12 ms·
To be fair speed bumps to slow a car to 35mph seems like slightly the wrong tool. Also why does a text based website require a loading animation???
by benj111 8y ago
To be fair speed bumps to slow a car to 35mph seems like slightly the wrong tool.
Also why does a text based website require a loading animation???
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago> To be fair speed bumps to slow a car to 35mph seems like slightly the wrong tool What alternative would you suggest? As a parent of kids who cross the street to get to school, in my fantasy world, speed limits in school zones are enforced by impounding the offenders' cars.
- benj111 8y agoWell I would be aiming for a lower speed for outside a school, and I also wouldn't want to drive over a speed bump at 35mph. If the aim is to lower to speed to 35mph, speed cameras? In my fantasy world school drop off points would be 10 minutes walk from the school. But impounding sounds good too :)
- tom_ 8y ago35mph is presumably the upper limit, not the lower one. Perhaps the goal is to make cars go even slower than that when going over the crossing.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>35mph is presumably the upper limit Yeah. I'd wager that they will not be pleased when they catch some teenager catching air in his shitbox at 34.9mph.
- skywhopper 8y agoWhy can't this be one of many tools in designing the environment to accommodate multiple road users? And isn't it better to design the road to encourage safe driving rather than designing a system designed solely to punish users who do something against the rules?
- village-idiot 8y ago> I also wouldn't want to drive over a speed bump at 35m ... yes, that’s the point.
- benj111 8y agoI get that. What if they put speed bumps on the motorway/freeway, to slow everyone down for roadworks? FTA "and was built to slow cars to 35 miles per hour" Yes use speed bumps to slow people to 20mph, not 35mph.
- village-idiot 8y agoYour argument seems to center around you conflating various traffic calming measures. If you look at the pictures in the article you will see that they are depicting a speed table, not a speed bump. Speed tables are longer and gentler than a speed bump, and designed to slow the vehicles down less than a speed bump or speed hump. I agree that 35mph is a bit high for most speed tables, but 30mph would not be out of place for such a device. Obviously hitting a speed bump at 35mph would be a very bad experience, but that's a different device than what's represented in the article.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>What alternative would you suggest? Roads that are not straight, wide and well marked cause drivers to slow down naturally. Bushes trees and other landscaping can be used to make the road seem narrow which also makes people slow down. Having a good S-curve before the slow area works well too and many rural towns do this. For a school zone you should probably stick a traffic light at the school entrance since that will allow you to create a traffic clusterfuck in order to slow traffic for the hours when you want it slow and not reduce the capacity of the road the rest of the time. Turning it into a 4-way stop would probably work well since people approach those slowly since they have to stop anyway.
- FiveSquared25 8y agoAnd also reduce bushes and lawns, they obstruct. And overly tall trees.
- walshemj 8y agoIn the UK 90% of the traffic near schools and start and end times are parents driving there kids to school
- a11595 8y agoAs a $12k/year property tax payer who has no kids, in my fantasy world kids would not be allowed on the street or in front of my house. This would be enforced by impounding the children of parents who don't teach then to blindly run out into the street w/o checking for cars. This way the speed limit on my street could be raised from 30mph to 45, reduce traffic, and save time for thousands of people traversing that street in their cars every month trying to get to work.
- ricardobeat 8y agoThe cars should already be driving below 35mph since that's the road's speed limit. These raised crosswalks are a very common sight in Europe, they help drivers be more attentive to their interaction with pedestrains. Once they are more common (and people follow the speed limits) it becomes a natural element in driving, though still a bit annoying.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoIf the overwhelming majority of drivers want to drive more than 35mph on the road than slapping a 35 or below sign on it is not going to have any meaningful effect unless you back it up with the kind of strict law enforcement that is incompatible with American ideals. Edit: And as I said in the my other comment, if you want people to go slow you need road features that will make them want to go slow on their own. Speed bumps are far more of an insulting road feature than bushes or something to make the road feel narrow because they basically say "this road is capable of X but we're going to make you go Y and you can't do anything about it" which is why people are complaining. If you want people to go slow toss in a raised median and raised curbs to make the road feel narrow.
- skywhopper 8y agoYeah, that's what traffic calming measures such as raised crosswalks are for...
- arthurdenture 8y agoNo, if the majority of drivers want to drive faster than 35mph, the road is badly designed. It needs traffic calming devices, such as narrower lanes, curb extensions, and, yes, raised crosswalks. Enforcement (including automated enforcement) is a useful tool, but the start should be designing the road so that drivers naturally go at a safe speed.
- derefr 8y agoNo, but that's why we're not talking about a sign, but a raised crosswalk (i.e. a speedbump.) If you're going over 35mph, your car will scrape against it and possibly catch air off it, and you'll quite quickly regret going over 35mph and probably not do it again on that stretch of road.
- skywhopper 8y agoCurious what you think the right tool is? Raised crosswalks can solve problems beyond just traffic calming: if they are lifted to sidewalk level they make wheelchair access much easier and safer; they also lift pedestrians higher in the air to make them easier for drivers to see.
- runarberg 8y agoReally I think raised crosswalks are the only time a speed bump is properly used. A free standing speed bump (without a crosswalk) is sort of useless since drivers like to speed up between them, and slow down only just before they hit the bump. But a raised crosswalk really does magic in increasing the proportion of drivers that actually stop for crossing pedestrians.
- walshemj 8y agoWhy not have traffic lights with cameras to catch offenders