6 ms·
It is unfortunate that Dyson neglects the role of Oliver Heaviside, again. This is in a long tradition of English neglect, ultimately traceable to Heaviside's s
by ncmncm 8y ago
It is unfortunate that Dyson neglects the role of Oliver Heaviside, again. This is in a long tradition of English neglect, ultimately traceable to Heaviside's status as a commoner. Heaviside invented the mathematical tools we still use to understand and teach Maxwell, and most of the important consequences of the theory, but Pupin, Hertz, Marconi, and deForest used his methods and <del>took</del> got the credit.
Today Heaviside's method is taught as Laplace transforms, with Heaviside's name scrubbed off. We only hear of him as an alternative name for the step function, the integral of the Dirac impulse function, and of the "Heaviside layer", the ionosphere that makes transcontinental radio actually possible, but we would have waited decades longer without him.
An excellent reference for the importance of Heaviside in the ultimate success of application if Maxwell's theory is Paul J. Nahin,
"Oliver Heaviside: The Life, Work, and Times of an Electrical Genius of the Victorian Age", https://www.amazon.com/Oliver-Heaviside-Electrical-Genius-Victorian/dp/0801869099/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1546801611&sr=8-1&pi=AC_SX236_SY340_QL65&keywords=nahin+heaviside https://www.amazon.com/Oliver-Heaviside-Electrical-Genius-Vi...
- tntn 8y agoI'll second that book recommendation. It's incredible that you can ask a graduating class of EEs if they know of heaviside and only get some mumbling about a step function, given that Heaviside developed the majority of the fundamental ideas still used in EE. Complex impedance, vector calculus, Maxwell's equations, telegrapher's equations, precursors of s-domain methods, inductive loading, many of the names for AC circuit concepts. I think Hertz acknowledged Heaviside's contributions, though, and didn't intentionally take credit for his work. I could be confused, though.
- ncmncm 8y agoIt was deForest, particularly, who pretended to originality. I should have written "got".
- iorrus 8y agoExactly, one of the main reasons why maxwell is so hard to understand is that everything is expressed using quarternions unlike Heaviside who expressed the equations using the vector notation we see them expressed in today. In reality ‘Maxwell’s’ equations are in fact Heaviside’s.
- ncmncm 8y agoWe should not neglect Josiah Willard Gibbs's notational contribution, either. We otherwise hear of Gibbs mainly when we mention Gibbs free energy.
- srean 8y agoGibbs free energy and the entire body of literature on classical statistical thermodynamics. That alone would have been a enviable legacy to leave behind.
- segfaultbuserr 8y agoMy realization about Gibbs's contributions was reading an article about Fourier analysis in electronics, the article said when you approximate a square wave by using a series of sine waves, there will be overshoots at the edges, and this problem is called "Gibbs phenomenon". What, "Gibbs"? Wasn't he the physicist working on the physics behind chemical reactions? So he did some applied mathematics, too? It shouldn't be the same person, is it? Then I've read his Wikipedia article... And ironically, Gibbs phenomenon was initially discovered by an unnamed mathematician Henry Wilbraham in 1848, not Gibbs, but his paper was ignored and forgotten, like many other important ones in the history of science...
- jacobolus 8y agoArguably the reason that generations of STEM students have been horribly confused about 3-dimensional vectors and rotations (including electric/magnetic fields), etc. is that they were reframed in the confused and non-generalizable Gibbs/Heaviside language, instead of in Grassmann/Clifford’s formalism in which vectors and bivectors can be properly described as separate types of objects. It can be so much nicer. http://geocalc.clas.asu.edu/pdf/OerstedMedalLecture.pdf http://geocalc.clas.asu.edu/pdf/OerstedMedalLecture.pdf
- iorrus 8y agoWow Thanks for that... fascinating.
- 8y ago
- aaachilless 8y agoOne of my maths professors was a humorous guy and in his lectures would, as an ongoing joke, only explicitly credit Heaviside and Hungarians.
- beautifulfreak 8y agoMy thoughts exactly. Heaviside gets a chapter in the book, Strange Brains and Genius, which reveals some of the odder things about him: https://www.amazon.com/Strange-Brains-Genius-Eccentric-Scientists/dp/0688168949 https://www.amazon.com/Strange-Brains-Genius-Eccentric-Scien...
- ducktective 8y agoIn university in eng.math, diff.eq, electromagnetism and signals and systems courses, we had a "Heaviside Method" (with this exact name) in deriving the numerator coefficients in partial fraction expansion process of yielding time-domain equivalents of s-domain functions. I specifically remember my professor saying that this method is ascribed to "Heaviside" so much so that I later googled him and read his Wikipedia entry.
- adrianratnapala 8y ago> This is in a long tradition of English neglect, ultimately traceable to Heaviside's status as a commoner This is unfair on the English. Glancing at their wikipedia entries, Heavyside doesn't seem any more common than [Dirac][1] or [Faraday][2]. If I had to guess at a sociological reason why Heavyside got ignored, it's that he got caught in the transition when people started learning engineering through universities rather than apprenticeships. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Dirac#Early_years https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Dirac#Early_years [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Faraday#Early_life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Faraday#Early_life Heavyside's uncle Charles Wheatstone was a tradie who never went to unversity, but got knighted for services to electrical engineering. Faraday was another tradie who joined the Royal Society eight years before he got an (honorary) university degree. But in a later age Dirac became a world famous scientist, but would probably have gone nowhere if he hadn't got a scholarship to study electrical engineering at a university. We can't wag our finger at Victorian English society for a the sin of credentialism when our own society does it much more vigorously. It's especially for our own profession, as programming is much more a craft than a thing you can learn at university.
- eng101 8y ago*Heaviside