5 ms·
Huawei is also a Gold member of the RISC-V Foundation: https://riscv.org/membership/1745/huawei/ https://riscv.org/membership/1745/huawei/ As another potentia
by phkahler 8y ago
Huawei is also a Gold member of the RISC-V Foundation:
https://riscv.org/membership/1745/huawei/ https://riscv.org/membership/1745/huawei/
As another potential threat to ARM, here is an ARM licensee that designs their own chips and is interested in RISC-V. It's not a problem today, but if interest in the ISA continues to grow it should be relatively easy for them to switch.
- stefan_ 8y agoSwitch??? There seems to be some widespread confusion what RISC-V is, currently. It is not remotely competitive with any ARM processors, and for those used in smartphones, there is no indication it will be for at least another 10 years. It is solely used in applications where the choice of processor is mostly meaningless and cutting out ARM is 20 cents saved on the BoM. Remember Huawei makes a long long list of products besides smartphones such as networking gear where you need the occasional small to medium sized processor.
- monocasa 8y ago> It is not remotely competitive with any ARM processors It is absolutely competitive with cores at the same gate count. That goes beyond stuff like RPi level cores. > and for those used in smartphones, there is no indication it will be for at least another 10 years. I mean, shitting out a new high perf uarch isn't the easiest thing in the world, but you're literally commenting on an article from Huawei claiming that they had. And now Moore's law is more or less mined out, which means it's no longer a Sisyphean task to chase the perf dragon.
- audunw 8y ago> It is absolutely competitive with cores at the same gate count. That goes beyond stuff like RPi level cores. He may also have been thinking about things like toolchains and debugging tools. There are several professional IDEs geared towards ARM embedded development
- nickik 8y agoThere are tool makers and IDE makers that support RISC-V already. Look at the list of companies, it includes quite a few companies like that. Of coure ARM is way ahead but RISC-V is catching up and people are trying to innovate.
- monocasa 8y ago> There are several professional IDEs geared towards ARM embedded development Having been an embedded developer for around a decade, yeah they exist but are absolutely terrible. I seriously don't understand how Keil, Metrowerks, and IAR still make sales. Like, they're somehow worse than the FPGA toolchains I had to deal with. If RISC-V doesn't get those parasitic business models attached to it, it'll be better off.
- nightfly 8y agoWhat IDEs/toolchains do you tend to actually use/see used in industry?
- monocasa 8y agoI've used all of the above and shipped code with them; when coming into a project it's more important to get things done than bitch about the gains other tools get you. When starting a design from scratch, my own proclivity generally goes towards gcc/clang +some commandline build (make, cmake,.etc), openocd+gdb, and an eclipse project built up that's ready to go for those who like GUI editors. That free stack tends to have less bugs than the above tooling and way more examples for when you want to do something weird.
- Recurecur 8y agoOne very interesting development is MIPS open-sourcing all(?) of its IP. From what I understand, MIPS cores are already quite competitive with ARM, with good support for FP etc., and the MIPS ecosystem is quite good.
- 8y ago
- nickik 8y agoMaybe you should actually inform yourself before posting a definite statment like this. That no RISC-V processor is competitve with any ARM processor is just straight up nonsense. RISC-V ISA wins in most metrics against ARM amd chips that implement it get higher performance on the same gate count. Your next claim that 'its all about that 20c licencing cost' is further nonsense that simple is not reflected by most companies in the RISC-V space. It probebly true for some, but WD for example has said that just based on cost they would not switch. Next lets talk about high end cores. Esperanto technologies is gone licence a 7nm RISC-V Core that competes directly with A-72 and A-76. That not as advanced as some of the cores you can licence but its very competitive in terms of soft-ip. That all said, mobile application processors will be a few years away but the primary issue is not the core performance itself.
- chocolatebunny 8y agoI've heard hardware guys complain about saving pennies. When you're manufacturing millions of units then saving 20 cents on each of them absolutely does matter. Obviously saving 20 cents now doesn't offset all the other issues with RISC-V but saying it's meaningless to cut out 20 cents is not correct.
- est31 8y agoI don't think that's what stefan_ wanted to say. I think it's rather that RISC-V isn't effective enough (yet) to be suitable for scenarios where the main thing you optimize for is something other than cost (like heat dissipation, power use, performance, etc). For scenarios where these things don't matter, but cost is very important, RISC-V is the ideal choice.
- nickik 8y agoThe problem is that most of these companies will still use commrecial soft cores. Meaning that you still pay for the RISC-V chip most of the time. So it will probably be cheaper, but your not saving 100% most of the time. There are some companies where is is a huge issue. However for others its all about avoiding up front cost. For others its about flexibility. For others its about narrow innovation.
- wyldfire 8y agoI'll bet that in <= 6 years we will see popular mobile computing devices with RISC-V applications processors. But you're right that those will probably be the last to switch. Most SoCs have plenty of ARM cores that could be swapped with RISC-V cores without significant (or even any) impact to vendors.
- benj111 8y agoWhat do arm licencees actually get? Technologically speaking, slapping a risc-v decoder on an arm core is trivial no? So how much of this is Huawei ip, how much arm? Is it not possible that arm will become the leading risc v vendor?
- StillBored 8y agoDid you see the list of partners in the announcement? Its one thing to say that linux runs on your core, its another to have a supported release by every major distro along with other OS's people want to run working (windows/etc). It might be said that is the harder piece of work because its not just engineering but politics and business cases. So beyond that there is an incredible amount of engineering work required to get lots of application stacks to perform well on an architecture. Its one thing if a core is similar performance/watt given some small benchmark suite. Its another to get specJBB or other random large application suite running well. There are literally tens of thousands of pieces of code here or there that need to be ferreted out and fixed, from adding crytp/vector instruction support, to lock tuning. There is also the experience of finding edge cases in the system architecture that don't perform well in a given situation and need to be modified in a future design. That is something you get with a mature architecture and something the arm ecosystem has spent the last 7+ years working on with organizations like linaro and in major projects like the linux kernel, gcc, clang, openjdk, android, etc. Missing a 20% performance optimization somewhere in a 100 million line code stack can be the difference between performing like a 7 year old core from your competitors or being seen as equal. Now all that said, risc-v has plenty of opportunity, investment, etc. Nothing I've said above is unique to arm/x86/power/etc its just a matter of putting the effort in. That work hasn't yet been done for risc-v, so its a natural fit for small limited microcontroller/embedded applications where the software stack is more controllable, rather than general purpose high performance applications (phones, servers, etc).
- wk_end 8y agoA good sign that the RISC-V hype is out of control here is that the top comment on a news story about something good for ARM claims that it is actually bad for ARM and good for RISC-V.
- justicezyx 8y agoNo, I see this comment as very relevant. If you think about what happened recently, and Huawei's position as the beacon of China's hihg-tech industry; the fact that they are in Arm and Risc-V suggests the scope of their investment. That is important to indicate the direction they want to go. If you also correlate that with their investment in K8s, you'll see a clear picture how a complete strategy is being laid out. And Huawei understands Open Source is going to be the future for catching up. Now piecing everything together: - If done right, an investment in Arm for short-/middle-term, and long term bet on Risc-V + cluster manager like K8s, will provide a meaningful long-term alternative for cluster computing. - Then again, Huawei has similar investment in the edge computing space for various kind of low-power phone chips.
- dmix 8y agoSo basically their investment in ARM has cross-over advantage to RISC-V (and likewise?)?
- justicezyx 8y agoWhat do you mean by crossover?
- ahartmetz 8y agoPresumably that CPU design expertise is transferable between architectures, especially if they are similar.
- justicezyx 8y agoI only know very little on the surface of chip design in general. My impression is yes, expertise are transferrable. Although the key here is cultivating market and hone the operational prowse, those also require time to do.