18 ms·
Fusion Power Is About to Become a Reality?
- StavrosK 8y agoWhat do you mean "finally"? It's been about to become a reality for decades!
- csours 8y agoIt's been 20 years away for the past 60 years. Now it's only 10 years away.
- goatlover 8y agoSame with AGI and now apparently, Martian colonies, according to Elon.
- izzydata 8y agoSo we are only 30 years from it being 5 years away?
- FlyMoreRockets 8y agoCommercial fusion will coincide with the Singularity.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAs expected. It's often forgotten that acceleration of technology caused by runaway recursively-improving AI would require rapidly increasing availability of energy - after all, something has to power all this tech. Who knows, maybe lack of fusion power is the one thing that'll delay the singularity? :).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jungler 8y agoThis used to be the joke with solar power too. After decades of being 10 years away it became "5 years away but we're subsidizing it now" and just like that, it started scaling out to viability.
- londons_explore 8y agoMore like It's been 60 years away for the past 60 years. Now it's only 50 years away.
- jug 8y agoThe time remaining is an asymptotic curve never quite reaching 0, right...
- justtopost 8y agoSee Xeno's paradox, valve time, etc.
- api 8y agoThis is lazy nonsense. Fusion is underfunded and yet we've still made fantastic progress on power density and stability.
- xte 8y agoFew things: no government really want unlimited energy for all for a simple reason: power&control. If any country in the planet can be autonomous if it can produce enough food for their citizens there is only war as a means to control it's development and that's unacceptable for nearly all ruling classes. Second things: we have already achieved nuclear fusion in France and UK and perhaps other researches I do not know but from there to arrive to a positive sustainable heat production and in turn to arrive at industrial scale the road is super long only technically leaving apart any political and business consideration. Third and last thing: actual fission based nuclear power is useful to produce plutonium so usable and powerful nuke, and anyone like the idea of having many of them in it's arsenal. With fusion we only produce heat. Usable for many things, mostly to produce steam and so electricity and even to heat cities in the winter. But with little use for military purpose. Long story short: I think even if someone know and can produce a working fusion-powered electrical plant no government will let seriously develop it, at least for next few decades...
- AboutTheWhisles 8y agoWouldn't that imply that less powerful governments would want unlimited energy to become less dependent on richer and more powerful governments?
- xte 8y agoThey simply can't... Less powerful in that sense means less developed. Such kind of research demand enormous resources and knowledge. These days industrial knowledge is mostly in private hands with universities that are not anymore a "center of (public) knowledge" bu mere gym to form Ford-models workers with a different skillset respect of classic one but not much different in terms of ability to understand the big picture, being autonomous etc. In present society there is no room for new "Einstein", "Tesla" etc.
- AboutTheWhisles 8y agoYour post that I replied to said that no governments wanted free energy, now you are shifting the goal post to some sort of further made up hypothetical world where big governments have free energy and small governments don't.
- cjslep 8y agoSeems like partially a Dennis Whyte puff piece. The problem all tokomaks have is that ELMs exist and will remove the inner lining of the containment unit over time, and current cutting edge research is on how a plasma will react with specific impurities and their distribution within said plasma. A major problem is lack of true experimental evidence, as most fusion experiments are crude approximations of reality and then subsequent closed source, poorly documented, or guess-the-fellow-researchers code is at play. Source: talked a lot this past holiday from a friend at ITER.
- xorfish 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edge-localized_mode https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edge-localized_mode For anyone wondering what ELMs are.
- lambdadmitry 8y agoAnother problem, apparently, is plasma disruptions [1]. They are more dramatic, can irreparably damage the vessel, and hard to solve or mitigate. ITER has a taskforce dedicated to them [2], but it remains to be seen if that approach will work (and the energy will still be dumped into the first wall and support structure, albeit less local than with relativistic electrons). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokamak#Plasma_disruptions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokamak#Plasma_disruptions [2]: https://www.iter.org/newsline/-/3183 https://www.iter.org/newsline/-/3183
- sandworm101 8y agoAnother approach to this is to not use solid walls. General Fusion (BC, Canada) is playing with the idea of a spherical plasma within a void of spinning liquid lead. The lack of solid walls makes for some very interesting options in terms of damage mitigation.
- lambdadmitry 8y agoThey already abandoned that idea AFAIK. Liquid lead wall introduced too much contamination into the plasma, making fusion impossible.
- blacksqr 8y agoNo.
- rossdavidh 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- zunzun 8y agoValuable, valuable helium-3 can be mined on the moon and used for fuel after we put a lightweight, working fusion reactor there with enough personnel and spare parts to run it (puff,puff,inhale).
- Symmetry 8y agoHelium-3 is a whole 'nother kettle of fish. Deuterium/Tritium is a lot easier to fuse and is what pretty much everybody working on the problem is looking at. If, later, we were able to get get helium-3/deuterium fusion working that would be great because then there wouldn't be any neutrons created reducing the already modest fusion nuclear waste problem to zero. But that's still a ways off.
- the8472 8y agoWell, the gamma rays produced by fusion can still photo-desintegrate various elements which in turn leads to secondary neutron radiation and unstable isotopes. I don't know what the cross sections of those interactions are but it's not quite zero.
- gweinberg 8y agoAs I understand it, if you have conditions that allow deuterium-helium3 fusion you will always get some deuterium-deuterium fusion. So the number of neutrons produced is way less than D-T or pure D-D fusion, but it is still a significant problem.
- apendleton 8y agoAgreed about He3, but it's not just D/T; there's at least a bit of money going onto p/B11, as a way of sidestepping the problems of neutron embrittlement. I think TAE is working on it?
- pier25 8y agoAnd some clones to oversee the operation
- 8y ago
- xefer 8y agoI believe this (long!) video of a Dennis Whyte talk from 2016 was posted to HN way back when: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 It sounded pretty encouraging, but I have no idea what progress has been made or if these ideas had run into any roadblocks in two years since this was first discussed.
- ryanmercer 8y agoEh, it is my opinion that we are a long way from even having a net-positive prototype reactor (if ever). Even if we get one operational, I suspect the construction cost alone would be an order of magnitude more than a traditional nuclear reactor. Then, how much of a net output will you actually be capable of generating, probably a fraction of the energy it consumes which is something but by the time you factor in construction costs as well as maintenance/upkeep costs you're probably going to have a fantastically expensive power source. Then consider that if we had a viable fusion reactor TODAY, and only needed 10,000 of them to replace the 62,000 something power plants in the world it would likely take many decades to build them all. Then of course, energy consumption increases over time. Between 1990 and 2008 world energy consumption increased 39%. Since 2008 we've added considerably more electronics to our lives just in 'the first world' nations so I suspect that increase has been even greater in the past decade. Factor in electric vehicles being added and... So even if we do get fusion working in the near future, it's not going to be anywhere near a miracle.
- kolinko 8y agoThe consumption probably grew due to Asia and Africa using more electricity, but in the western world? In 2008 I had a stationary computer taking 350W-400W, a bunch of 100W lightbulbs in my house, a TV, and an old fridge. Now I have 60W laptop that took over my TV as well, and most of the lightbulbs are the power efficient ones taking 10-20W, 100W ones are not even being sold in Europe (a few exceptions aside). (Just checked - in Europe, electricity consumption was on the rise to around 2008, and then remained static and even fell a bit)
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI think we can expect electricity consumption to go back up quite soon. Contributing factors are electrification of transportation, transition to electric heating, ever growing software bloat, increasingly compute-intensive ideas like deep learning and blockchains requiring more and more powerful data centres... and let's not forget that software hasn't eaten the world yet. Some of it will be a demand shift from fossil fuels, which is a good thing, but it still means we need more electricity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- modzu 8y agothe headline is clickbaity but the gist of the article is different: even if its a long way off or even if it might not work, its very important to try
- sp332 8y agoThe new trouble with fusion and even near-future fission projects is that solar and wind costs have plummeted. It's a lot harder to get investment in anything else when solar is now $.03/kWh.
- Libbum 8y agoYou are mistaken. Grid level battery storage cannot provide baseline power for days, and until that's a reality we will need a baseline power source that can supply when there is no sun, wind (or hydro, wave etc where available). Fusion & fission plants are the sustainable alternatives for this sector.
- Maximus9000 8y ago> baseline power FYI, it's "baseload power" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load
- Libbum 8y agoIndeed, sorry - fast typing.
- toomuchtodo 8y agohttps://pv-magazine-usa.com/2019/01/01/solar-tsunami/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2019/01/01/solar-tsunami/ > Developers have applied to build 139 GWac of large-scale solar projects in the territory of six grid operators – around five times what is currently online across the country – and that figure doesn’t even cover the entire United States. By any metric, we are looking at an unprecedented boom in solar development over the next five years. > The six grid operator queues we investigated also showed more than 16 GW of battery projects which have filed for interconnection. And this number should not be too surprising to anyone who is watching the meteoric growth of energy storage. > Per the US Energy Storage Monitor, from Wood Mackenzie Renewables & Power along with the Energy Storage Association (ESA), total energy storage deployed expanded by 60% in terms of energy and 300% on a power basis in the third quarter of 2018 versus the prior year. Going out mostly until 2023, the report noted that the front of the meter pipeline expanded to approximately 33 GW of power. Natural gas picks up the slack until batteries (which everyone underestimates; we're going to have an enormous amount of energy storage cumulatively to go 100% low carbon) get a bit cheaper; wind, solar, hydro, and long distance transmission lines combined with utility scale storage is more than adequate to replace traditional base load (and all are possible today, not decades later if we started building fission/fusion commercial generators today).
- stevespang 8y agoWho paid you to write this comedy, Bergstein ? The fusion industry has been paying to get stories like this published for decades, and they STILL don't have a working model . . . . it's a fantasy.
- lambdadmitry 8y agoThe title picture is misleading. It's not a "fusion reactor", it's a training facility at Culham, never having an actual reaction going (it's actually a few spare sectors of the reactor vessel assembled together to form 3/4th of its circumference). Those reflections all over the right part of the picture? That's plexiglass window between the vessel and an access platform.
- pier25 8y agoIf fusion works (and that's a really big if) it could be the miracle humanity needs.
- swarnie_ 8y agoUntil someone works out how to weaponize it which always seems to be the way....
- garmaine 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermonuclear_weapon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermonuclear_weapon
- shadowxs76 8y agoIt has already been weaponized. Hydrogen/thermonuclear fusion bombs are a thing and have been since the 50s.
- iaw 8y agoWhile other replies have addressed your misunderstanding about the existence of fusion based weapons it is also worth highlighting that the radioactive waste by-products from fusion power generation are far more manageable than by-products from existing fission power generation methods.
- pier25 8y agoWe already have the capability to wipe out humanity with nuclear weapons. Nothing would really change in this respect.
- cestith 8y agoWeaponized fusion has been around for decades. Getting a confined, long-term reaction from which to draw usable power is the difficult part remaining.
- iaw 8y agoFusion already 'works.' The sun is a giant ball of fusion and fission. On earth we have already achieved net energy positive fusion at the JET experiment reactor. Tokamak's have been in testing for decades with live fusion. Home experiments like the Farnsworth Fusor have been built by teenagers. The question around fusion power is not an 'if', it is a 'how much'. How much more time and money will it take to develop appropriate materials and processes to make fusion an economically viable power generation process?
- barrow-rider 8y agoBetteridge's law of headlines: "Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline... That said, the actual article doesn't have a question. But they've been saying "Fusion is Just Around the Corner" since I was a kid so a solid "No" is probably applicable.
- DennisP 8y agoIn the 1950s they said fusion was around the corner, because they were just getting started and didn't understand the problems yet. In the 1970s they said it was 30 years away, but conditioned that on a much higher level of funding than they actually got. For the level of funding they got, they said it would never happen. Now we have a very good understanding of tokamak plasmas, and some new enabling technologies including much better superconductors.
- pfdietz 8y agoAnd in the 1980s, it was pointed out that fundamental limitations on power density will likely keep any DT fusion reactor from being competitive.
- pontifier 8y agoHere I come again to lament the lack of interest in the reactor I've designed. I've become very pessimistic about even trying to work on it. Think about that for a minute... imagine that my design works, but our society is so jaded by con artists and corrupted by insiders theiving and politics that it never gets a chance. I feel like I'm starting to identify with bond style supervillains. I could fund the research alone, and keep the fruits of my labor to myself. I'm sure I could also weaponize it.
- stallmanite 8y agoGot a link for the curious?
- pontifier 8y agoWww.ddprofusion.com
- AboutTheWhisles 8y agoIt's not what you know, it's what you can prove.
- pontifier 8y agoThat's exactly the problem in our society right now. How am I supposed to prove this without building a prototype? I don't have the resources to personally build one right now, and nobody else seems to care. Our entire society stands to benefit from this, yet I'm expected to complete this work alone? I used to be altruistic and optimistic, now, not so much. I'm inclined to let the world rot while I take my sweet time. It's not like I have much choice in the matter anyway.
- dicroce 8y agoTie into the grid and get paid from your utility.
- nategri 8y agoNo??
- X6S1x6Okd1st 8y agoIt sounds like we really don't know what the maintenance/running costs will be. Is there a good reason to think that this will certainly beat the cost of fission?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 8y agoThere's excellent reason to think it won't.
- EamonnMR 8y agoRelying on fusion power solving our problems is a foolish. We need to solve our energy problems with the technology we have now, and if we end up with cheap clean electricity on top of it, well, we'll already have the infrastructure to take advantage of it.
- logfromblammo 8y agoI'm at about the point where I will finally believe fusion power is a reality when the utilities board has just approved a $0.005/kWh rate increase to handle some unexpected cost overruns, experienced during the decommissioning of a 50-year-old fusion plant.
- theothermkn 8y agoMy problem with this article is the focus on the "startup" mythology of moving fast and breaking things. Break a Coulomb barrier, first, and then come talk to us. I really liked https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk for a discussion of how to evaluate and understand fusion claims, as well as a discussion of the high-field REBCO tapes that seem poised to enable the ARC/SPARC reactors out of MIT. Another video I like is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMxOvuSMAug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMxOvuSMAug , featuring Steven Cowley. In short, newly commercially available high temperature superconductors in mass quantities seem poised to give us at least a doubling of available magnetic field strength, and all the figure of merit that improve only linearly with size improve to the 2nd, 3rd, or 4th power with magnetic field strength. This is what could lead to break-even before ITER, not the mythology of American entrepreneurial moxie. In my opinion, the article author knows whom he's flattering.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoOur whole civilization might just depend on if we can get viable fusion working in the near future. With global warming, I do not have any hope of a political solution in the timeframe required. We can only hope for a technical solution, and that solution will be very, very energy intensive (carbon sequestration from the atmosphere, massive desalination to provide fresh water for humans and agriculture, etc). Fusion is the only candidate that can provide that level of energy at the density and scale in a location independent manner.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoFWIW, I consider fusion power to be one of two possible black swan events that will change the the future from what we consider 'gloom and doom' into something much more fun to live in. The other, if you're wondering, is fully decoded cell biology[1]. So if we have enough energy to operate at a high standard of living without any imported raw material, it enables countries to switch from energy negative economies to energy positive economies. For example African countries that smelt the iron and aluminum that is being mined and exporting finished goods rather than raw materials can capture more of the economic value of those resources and keep it local. Building transport systems based on indigenous electricity generation, removing dependency on pipelines and other fossil fuel taxes. At a low enough cost, excess energy allows for the production of fresh water from seawater, nitrogen from the atmosphere (for fertilizer and farming), and long chain hydrocarbons (gas, oil, plastics, etc) using the Fischer-Tropsch cycle. [1] Basically we know a lot about how cells work and I expect at some point we will know exactly how they work, allowing us a genetically remove errors that result in disease, regenerate and replace any component of the body, and fix any side effects from material exposure (like cancer).
- epistasis 8y agoI don't understand your enthusiasm here, what are the potential wins of fusion energy over any other energy source that we currently have? Do you expect it to be super cheap, i.e. more than an order of magnitude cheaper than solar? If so, how do you justify that belief? I ask this of everyone that's enthusiastic about fusion, but I've never heard a reason why fusion is such a desirable energy source.
- fromthestart 8y agoFusion is safe, clean, produces no waste, runs 24/7 on demand, and after startup costs should be cheap, assuming repairs and maintenance aren't enormously costly. Not to mention, more space efficient than wind or solar. You don't need a particular environemt for it like hydro. No more minig/drilling for energy. No more emissions. No toxic waste. No hourly power variability. No need for batteries. Fusion is the perfect energy source on paper, if it ever becomes a reality.
- shaki-dora 8y agoIt seems like there's a segment of the tech crowd forever living in some 1950s sci-fi fantasy. There must be something about big hairy difficult-to-control technology that has an emotional appeal to a certain segment. Meanwhile, in the real world, wind and especially solar power, as well as battery technology, are close to being cost-competitive with even the cheapest power sources (i. e. coal and gas). I know it still stings how the general public just insisted on their black swans or whatever, and didn't quite like the idea of radiation as much as you do. But the safety argument has long become irrelevant. Nuclear power has lost on economic terms now, and it has absolutely no chance of catching up with renewables in the one or two decades until those become so cheap as to render that fight irrelevant, too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 8y agoThere's something Dieselpunk about fusion reactors. One could make the case it's a replay of vacuum tubes (read fusion) vs. transistors (read photovoltaic cells). The former are hot and bulky and relatively dangerous; the latter are made churned out by the billions at ever decreasing costs.
- gonational 8y agoSome other articles about vapor power: 2016 - https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=11585194 https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&obj... 2014 - http://techgenmag.com/2014/10/why-nuclear-fusion-will-soon-become-reality/ http://techgenmag.com/2014/10/why-nuclear-fusion-will-soon-b... 2012 - https://www.rt.com/usa/plasma-fusion-energy-nuclear-080/ https://www.rt.com/usa/plasma-fusion-energy-nuclear-080/ 2010 - https://www.universetoday.com/52696/nuclear-fusion-power-closer-to-reality-say-two-separate-teams/ https://www.universetoday.com/52696/nuclear-fusion-power-clo... 2008 - https://cleantechnica.com/2008/11/13/will-nuclear-fusion-solve-the-energy-crisis/ https://cleantechnica.com/2008/11/13/will-nuclear-fusion-sol...
- nickik 8y agoI have never understood why people are so hot for fusion. Fusion gives you 10^15 energy density, fission gives you 10^12 already. So the difference between fusion and fission is really not relevant compared to what we have now. Fusion has many of the same potential practical problem as fission and many even worse. Yet fission is here, its the highest low-carbon energy source, it has proven to be able to replace fossil on a MASSIVE scale, see France, US, South Korea, Japan, Switzerland, Sweden and so on. Fusion is the dream in the future that makes it easy for people to dismiss fission. And that is keeping us back. I'm not saying studying fusion is not useful, but a we should put 10x more resources in fission research. The world just does not make sense to me.
- mcguire 8y agoPaul Erdös said mathematicians were god's way of converting coffee into theorems. I claim programmers are god's way of converting coffee into profanity. Fusion research is god's way of converting money into promises. This same article could have been written in the 1980s. "Fusion definitely works. You see it every day. Our sun and other stars blast hydrogen atoms together with such intense force that their nuclei overcome their normal inclination to repel each other." And all we need to do it is a mass of hydrogen the size of the sun.
- perilunar 8y ago> And all we need to do it is a mass of hydrogen the size of the sun. Done. Now we just need to set up lots of panels to collect the energy.