5 ms·
Seems like the actual issue is that the specs are way too tight. If 80% of the cables fail the test but virtually all of them work fine in the real world, what
by CamperBob2 8y ago
Seems like the actual issue is that the specs are way too tight. If 80% of the cables fail the test but virtually all of them work fine in the real world, what does that say about the test?
How common is it for someone to buy one of the retail-grade cables they're discussing in this article, and find that it doesn't work reliably?
- phinnaeus 8y agoMore specifically, for a digital signal, what does "working, but not up to spec" look like? Occasional packet loss? Corrupted data that is masked by ECC?
- sigstoat 8y ago"working, but not up to spec" can mean "works today, stops working tomorrow when subjected to a bit more nearby electrical noise". 10GbaseT links frequently can't negotiate down, so your link can just stop working whenever.
- russdill 8y agoAnything "masked" by ECC is part of the design.
- sannee 8y agoCan also mean: Works with devices A and B, stops working with devices A and C.
- secabeen 8y agoIt also is a testament to the ability of the interface vendors to get solid connections of out-of-spec cables. I have a small server room that is only wired with a 200+ foot run of in-wall Cat5e cables that the building was originally wired with. Running fiber to the room would be a multi-thousand-dollar job. On a lark, I took two switches with 10G-BASET interfaces and successfully brought up a 10Gigabit link across that Cat5e. I brought that link into production 6 months ago, and through that time have had less than 100 errors per link. Just incredible.
- Scoundreller 8y agoThank you for testing out just how over-spec’d our world is. I recall making a very crude crossover cable by cutting and soldering wires together and still got 100mbit (as high as I could test, this was early 2000s I think).
- pkaye 8y agoThere is an old show floor demo I've heard about where a bunch of barb wire is used to transmit Ethernet data. The crucial part was spacing the wires apart to get the right impedance. Don't recall what speed them were transmitting though.
- CamperBob2 8y agoThat goes back to the original demonstration of 10BaseT (10 Mbit). It blew everybody away, definitely one of the great Valley demos of all time. I want to say this was Bob Metcalfe, but not 100% sure he was involved.
- derefr 8y agoYou and the GP poster might both live in a nice little RF-shielded part of "our world", mind you. A Cat 6 cable, like a "ruggedized" laptop or a mars rover, will work near sources of EM interference that would knock your regular cable (or computer, or robot) over dead. That's most of why they cost more. Though, mind you, right tool for the job—I'm surprised that everybody is talking about "getting perfect cables" for maximum interference-tolerance in business-critical applications, when what I'd expect the professionals here to be thinking in terms of is taking measurements of the local RF environment they're going to do cable runs in, and then using the cheapest thing that's within tolerance.
- justtopost 8y agoJust because its meat, doesn't mean you can sell me horse flank as usda filet. The differince is critical is some applications, even if overspec'd in others. Thats the point of having a standard. If you only need cat5e quality, you can just buy that, at signifigant discount.
- yellowapple 8y agoFor what it's worth, I just bought a few one-off Ethernet cables at Fry's, and while I didn't look all that hard, I didn't see any that weren't marketed as Cat6.
- JJMcJ 8y agoSimilar to buying organic food, or ocean caught fish vs. farm raised. Change the label, double the price. The temptation is very strong. Similar amusement from the Capacitor Plague: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacitor_plague https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacitor_plague
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoIf they "worked fine" they would be meeting the spec they said they would.
- CamperBob2 8y agoI don't know about you, but I plug my cables into hubs and NICs, not TDRs and oscilloscopes. Absolutely nothing in the real world needs twisted-pair cables to exhibit 54 dB of NEXT. If it does, that's an engineering failure in itself, IMO.
- derefr 8y agoThe LAN on the International Space Station, maybe?
- wmf 8y agoMost real cable runs have large margin because they're shorter than 100m.
- toast0 8y agoThe category specs are the 'requirements' for rock solid Ethernet at a certain distance in a bundle with mixed low voltage, not _too_ close to AC distribution, in reasonable RF conditions. Cat 6a goes to the full 100 meters (330 feet) at 10Gbps, Cat 6 goes to 55 meters (180 feet). Most people buying retail cables aren't going to be using that for that distance, and are more likely to run at 1Gbps than 10Gbps; where cat5 (not e) meets the spec at full distance. I'm a bit surprised that the cables didn't all meet cat5 (e) spec, but even that is not really required to have a solid ethernet connection at 1Gbps if you're not in a tricky environment -- I ran a 1Gbps drop over mostly cat 5e with a ~ 20 foot section of cat 3 for many years with no apparent issues (repurposed a buried 4-pair pots drop to a separate structure for ethernet). Most likely any reliability issue with this cables is going to be if the connectors were poorly crimped and the connections loosen over time. That said, ethernet negotiation is a slower protocol, that's easy to decode, so it's very possible for both link partners to negotiate to something the wiring can't sustain. I've seen some drivers end up negotiating down to a lower speed in this case, but it's not part of any formal ethernet spec AFAIK.
- koolba 8y ago> I ran a 1Gbps drop over mostly cat 5e with a ~ 20 foot section of cat 3 for many years with no apparent issues (repurposed a buried 4-pair pots drop to a separate structure for ethernet). Oh man that takes me back. I did the same thing though it was for 100Mpbs at the time. I distinctly remember staring at the twisted pairs prior to starting and wondering, “Is the actually going to work?”
- toast0 8y agoYeah, I wired it up, because I knew at least I could run it at 10baseT if I had to, and then I might as well try it at the fastest I could, and it worked ok at 1G, so that's what I used. :)
- xenadu02 8y agoIs your claim that manufacturers should be allowed to sell products with complete fabrications on the label because most of the time it is "good enough"? If manufacturers want to sell Cat 5E (or lower grade) cables they are free to do so, but the market won't accept the higher price they want to fetch for those cables. It also means the manufacturers are either incompetent (doing no testing) or are knowingly testing the cables but not bothering to test them to the specification they are claiming on the package. Either way that's a crime.
- CamperBob2 8y agoIs your claim that manufacturers should be allowed to sell products with complete fabrications on the label because most of the time it is "good enough"? That certainly requires a creative reading of what I wrote. No, I'm saying that the test specs may be rigged to favor high-end cable manufacturers, and we may all be paying too much for cables as a result.
- xenadu02 8y agoThe cable tester they are using is setup to test the actual specification. That is to say they are testing the _very definition_ of Cat-5E, Cat-6, or Cat-6A. That's the thing about cabling standards: either you meet the requirements of the standard or you don't. I presume the committee that designed 100Base-T, 1000Base-T, and 10GBase-T didn't pick numbers out of nowhere for no reason. Your comment seemed to be using circular reasoning... if the standard is too stringent than it's just a free-for-all, or the manufacturer's made-up non-standard, but there is only one way to be Cat-6A: follow the specs laid out in the standard. Otherwise why even have standards?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]