a cabal of Evil Sexists deliberately doing their best to be sexists.
- ubercow13 8y agoWhat part of that chain of events would lead to a sexist outcome? Where's the gender bias introduced?
- foldr 8y agoI think CES's half-formed "this is immoral" and "this is not a robot" excuses would have been less likely if the product was targeted at men.
- specialp 8y agoWithout an example of them showing bias by actually giving an award to a product that is much like theirs that targets men this is sheer conjecture, and presumption of bias. Has the CES ever given an award for an adult product? Perhaps it could be due to the USA having very puritan views on sex still to this day (Violence OK on broadcast TV, but no nudity/sex).
- noptd 8y agoAgreed, this seems like a blatant attempt at co-oping the empowerment movement in order to boost their bottom line. According to Fortune (http://fortune.com/2019/01/09/the-ose-toy-ces2019/ http://fortune.com/2019/01/09/the-ose-toy-ces2019/), CES responded to the author two months ago. If this is truly about airing grievances about losing the award, why wait until now to publish a respose?
- aboutruby 8y agoI think it's because it made the frontpage of reddit
- DanBC 8y agoIt made the Guardian where I read it. HN asks people to submit the original article, which is why I submitted this.
- jploh 8y ago>Agreed, this seems like a blatant attempt at co-oping the empowerment movement in order to boost their bottom line. Exactly this. On a side note, where can I get more information about the Osé (e.g. prototype, demo video)?
- vilda 8y agoTo add, there's not much inclusivity in a company of single female-only product, in a market of overwhelmingly female-oriented products. Doesn't that fit into "majority" category? Has there been any inovation for men toys?
- saagarjha 8y ago> a market of overwhelmingly female-oriented products What market are you talking about? This claim seems pretty dubious. > Has there been any inovation for men toys? See: CES.
- cannonedhamster 8y agoThe posting literally describes sex toys for men at CES being displayed. There have also been numerous sex toys over the years by multiple partners and companies. I'm not sure why the award was withdrawn, however none of the options make CES look good.
- marcus_holmes 8y ago> "Spending half the page blabbering about empowerment of women and LBQTI+ only detracts from their argument. Their baseless claim of mysoginy and homophobia distracts..." Rather than dismissing all that information as "blabbering", maybe consider the possibility that it forms the base of their not-so-"baseless" claim of bias? Just a suggestion... And when I read it, it made perfect sense that this is a robot. As they presented it, this is a machine that uses a variety of movements and sensory feedback to achieve a very precise effect on a subject. There's lots of "robots" that do less. And, y'know... it's a tricky effect to achieve (in a lot of cases - there's a huge variety of responses to stimulus).
- kkarakk 8y agobut it does get them clicks and is a way to milk the situation. marketing is getting paid for this one. mo one cares about appeals to reason. everyone clicks on appeals to emotion
- tebs1200 8y agoIt comes down to semantics, but based off the opening paragraph on "Robot" it seems that it would fit the definition: "A robot is a machine—especially one programmable by a computer— capable of carrying out a complex series of actions automatically. Robots can be guided by an external control device or the control may be embedded within. Robots may be constructed to take on human form but most robots are machines designed to perform a task with no regard to how they look" From the description in the article it sounded like the entry managed complex simulations of a tongue and fingers. I can see how it could be defined as a robot. I haven't looked up what the CES definition/guidelines for a robotics entry is though.
- jbob2000 8y agoIs an articulating cordless drill a robot? Because that’s all this thing is. It’s still an electronic, but it’s not a robot. If this thing could learn and sense which movements produced the best effects, then it would be a robot. But it’s no different than a remote control car, and we don’t call those robots.
- tebs1200 8y agoNo - An articulating cordless drill can't carry out a "complex series of actions" and it can't do anything automatically. It stated in the article that the device's operation could be tailored to each individual's preferences.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- forkLding 8y agoIt does match the definition of a robot as based on this dictionary's second definition: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/robot https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/robot There was also likely a long process for awards, its a pretty scumbag move to suddenly just not give the award/honor after announcing it, I can imagine my anger too if someone was going to give me an award and then not. CES is in the wrong here, they've been quite unprofessional. The lady does sound a bit too dramatic but I imagine she is pissed, that's all.
- ericb 8y agoWhen the reason for rejection is "obscenity" and they are letting exhibits play porn in the exhibit hall, I'd be pissed too.
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoThat wasn’t the reason though.
- mc32 8y agoAwards get retracted from time to time, mostly political reasons. I think it’s silly. Once you award, you shouldn’t take it back, but it’s not unheard of.
- ryanmercer 8y ago>I can imagine my anger too if someone was going to give me an award and then not Reminds me of the Miss Universe mix up with Steve Harvey and the Oscar mix up with Warren Betty except an order of magnitude worse.
- danillonunes 8y agoProblem is: The toy already won the robotics award and it was only withdraw later. The conclusion that can be taken from your explanation is that CES have a bunch of robots experts in the judging team of a robotics contest and they could’t tell what is or isn’t a robot before awarding it a prize. That’s even worse in my opinion. If I was them, I would rather stick with the accusation of sexism.
- mmjaa 8y agoIts a robot because it replaces a function normally performed by a human with an automated system.