7 ms·
Drivers Complain Raised Crosswalk Slows Vehicles
- jay_kyburz 8y agoI don't think its unreasonable to mark them a little clearer, they are painted red on the road here in my suburb. https://www.google.com/maps/@-35.3193446,149.0814324,3a,75y,180.36h,90.46t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1ssK2ZQhQCiYdcBqor2TGF_w!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@-35.3193446,149.0814324,3a,75y,...
- runarberg 8y agoThis one in Reykjavík does wonders. I hardly ever have a car not stopping when I try to cross there. https://www.google.com/maps/@64.1493811,-21.9324505,3a,75y,231.32h,72.98t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s0RLratVHg6IZxIMnev2uYQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@64.1493811,-21.9324505,3a,75y,2...
- Bud 8y agoVery nice design there. Elegant.
- walshemj 8y agoAt zebra crossings pedestrians have right of way by law so I would hopes so.
- FiveSquared25 8y agoAlso adjust the sidewalk to make a bigger contrast (ie paint them blue or something like that)?
- strstr 8y agoThe law is messier than you would think. At least in WA (where I live) if a pedestrian steps out when it would be unreasonable to expect the car to be capable of stopping (e.g. you step out a foot in front of a car that is going the speed limit and you weren’t visible) the driver is not responsible.
- aasasd 8y agoIf I saw that for the first time while driving, I would probably think it best to find another way altogether.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stefan_ 8y agoIf you can't see a raised crosswalk, how can you claim to see someone wanting to cross the crosswalk? It's absurd.
- darkerside 8y agoDid you watch the video? They're actually quite difficult to see
- oth001 8y agoEven so, driving over these at 35mph is damaging to a vehicle.
- benj111 8y agoTo be fair speed bumps to slow a car to 35mph seems like slightly the wrong tool. Also why does a text based website require a loading animation???
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago> To be fair speed bumps to slow a car to 35mph seems like slightly the wrong tool What alternative would you suggest? As a parent of kids who cross the street to get to school, in my fantasy world, speed limits in school zones are enforced by impounding the offenders' cars.
- benj111 8y agoWell I would be aiming for a lower speed for outside a school, and I also wouldn't want to drive over a speed bump at 35mph. If the aim is to lower to speed to 35mph, speed cameras? In my fantasy world school drop off points would be 10 minutes walk from the school. But impounding sounds good too :)
- tom_ 8y ago35mph is presumably the upper limit, not the lower one. Perhaps the goal is to make cars go even slower than that when going over the crossing.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>35mph is presumably the upper limit Yeah. I'd wager that they will not be pleased when they catch some teenager catching air in his shitbox at 34.9mph.
- skywhopper 8y agoWhy can't this be one of many tools in designing the environment to accommodate multiple road users? And isn't it better to design the road to encourage safe driving rather than designing a system designed solely to punish users who do something against the rules?
- userbinator 8y agoFor a second I was confused because I thought "raised" referred to one of these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedestrian_separation_structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedestrian_separation_structur... Those are much safer, but unfortunately also much more expensive.
- skywhopper 8y agoI'd be curious about the safety idea, given that most such pedestrian overpasses involve a couple of stories of stairs on either side. Their real purpose is to allow auto traffic full ownership of the intersection.
- userbinator 8y agoI've seen ones which have a spiral ramp, not stairs.
- ape4 8y agoSafer but because its trouble to use, not all pedestrians will take it.
- mc32 8y agoI wish they had more of those at busy pedestrian-auto intersections like busy train stations, etc., so that peds could cross at any time rather than having to wait for a light. A nice kitty-corner to kitty-corner X above an intersection. I think a compromise could be have these but not require ADA if the street level crosswalk is ADA compliant. Otherwise these get prohibitively expensive and don't get deployed at all.
- baylisscg 8y agoAt a train station where you're raising pedestrians to get over the tracks already it'd be less difficult to integrate.
- walshemj 8y agoThe complaint is damaging vehicles - years ago at college one of the guys on my course trashed his classic MGB's exhaust driving at 5ph in the college car park and sued them to recover the quite large cost.
- village-idiot 8y ago5mph is obviously too slow, indicating that perhaps that speed bump was poorly designed. But practically it is impossible to design something that forces cars to slow down without risking vehicular damage. Speed bumps, speed tables, and chicanes all carry the risk of serious consequences should the driver not slow down. Without those consequences some drivers can and would ignore them. Also worth pointing out that the point of these obstacles is to protect pedestrians. Given the extreme lopsided nature of vehicle to pedestrian crashes, I believe that some risk of vehicular damage is a fair trade to prevent pedestrian fatalities.
- myspy 8y agoEvery driver that complains when going too fast and damaging his car on such a speed reducer should loose his license for a couple of weeks to get a clear head again. How bad people are driving is kind of a mirror of the current society. I‘m annoyed by people thinking the world belongs only to them. No buddy, other people have the same rights.
- strstr 8y agoThat’s a lot of vitriol. Based on the photos of the cross walk it looks like it isn’t clearly labelled. There’s 3 signs you have to read in order to know what is going on. There should be a sign giving drivers an estimate of the appropriate speed, or something similar.
- darkerside 8y agoDid you watch the video? The raised-ness of the crosswalk is practically invisible. This wouldn't be news if it weren't confusing the shit out of all the locals. When's the last time you saw a damn speed bump in the local paper headlines?! Maybe instead of assuming other people are idiots, just accept that people are people. There's probably a better solution here.
- benatkin 8y agoGoing over a speed bump at even 15 miles per hour is a minor annoyance, whether you're a driver or a passenger. I'm not surprised people are complaining about them. Flashing lights make me feel safer as a pedestrian and are less annoying to me as a driver. I don't know how well they actually work, though.
- sbov 8y agoIf you don't want people going 35mph down the street, maybe the speed limit shouldn't be 35mph. Edit: I hate vague traffic signs. "Reduce speed". Ok, I was going 30, now I'm going 20. Is that good enough?
- strstr 8y agoSpeed limits are pretty ineffective at reducing speed, although they are good at communicating expectations (which is one the issue here). Iirc the green book recommends road narrowing for slowing down drivers.
- loup-vaillant 8y agoWhere I live we have a standard sign next to speed bumps: https://www.direct-signaletique.com/I-Grande-14093-panneau-ralentisseur-de-type-dos-d-ane-c27.net.jpg https://www.direct-signaletique.com/I-Grande-14093-panneau-r... There, no more problem. From what the reporter said though, it looks like the US doesn't have such a standard sign yet…
- runarberg 8y agoThe sign design in the USA is weird. They really don’t like symbols, and prefer to spell things out with weird abbreviations. Instead of an obvious sign like that, you would get a diamond shaped yellow sign with saying “SPEED BUMB” and instead of a standard crosswalk sign you would get the same yellow diamond saying “PED X-ING”, and it is by no means consistent what they actually say. The USA could really use some sign design revision.
- ephimetheus 8y agoI mean, as long as the car doesn’t bottom out when you’re at the speed limit, this is perfectly fine. I live in France, here there are speed bumps where you practically have to stop in order not to ruin your car, even though the speed limit is 30 or higher... that is annoying.