5 ms·
There absolutely is. The individual is not advocating that the group pay more collectively. He is advocating that others be forced to pay more. There is a cl
by zepto 8y ago
There absolutely is. The individual is not advocating that the group pay more collectively. He is advocating that others be forced to pay more.
There is a clear distinction.
If this individual was advocating for people in his position to pay more, he could simply start a campaign for like-minded millionaires to pay more, and perhaps build some infrastructure to support this voluntary donation to the government.
- lordnacho 8y ago> If this individual was advocating for people in his position to pay more, he could simply start a campaign for like-minded millionaires to pay more That is actually what he's doing, the whole point of the article.
- zepto 8y agoDid you actually read my whole comment, or did you quote that out of context intentionally? He is not campaigning for like-minded millionaires to pay more voluntarily, he is campaigning for them to force other millionaires to pay more through the tax code. You can clearly see that’s what I meant if you hadn’t just quoted out of context, so I question whether your comment is in good faith.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lordnacho 8y ago> You can clearly see that’s what I meant if you hadn’t just quoted out of context, so I question whether your comment is in good faith. Take a chill pill. It's not clear that's what you meant, I think many people will agree. It's the internet after all. That doesn't mean we have to be accusing each other of bad faith immediately.
- zepto 8y agoSo why didn’t you include the second half of the sentence which reads: “and perhaps build some infrastructure to support this voluntary donation to the government.”? That makes it abundantly clear that I was talking about a voluntary scheme because that is plainly stated, and it seems like you saw the sentence because you chose to quote the first half. The first paragraph also makes that same distinction. If you had quoted the full sentence instead of the partial one, your comment would simply be false. I didn’t accuse you of bad faith but I did raise the question, and this is why.
- lordnacho 8y agoThe second half of the sentence can sound quite sarcastic. Depends on how you read it. Like I said, it's the internet. I'll admit I didn't think too much about what you might have meant. Think about it, why would the government need anyone's help to collect money? And in what sense would it be voluntary? The taxpayers are either forced to by law or by social pressure to pay. Anyway, let's put that to bed.
- zepto 8y agoOk - i’ll accept that you didn’t think about what I meant when you replied rather than acting in bad faith. It seems odd to me that you don’t seem to make a distinction between government power and social pressure. A key principle of the legal systems of the US and tbe UK and many other western democracies is limit the use of force to the government precisely so that confirming to social pressure is voluntary and not forced. Forcing people to do things is reserved to the government. I realize this is not the case in many regressive regimes or weaker states, but the author is writing for a British publication about the US tax code.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> build some infrastructure to support this voluntary donation to the government. He is not asking for infrastructure to support voluntary donation tobthe government. That would be stupid and ineffective. He is asking for the government to change its tax structure to tax people like him more.
- zepto 8y agoI’m glad you can tell that’s not what he’s asking for. I agree with you - he’s not asking for that. How do you know if it would be stupid and ineffective? Perhaps he’s representative of rich people who want to pay more tax.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThen why are you suggesting he do something that he is not advocating?
- zepto 8y agoWhere did I suggest he do that?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> How do you know if it would be stupid and ineffective? Because you can already pay more taxes than required in many places, and (almost) nobody does so. > Perhaps he’s representative of rich people who want to pay more tax. He is representative — he doesn't pay more than is required. He is proposing that the government require people like him to pay more taxes, which would mean that low income people pay less.
- zepto 8y ago> Because you can already pay more taxes than required, and nobody does so. There are lots of things people can do but don’t until a social movement encourages them to do so. Charities for example don’t receive donations until someone makes a case for why they should. Also, I’m not sure why you think that raising taxes on one group automatically results in other groups being taxed less. That isn’t typically how it works.