8 ms·
Not sure I could call this "well made" which is a disappointment for me with regards to Anker. The HV and LV sides don't appear to be well, or even at all isol
by gumby 8y ago
Not sure I could call this "well made" which is a disappointment for me with regards to Anker. The HV and LV sides don't appear to be well, or even at all isolated.
I suppose the big yellow-wrapped thing is the voltage transformation stage, but the connector should feed directly into it. Looks like it is actually be a transformer rather than a switching supply, which I suppose could cut costs.
- lykr0n 8y agohttp://cdn2.geekifix.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/21-1024x683.jpeg http://cdn2.geekifix.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/21-1024x... It looks like power comes in right above the FT15SM. I'm seeing great separation between the left and right side. Sure, there isn't' an air-gap, but it looks like good enough. It's compact and potted which makes it hard for either of us to get a really good idea.
- devy 8y agoKeep in mind that what Ben torn down in the article was actually a Chinese version of the charger - the north american version could be different (though I am unsure.)
- zaarn 8y agoIt does seem like the HV and LV are seperated into the daughterboards, which would give them some seperation. The actual seperation you need isn't that big and if you're careful you don't need to divide the PCB into two strict sections (just look at most Multimeter PCBs). I also suspect that like 99% of power supplies, this is a transformer with a switching voltage regulator behind it since PD 2.0 requires a range of voltages to be available.
- theamk 8y agoeh? this is not a 50Hz /60Hz transformer, for two reasons: (1) Low-frequency transformers rated for 18 watts are way bigger than this (2) There is a nice big picture of INN3265C ("Flyback Switcher IC") So there is no way one could connect the connector directly to the transformer.
- Dylan16807 8y agohttp://cdn2.geekifix.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/21.jpeg http://cdn2.geekifix.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/21.jpeg If this is the isolation left to right, it seems like plenty bordering on overkill. You can't just feed wall power into the transformer in a switched power supply; the power needs to be rectified and then fed to it at tens to hundreds of kilohertz. The chip bridging the gap is designed for this task, with builtin isolation.
- amluto 8y agoThere are no UL or similar markings on the case, and the fuse isn’t marked as a UL recognized component. I bet the US version will be somewhat different.
- chargerlab 8y agoHi, this is Ben from ChargerLAB. I am the author of this terrible article. I promise I will do better next time. Yes. This is Chinese version. It's "Triple C" certified instead of UL certified. The components might be different across different versions but we are not certain. The next time we will try to have a comparison between the same products aimed for differnet regions. You can checkout the teardown of an US version 60W Anker USB-C charger from this link. http://www.chargerlab.com/archives/539.html http://www.chargerlab.com/archives/539.html
- tomn 8y agoIt looks like there's plenty of seperation to me. Three things cross the boundary: The main controller has an isolated primary/secondary side, so it's fine for it to bridge. According to the datasheet it's got >4kV of isolation. The big yellow thing is a transformer, but it's switched at high frequency; this is quite common in this kind of thing. Note that the secondary wires coming out of the top are properly insulated, so this should be quite well isolated. The class-Y capacitor is designed for exactly this purpose.
- Faaak 8y ago> I suppose the big yellow-wrapped thing is the voltage transformation stage, but the connector should feed directly into it. Looks like it is actually be a transformer rather than a switching supply, which I suppose could cut costs. Switching power supplies can use transformers too while remaining efficient.
- londons_explore 8y agoIt's been at least 15 years since a transformer was cheaper than a rectifier and flyback transformer design. Steel costs more than silicon...
- inferiorhuman 8y ago> Not sure I could call this "well made" which is a disappointment for me with regards to Anker. Does Anker have a good reputation? I bought an Anker cigarette lighter - USB charger a couple years ago. One of the reviewers pointed out it fit poorly, took it apart, and made suggestions to Anker on how to improve the product (and got feedback from Anker). I figured it was safe to assume the improvements made it into the product. Turns out that a year later no improvement had been made and the damn thing would disconnect every time I hit a bump or looked at it funny. From my POV Anker is 7-11 quality stuff. Edit: I'm loving the downvotes from the brand loyalists who've nothing to contribute.
- kazen44 8y agomaybe you got "old" stock? it's not uncommon for products like this to sit in a warehouse for over a year. Anker has been fine in terms of quality in my opinion, never had an issue with any of their products. Although i must say there are better on the market. especially in terms of powerbanks.
- inferiorhuman 8y ago> maybe you got "old" stock? it's not uncommon for products like this to sit in a warehouse for over a year. Potentially, but I'd hope that Anker would exercise a bit more control over their Amazon inventory. From the looks of it there are still plenty of (premature failure, fire) complaints in addition to the no return policy. It screams fly by night to me, but it's interesting to see they've a better reputation with other products. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00VH84L5E https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00VH84L5E Here's the review (about eighteen months before I bought mine): https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R4F5INKA6PO2I/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R4F5INKA6PO2I/
- kazen44 8y agowhat about a no return policy? I was able to return anker products just fine. (i might add im not in the US though)
- gumby 8y agoThanks to the commenters who mostly allayed my concerns.