5 ms·
If this millionaire is not creating jobs, are they not free to pay more taxes than the government sets as minimum to pay? Go ahead, donate it, make it more use
by mc32 8y ago
If this millionaire is not creating jobs, are they not free to pay more taxes than the government sets as minimum to pay?
Go ahead, donate it, make it more useful. Don't let the minimum stop you.
I suppose they prefer the government decide where it should be spent. Why not donate to the gov program they prefer themselves? Or Donate to the efficient programs, or donate to the one with ornery staff, if you like. No one will stop them.
- thomasmeeks 8y agoThey do prefer that, yes.
- Retric 8y agoThey want to donate to the general public not the government.
- mc32 8y agoWhat? How does one donate to the general public via tax receipts?
- Retric 8y agoIf pay more in taxes then you end up paying less. If nothing else the government needs to borrow less money and thus pay less interest. Right now every year on average American taxpayer pays an extra ~3,000$ in taxes covering interest. Changing the tax code is about who plays, it has ~zero impact on how much the government spends.
- bobbygoodlatte 8y agoThis particular straw man argument comes up every time taxes are discussed. Obviously the marginal effect of one person paying more in taxes is close to zero. There's no hypocrisy in advocating the group pay more collectively without unilaterally taking it upon oneself first.
- mc32 8y agoIt begins with _I’m a millionaire..._ Not we’re millionaires... or Millionaires should pay more... because otherwise they’d be imposing their personalpreferences and beliefs upon others whom they don’t represent.
- skh 8y agoI try to impose my personal preferences and beliefs on others whenever I vote. I see nothing wrong with this. I also believe that people in my income bracket should pay more in taxes. I'm not going to voluntarily pay more whilst others don't. It's an aspect of the free rider problem. I'll continue to vote for higher taxes and continue to take advantage of the stupid tax system we have. Perhaps this makes me a hypocrite. So what? The belief that taxes should be higher for people like me is true/false independent of my hypocrisy.
- zepto 8y agoThere absolutely is. The individual is not advocating that the group pay more collectively. He is advocating that others be forced to pay more. There is a clear distinction. If this individual was advocating for people in his position to pay more, he could simply start a campaign for like-minded millionaires to pay more, and perhaps build some infrastructure to support this voluntary donation to the government.
- lordnacho 8y ago> If this individual was advocating for people in his position to pay more, he could simply start a campaign for like-minded millionaires to pay more That is actually what he's doing, the whole point of the article.
- zepto 8y agoDid you actually read my whole comment, or did you quote that out of context intentionally? He is not campaigning for like-minded millionaires to pay more voluntarily, he is campaigning for them to force other millionaires to pay more through the tax code. You can clearly see that’s what I meant if you hadn’t just quoted out of context, so I question whether your comment is in good faith.
- petermcneeley 8y agoFor the same reason why there is environmental regulation not just individual ethical choices of companies; Game theory. If those that make the "right" choices bear the burden of those that make the "wrong" choices then this cost will accumulate and produce a power difference. If you already know this then why ask the question? If you dont then I can recommend you study some games https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_games_in_game_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_games_in_game_theory
- wongarsu 8y agoI don't think "I have too much money, take it away" is the right way to look at it. It's more about "the government needs $X to do what we tasked it with doing, isn't it unfair that I pay a smaller share than you"
- lwhalen 8y agoAny individual or corporation is free to donate directly to the US General Fund, which is where the vast majority of tax revenue goes: https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/resources/faq/faq_publicdebt.htm#DebtFinance https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/resources/faq/faq_public... In the meantime, I need as much of the money that _I earned_ as the gov't will deign to let me keep. Why? None of your damn business, that's why. I earned it, let me save or spend it as I please, without even more of gov't sticky-fingers rooting around in my damn pie.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vkou 8y agoSo, when a poor person complains that the taxes on the rich are too low, they can be criticised for being a jealous loser, and when a rich person does it, they are a hypocrite? Who exactly is allowed to advocate for higher taxes on the rich?