10 ms·
We won a CES robotics innovation award, then they took it back
- catwell 8y agoA French sex toy for women (Little Bird by B. Sensory) already won a CES innovation award in 2016. I can't remember if it was in the robotics category or not. We are already reading the arguments of one side here, I wonder what the actual justification for the rejection was.
- noptd 8y agoThe Fortune article has more context- http://fortune.com/2019/01/09/the-ose-toy-ces2019/ http://fortune.com/2019/01/09/the-ose-toy-ces2019/ Considering CES responded two months ago, why publish this response now? Seems more of a strategic PR play in the news cycle IMO. I'm 100% for the equality/equity movement but this seems to be an attempt at co-oping it for PR in order to boost a bottom line, at the expense of providing ammo to those who wish to discredit the movement entirely.
- jeroenhd 8y agoAs impressive as this toy sounds, I don't see how it is related to robotics. The comparison between a vibrator and a full sex robot does not make sense to me; a sex bot needs to articulate joints and show human expressions, a vibrator needs to make some ver slight movements in very specific places. I don't blame the author for being upset about this because I can't see a reason to retract the submission to the contest. I do, however, feel like these kinds of sex toys are only minimally related to robotics, so I think they shouldn't have been able to submit their device in the first place. That's another fault on the end of CES. As sibling comments note, there's been vibrators on the robotics section before, but it might be that they slipped through the submission process as well and, to prevent controversy, let through unscathed. Now that more of these submissions come through the board seems to have decided that enough is enough and actually speak out against these just-if-not-nearly robotic devices. Their defence that the product has been designed with the help of roboticists is very strange. If me and a few aerospace engineers build a fence that fence does not qualify as a space craft, no matter how many heat shield we stick to the side of it. Spending half the page blabbering about empowerment of women and LBQTI+ only detracts from their argument. Their baseless claim of mysoginy and homophobia distracts from their reasons for why they should be included in the first place and should not have been included in this response. It makes the author of the piece look very unprofessional and desperate for help from some of those action groups that take to the streets the moment they see the word "discrimination".
- undecisive 8y agoThat sounds plausible. And I think if the first communication on the matter had been about the difference between robots and devices containing robotics technology, that would be correct. However the first communication (according to the original post) was about indecent / not in keeping with CES image. The "Oh well, it's not even a real robot" seems like an afterthought. So not really a "baseless claim". A stretch, maybe, but a pretty reasonable one, all things considered.
- jeroenhd 8y agoTo me the first response sounds very much like a canned PR response written by someone with little knowledge of what goes on inside CES. CES has allowed vibrators before so I don't see why they wouldn't stroke with policy now. As another comment in this thread states, OhMiBod has been showcased for years. I think at first someone at the top (or middle management) just said "that's not relevant, someone get that project out of here", which got passed down the chain of the company to some intern writing a standard email with a useless explanation. Then, when that blew up, an actual response was formed by the PR department, then by the top of the company, complicated further by the authors of this piece contacting people unrelated to either statement and getting another explanation from them. Just a corporate communications cluster fuck. "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity" and all that.
- foldr 8y agoThe chain of events you're describing illustrates how sexism actually works. It's not usually the result of a cabal of Evil Sexists deliberately doing their best to be sexists.
- ubercow13 8y agoWhat part of that chain of events would lead to a sexist outcome? Where's the gender bias introduced?
- mbrumlow 8y agoMaybe they should have submitted their product to the appropriate catagoey -- the one with all the other sex toys.
- akuji1993 8y agoMight wanna put an NSFW tag on this...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vkaku 8y agoIf they wanted to avoid obscenity, they should have taken down all the toys and any sexist entertainment out there. It just doesn't seem fair to this curly looking innovative toy.
- ryanmercer 8y ago> any sexist entertainment out there Indeed. Booth babes, 'fitness' models, etc are blatant wink wink nudge nudge "this isn't eye candy specifically to lure in male reporters and buyers, they're here to welcome you to our product booth and nothing else, honest".
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoWhy are they playing the gender bias card here? It’s odd to take it back, but this clearly has nothing to do with gender. What a silly ploy for even more attention.
- jakobegger 8y agoAccording to the article, they aren't allowed to exhibit their sex toy for women at CES, while a sex doll for men and VR porn targeted at men are on display. There may be other explanations, but it does look like a bit of a double standard.
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoThe previous sex toy that won an award was for women, from OhMiBod, founded by a woman. This is just a weak attempt to create controversy. It has nothing to do with them being women and that’s a silly first assumption. If you go to the OhMiBod website, they have a big ad up boasting of their CES 2019 presence, including their all-female lineup of vibrators. “The company’s experience contrasts starkly with the way CTA has treated sex toy company OhMiBod. Based in New Hampshire, the company has a variety of vibrators on display. They launched more than a decade ago and first appeared at CES in 2011 with a vibrator that synced to music on an iPod. They’ve been at the show ever since, and have received nothing but support from CTA, said co-founder Suki Dunham.” Also, there is nothing gender-specific about VR porn. The fact that they were notified by CES 2 months ago and only launched a cheap smear campaign now is also telling. And another year, a product by B.sensory, another smart vibrator, also won an award. Also a female founder. But yeah, clearly they hate companies run by women and products for women. Face it, you are getting played by a PR op here. Startups will do anything for coverage, and this is a pretty low brow tactic. Sadly, it worked very well. It’s unfortunate because it really waters down actual incidents of sexism, and people are getting desensitized to claims that any adversity someone faces is because everyone else is a racist or sexist. That’s counterproductive to the cause.
- foldr 8y ago>The previous sex toy that won an award was for women, from OhMiBod, founded by a woman So...this completely undermines CES's revised story (that they can't give the Lora DiCarlo toy an award because there's no category for sex toys). The fact that CES has given two separate reasons for this decision, neither of which makes sense, isn't exactly making them look good.
- fermienrico 8y agoI’m trying to link the accusation of gender bias and LGBT rights with the act of conceding the Innovation Award. Looks like their reason is that “it does not fall under Robotics category” which the article debates well. But, what actions and indications lead to gender bias? If I am a woman and I get rejected from a job, I don’t immediately start accusing the interviewer of gender bias. It hurts the cause for real issues when the noise in the social media is due to all kinds of baseless accusations.
- foldr 8y agohttps://www.engadget.com/2018/01/10/there-s-a-new-sex-robot-in-town-say-hello-to-solana/ https://www.engadget.com/2018/01/10/there-s-a-new-sex-robot-... Did you read through the article? It's laughable for CES to claim that sex toys are somehow too "obscene" for it or are off topic.
- eliseumds 8y agoExactly.
- noptd 8y agoThey claim it is too obscene in the context of the innovation award categories- there isn't one for sex toys (https://www.ces.tech/Events-Programs/Innovation-Awards/Honorees.aspx https://www.ces.tech/Events-Programs/Innovation-Awards/Honor...). I absolutely agree that they are overly puritanical when it comes to adult products in general though.
- icebraining 8y agoThe "Tech for a better world" category seems to be a catch-all, including such things as the Nissan LEAF, a smart pet bed, and a wine preservation opener.
- noptd 8y agoAgreed. Unfortunately the organizers seem to limit the innovation award to PG-rated products :/
- bjourne 8y agoFor those who didn't read the article... The author is claiming that their is a partial lewdness order among products so that normal products <= robotic vibrator <= vr porn. Therefore, if the lewdness threshold doesn't ban vr porn it cannot ban robotic vibrators either. But since robotic vibrators are banned and not vr porn, discrimination must be at play.
- lawnchair_larry 8y ago”Robotic” vibrators are not banned. OhMiBod (woman founder, too) has had them on display for years, and have a booth this year. Apparently it adjusts intensity based on your heartbeat from your apple watch now! Also, a smart vibrator from last year, also by a woman founder: https://sextechguide.com/news/mysteryvibe-crescendo-app-update/ https://sextechguide.com/news/mysteryvibe-crescendo-app-upda... The lewdness thing is inconsistent but clearly has nothing whatsoever to do with gender bias or sexism.
- noptd 8y agoOhMiBod's categorization as a personal massager is probably the determining factor- it provides the organizers enough plausible deniability to have it displayed on the main floor.
- rndgermandude 8y agoI didn't read it as "vibrators are banned in general", but as "vibrators are banned from receiving awards (in the robotics category)". As far as I can tell, the VR porn and the "sex robot for men" were not given awards either. They were just present on the CES.
- edh649 8y agoI believe they're not allowed to exhibit either (unless there exhibiting rights where prehaps dependent on winning an award) we were unexpectedly informed that the administrators at CES and CTA were rescinding our award and subsequently that we would not be allowed to showcase Osé, or even exhibit at CES 2019
- johny_q 8y agoI think I know why they took it back. You see, they always told people that penis means masculinity, and masculinity is toxic. Now, you are getting the picture, their product resembles or rather, modeled after penis, and this is a big no-no as they consciously or unconsciously promoting masculinity. The gender bias is that they are not allowing penis shaped things to be displayed at CES but allowing vagina shaped things and this is clearly a sexism for men, not the other way around.
- t4sk1n 8y ago"We also believe that society needs to drop the taboo around sex and sexuality - it’s a part of life and health that absolutely should be part of mainstream discourse." It's 2019 and an overwhelming number of social discourse is solely about sex and sexuality. A lot of people literally care about sex health more than any other health and it is, by many, believed to have negative effect on many people's mental health as well.
- icebraining 8y agoThat doesn't justify a double standard.
- t4sk1n 8y agoBut making such opening statements questions their integrity
- icebraining 8y agoTheir integrity is irrelevant when you have the facts and can judge the behavior of CES for yourself.
- t4sk1n 8y agoBut while examining this article, it should make people question everything that's implied
- icebraining 8y agoI don't see anything implied; it's all quite explicitly stated.
- tql 8y agoIt's 2019, saying your sex toy is for women and LGTBITQZ+ is antiquated and simply reeks of bigotry. It's no wonder they took your award back. If you want to be a revolutionary, say your sex toy is for children.
- stevespang 8y agoI could not have said this better: "Spending half the page blabbering about empowerment of women and LBQTI+ only detracts from their argument. Their baseless claim of mysoginy and homophobia distracts from their reasons for why they should be included in the first place and should not have been included in this response. It makes the author of the piece look very unprofessional and desperate for help from some of those action groups that take to the streets the moment they see the word "discrimination". "